tnshrm637
MartyMurray, I got the 6the question incorrect. I marked B as the correct answer. Can you please explain why A is the correct answer?
Thanks!
Tanu
Here's question 6:
6.The passage suggests that the Oneida delegates viewed the Canandaigua Treaty asScanning the passage for "the Canandaigua Treaty," we find the following:
The Oneida were then offered a one-time lump-sum payment of $60,000 in lieu of the $500 annuity guaranteed in perpetuity to each member of the tribe under the Canandaigua Treaty.
Also, further down in the passage is the following:
Finally, the offer of a lump-sum payment was unanimously opposed by the Oneida delegates, who saw that changing the terms of a treaty might jeopardize the many pending land claims based upon the treaty.
Here's (B).
(B) the source of many past problems for the Oneida tribeThe statements we've already found don't indicate that the treatywas "the source of many past problems." On the contrary, the second statement seems to indicate that the treaty was important to the tribe for what it supported, but we should check the passage to see whether there is some other information that supports this choice.
Reviewing the passage, we see that the third paragraph does mention some past problems. However, those problems, "taxation of Native American lands" and "Native Americans had been convinced by unscrupulous speculators to sell their lands," did not result from the existence treaty but rather resulted from other things. Also, the above second statement about the treaty follows the discussion of those past problems and indicates that the treaty, if anything, helps to prevent similar problems from occurring.
So, choice (B) is basically contrary to what the passage says about the treaty.
Now, let's see why (A) is correct:
(A) a valuable safeguard of certain Oneida rights and privilegesGiven what we've already discussed in considering choice (B), we see that the treaty did serve to safeguard Oneida rights and privileges, and taken as a whole, the discussion in the third paragraph of the treaty and how the Oneida responded to the proposal of changing the terms of the treaty indicate that the Oneida delegates considered the treaty "a valuable safeguard of certain Oneida rights and privileges."
So, (A) is supported by the passage.
Takeaway: The key to getting a question like this one correct and choosing a correct answer like (A) rather than an trap choice like (B) is to be very clear about what's said about what in the passage.
Choice (B) can be considered Nearby trap choice. A Nearby trap choice works by taking information in the passage close to mentions of the topic of the question, in this case, information about problems close to mentions of the treaty, to create a vibe of being supported by the passage even though it isn't really.