This might be my all-time favorite GMAT quant question, mostly because A) I totally flubbed it on my practice test and B) I learn something new every time I come back to it.
If you miss the clever bit of algebra that the remaining height of each candle can be modeled as [Original Height] - [Original Height]*[Work Done On the Candle By the Flame], which comes out to H-H(x/t) and H-H(x/2t) for Candles A and B, respectively, then this problem can be really confusing to solve.
You can get a good intuitive sense of the relationship by plotting the height of the candles as a function of time on an X-Y graph, but it still doesn't jump out at you when the height of Candle B must be twice the height of Candle A.
However, you can actually solve this question in about two minutes by picking a "smart denominator" for the variable "t," and then numerically checking the answer choices. I have quite slow arithmetic skills, but even I solved it in about 2:10 minutes.
- Let T=10 minutes (to make fractions easier). In that case, Candle A burns down all the way in 10 minutes; Candle B burns down all the way in 20 minutes.
- In 5 minutes, Candle A has 1/2 height remaining, Candle B has 3/4 remaining. Candle B is less than twice Candle A. Not the answer.
- In 8 minutes, Candle A has 1/5 height remaining; Candle B has 3/5 remaining. Candle B is more than twice Candle A. Not the answer, but you're honing in!
Obviously, 5/10 = 1/2 and 8/10 = 4/5, so you know the final answer must be between those ratios. It's either Answer C or D. Let's try T=7 minutes, which will split the two.
- In 7 minutes, Candle A has 3/10 height remaining; Candle B has 13/20 remaining. Candle B is barely more than twice Candle A. So the answer must be barely less than 7/10 and greater than 5/10, and the only answer in that interval is .... ANSWER C: 2/3
(Granted, the algebraic way is definitely better, but this a more intuitive brute-force approach if you don't "see" the algebraic relationship between height of the candles and work done.)