Despite being more complicated than four-handed canasta, the

Question

Despite being more complicated than four-handed canasta, the more challenging strategy of three-handed canasta makes it more popular with experienced card players than the other versions of the game.

(A) the more challenging strategy of three-handed canasta makes it more popular with experienced card players than

(B) three-handed canasta has a more challenging strategy that makes it more popular with experienced card players than

(C) the more challenging strategy of three-handed canasta makes it the more popular with experienced card players than with

(D) three-handed canasta's more challenging strategy makes it the more popular with experienced card players than with

(E) three-handed canasta has a more challenging strategy making it more popular with experienced card players than with

Explanation: https://gmatclub.com/forum/despite-being ... l#p1227698

Zarrolou · Accepted Answer

Who is more complicated than than four-handed canasta? What should this clause modify?
Not the strategy but the game "three-handed canasta" itself. Out A, C and D

We're left with:

(B) three-handed canasta has a more challenging strategy  that  makes it more popular with experienced card players than
(E) three-handed canasta has a more challenging strategy  making  it more popular with experienced card players than  with

The red parts are errors. "a more challenging strategy  making  " is wrong, and " with " is also wrong.

Let me rephrase E: "(E) three-handed canasta has a more challenging strategy making it more popular with experienced card players than with the other versions of the game"
This says that 3-handed canasta is more popular with exprerienced players than with the other version... does not make sense.

B has the right contrapposition: the 3-handed canasta (a game) is more popular with exp players than (another game) the other version.
 IMO B

fameatop · Answer

1. Despite being more complicated than four-handed canasta,  the more challenging strategy of three-handed canasta makes it more popular with experienced card players than  the other versions of the game.
(A) the  more challenging strategy  of three-handed canasta makes it more popular with experienced card players than-  
Author intends to make comparison between two types of canasta (3 & 4 handed). Placement of STRATEGY after comma makes incorrect comparison. Thus INCORRECT 
(B) three-handed canasta has a more challenging strategy that makes it more popular with experienced card players than 
-  Removes both the errors. CORRECT 
(C) the  more challenging strategy  of three-handed canasta makes it the more popular with experienced card players than  with 
 Author intends to make comparison between two types of canasta (3 & 4 handed). Placement of STRATEGY after comma makes incorrect comparison. Using WITH introduces error as it forces WRONG comparison between experienced players & other games rather than between Canasta & other games. Thus INCORRECT 
(D) three-handed canasta's  more challenging strategy  makes it the more popular with experienced card players than  with 
- Same error as in C 
(E) three-handed canasta has a more challenging strategy making it more popular with experienced card players than  with - 
  Using WITH introduces error as it forces WRONG comparison between experienced players & other games rather than between Canasta & other games. Thus INCORRECT

ankurgupta03 · Answer

1. Despite being more complicated than four-handed canasta,  the more challenging strategy of three-handed canasta makes it more popular with experienced card players than  the other versions of the game.

(A) the more challenging strategy of three-handed canasta makes it more popular with experienced card players than
 strategy is compared with four handed canasta 
(B) three-handed canasta has a more challenging strategy that makes it more popular with experienced card players than
 Correct 
(C) the more challenging strategy of three-handed canasta makes it the more popular with experienced card players than with
 strategy is compared with four handed canasta 
(D) three-handed canasta's more challenging strategy makes it the more popular with experienced card players than with
 strategy is compared with four handed canasta 
(E) three-handed canasta has a more challenging strategy making it more popular with experienced card players than with
 experienced players are compared with other versions of the game

Narenn · Answer

Question 1
 Answer Should be B

A) The Modifier despite  being…….four-handed canasta  should immediately be followed by the noun it modifies i.e.  three-handed canasta.

B) Correct choice

C) The Modifier  despite being…….four-handed canasta  should immediately be followed by the noun it modifies i.e.  three-handed canasta.  
This choice also differ from question's intended meaning. Intended meaning is  The given strategy makes the three handed canasta more popular than other versions of the game with experienced players.  While This choice implies that  the given strategy makes three-handed canasta more popular with experienced players than with other version of game.

D) Repeats all the mistakes made in choice C

E) Does not imply intended meaning.

Narenn

doe007 · Answer

Explanation:

Concepts tested: Parallelism, Comparison

First thing to note is that sentence starts with “despite”; so there must be two parallel actions or events or nouns associated with “despite”. The comparison is made with “four-handed canasta”, so the part after comma must start with something parallel to “four-handed canasta”.

The sentence has a second comparison where popularity of three-handed canasta should be compared with that of other versions of the game.

A) “Four-handed canasta” is illogically compared with “more challenging strategy”. Wrong.
B)  Correct . Sentence has proper parallelism and comparison.
C) “Four-handed canasta” is incorrectly compared with the possessive noun “three-handed canasta's”. Wrong.
D) “Four-handed canasta” is illogically compared with “more challenging strategy”. Wrong.
E) “It” has no antecedent in the structure “THC making it …”. In the “more … than” structure, “experienced card players” is illogically compared with “other versions of the game”. Wrong.

Correct Answer is B.

avohden · Answer

Here is the   Official Explanation   from Kaplan.

The opening phrase of this sentence must modify the noun that directly follows it, but the comparative than four-handed canasta makes it clear that three-handed canasta, not the strategy, must follow the comma. Eliminate (A) and (C). Choice (D) can also be eliminated because three-handed canasta's is a possessive form, which acts more like an adjective than a noun and therefore, is not modified by the opening phrase.

There is a second comparison in this sentence—it (three-handed canasta) is more popular than what? To make the comparison work, the noun following than must be parallel to it. i.e. other versions of the game. Thus, than with in choice (E) is incorrect. The correct answer is choice (B), which fixes the modification problem and introduces no other problems.

Hope it helps

Skag55 · Answer

But B feels like we are comparing the "more complicated canasta" with the "more challenging strategy", no?

daboo343 · Answer

Official Explanation
Read the Original Sentence Carefully, Looking for Errors:

The opening phrase of this sentence must modify the noun that directly follows it. The comparative "than four-handed canasta" makes it clear that three-handed canasta, not the strategy, must follow the comma.

Scan and Group the Answer Choices:

(A) and (C) begin with "the more challenging strategy," (B) and (E) begin with "three-handed canasta," and (D) begins with "three-handed canasta's more challenging strategy." Use this 2-2-1 split to begin eliminating choices.

Eliminate Wrong Answer Choices:

Eliminate (A), (C), and (D). They all compare "four-handed canasta" to "strategy." (D) might have been a contender, but its use of the possessive "three-handed canasta's" effectively makes canasta into an adjective, not a noun, and four-handed canasta is being compared to a "more challenging strategy."

(B) and (E) both begin with the correct "three-handed canasta." However, (E) doesn't fit correctly into the original sentence. "... than with" at the end of (E) sets up an incorrect comparison between the "card players" and the "other versions of the game."

(B) is the only remaining choice, and it is correct.

TAKEAWAY: Make sure comparisons are logical: you can compare apples to oranges, or apple trees to orange trees, but not apples to orange trees.

gmatFalcon · Answer

Despite being more complicated than four-handed canasta,  the more challenging strategy of three-handed canasta makes it more popular with experienced card players than  the other versions of the game.

A. the more challenging strategy of three-handed canasta makes it more popular with experienced card players than
B. three-handed canasta has a more challenging strategy, which makes it more popular with experienced card players than
C. the more challenging strategy of three-handed canasta makes it the more popular with experienced card players than with
D. three-handed canasta's more challenging strategy makes it the more popular with experienced card players than with
E. three-handed canasta has a more challenging strategy, making it more popular with experienced card players than with

bichthuy · Answer

A, C, D are wrong because four-handed canasta is illogically compared to strategy. 
E is wrong because the word “with” at the end of choice E makes illogical comparison between experienced card players and other versions of game. 
Answer B has no error.

Helium · Answer

Despite being more complicated than four-handed canasta, the more challenging strategy of three-handed canasta makes it more popular with experienced card players than the other versions of the game.

A) the more challenging strategy of three-handed canasta makes it more popular with experienced card players than
B) three-handed canasta has a more challenging strategy, which makes it more popular with experienced card players than
C) the more challenging strategy of three-handed canasta makes it the more popular with experienced card players than with
D)three-handed canasta's more challenging strategy makes it the more popular with experienced card players than with
E) three-handed canasta has a more challenging strategy, making it more popular with experienced card players than with

Had option E) be given as

E) three-handed canasta has a more challenging strategy, making it more popular with experienced card players than

will it be also a correct answer choice?

GMATNinja   souvik101990

Helium · Answer

The opening phrase of this sentence must modify the noun that directly follows it, but the comparative "than four-handed canasta" makes it clear that three-handed canasta, not the strategy, must follow the comma. Eliminate (A) and (C).

(A) and (C) begin with "the more challenging strategy," (B) and (E) begin with "three-handed canasta," and (D) begins with "three-handed canasta's more challenging strategy." Use this 2-2-1 split to begin eliminating choices.

Eliminate (A), (C), and (D). They all compare "four-handed canasta" to "strategy." (D) might have been a contender, but its use of the possessive "three-handed canasta's" effectively makes canasta into an adjective, not a noun, and four-handed canasta is being compared to a "more challenging strategy."

(B) and (E) both begin with the correct "three-handed canasta." However, (E) doesn't fit correctly into the original sentence. "... than with" at the end of (E) sets up an incorrect comparison between the "card players" and the "other versions of the game."

(B) is the only remaining choice, and it is correct

Posted from my mobile device

Kinshook · Answer

Despite being more complicated than four-handed canasta,  the more challenging strategy of three-handed canasta makes it more popular with experienced card players than  the other versions of the game.

(A)  the more challenging strategy  of three-handed canasta makes it more popular with experienced card players than
Incorrect comparison

(B) three-handed canasta has a more challenging strategy that makes it more popular with experienced card players than 
Correct

(C)  the more challenging strategy  of three-handed canasta makes it the more popular with experienced card players than with
Incorrect comparison

(D)  three-handed canasta's more challenging strategy  makes it the more popular with experienced card players than with
Incorrect comparison

(E) three-handed canasta has a more challenging strategy making it more popular with experienced card players than  with  
Use of "with" is incorrect

IMO B

VerbalBot · Answer

Hello from the GMAT Club VerbalBot!

Thanks to another GMAT Club member, I have just discovered this valuable topic, yet it had no discussion for over a year. I am now bumping it up - doing my job. I think you may find it valuable (esp those replies with Kudos).

Want to see all other topics I dig out? Follow me (click follow button on profile). You will receive a summary of all topics I bump in your profile area as well as via email.

Despite being more complicated than four-handed canasta, the

Prep Toolkit

Top 5 GMAT Debrief Videos

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards

GMAT Sentence Correction (SC - EA only) Questions

Despite being more complicated than four-handed canasta, the

Prep Toolkit

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards