I would love if the comments appear like they do on facebook. One reply can have the quotes pertaining to it underneath and not form a new reply. I hope i expressed my thought effectively. Attaching a pic for reference

Thank you for the suggestion Hatakekakashi,

The FB approach to comments is a little tricky with forums - one is that many of our threads, such as this one is 25 pages long. What if someone comments on a post on page 20 for example? How would you be notified about it and how would you find where the latest post is/was? how would you see it?
_________________

Hello BB,

Considering the above scenario if someone comments on page 20, I personally feel that in only rare cases would someone find it useful. Why would I want to be notified about a comment on page 20 in the first place when all my interaction happens on page 24/25. The person who initially replies and whose reply is quoted will obviously be notified but considering a 25 page thread why should all the members in that thread be notified about it. A work around for this scenario, considering if the comment on page 20 is relevant to most people or at least to one person when a person visits the thread he/she can get notified about a new comment on page 20. Then it would be his/her wish to go ahead and see. For example I comment on 24 and 20 seems irrelevant i will do my things but if it makes sense and if i find the information useful I will go ahead and have a look at it. Regarding the notification, It can appear as "XYZ has replied to ABC comment and you could show the ABC comment as that would be the premise and if one feels it can be remotely relevant one can check else one can skip. I hope all of this makes sense bb

Regards,
HK

Yes, i understand the concept but this is not how the forum works or how it is built. For example, just one feature, forum posts are arranged based on the last reply. If there is a comment, and we don't bump the post, it is breaking that rule OR it will be subjecting someone to a painful search where the comment actually got posted (this leads to proliferation of SPAM, Trolls, and low quality posts)

Also, your point is that any comment on a page other than the current one is of no importance and not worth notifying others or making it visible..... I don't know that i agree.

In any case, forums are different from Blogs or Facebook - you never go back to a FB post or a Blog post really. They just die a quiet death. Forum threads, on the other hand, live for a very long time and preserve knowledge. It will be a LOT of effort to make the forum work like FB, it is not worth the effort ultimately.
_________________

Today I have found the following regarding KUDOS Details of other users:

1. I have access to see the deails of KUDOS of other users.
2. I can see who gave KUDOS as well as to whom the user gave KUDOS.
3. I have also found that I have the option to delete all of the KUDOS of other users.
4. I can't see all of the pages of KUDOS given by the user, though I can see all of the pages of KUDOS owned by the user.
5. There is no heading in the page of KUDOS owned by the user, though there is a heading like 'Kudos given to other GMAT Club members' in the page of KUDOS given by the user.

Therefore, I am curious to know the following:

1. Is it required to provide access to all users to view KUDOS details of other users?
2. Is it necessary to provide privilege to all users to delete hard earned KUDOS of other users?
3. Are all of the avove actually open to all or I have got this privilege as a moderator?

_________________

Anyone can see other's kudos. There is no reason to hide them.
Delete and Moderate features are available to you since you are a moderator.



_________________

Makes sense. Thanks for your perspective on the issue.

Regards,
HK

Oh.. great feature for moderator

However, points 4 & 5 may be fixed to polish this report.
_________________

Thank you. Correct. #4 and #5 are inconsistencies and perfections.


Sent from my iPhone using GMAT Club Forum
_________________

Suggestion - Make multiple notifications from the same topic as one notification.

I logged on to my GC account and saw three notifications. All i could see ( check attached pic for reference) was 3 people replying to the same thread and it was shown as new post. Instead of a new notification every time someone posts in a thread I think it would be better if all the three notifications could be clubbed as one and shown as you have 3 new/unread posts in the fuqua thread instead of 3 notifications with new post , new post , new post.

Regards,
HK

Cool!!! Reply Feature add to CHAT bb Thanks a lot

_________________

Thank you for the suggestion. We have been working on this for a little while now and hope to have it released within 30 days.
_________________

Thank you for noticing!
_________________

I look forward to the update

bb

Does it make sense to have 'sort by kudos' for a particular post be applicable to
all the pages? At present this feature is only applicable for the posts by experts/ members
commented on that particular page only?

Why it makes sense? For few older posts as this I can check best kudos explanations given by members in recent time.

_________________

adkikani - I am not sure i follow this question/request. Do you mean that it does not work on some of the pages of a multi-page discussion or ?
_________________

bb

Sir, I have seen users including myself ( once only ) arbitrary post questions here and there. Often Bunnel or Other moderators/admins have to post "Discussed in this forum..." like that. In this way, each and every question has got several discussion links, which are often retired or still active.

1. Could not we lock users posting here and there ? A drop down lists for all areas can be created when posting topics. Users can post only after selecting desired area.

In simple while posting , topic wise/ area wise selection should be there.

Pardon me if it is already implemented. I am an amateur player here.
_________________

Thank you for the suggestion. I think I understand your question. Let me know if not.

Right now You post a new topic within the forum you want it posted. We probably could change it and force everyone posting regardless of the forum to force them to choose a forum. This may force some of the offenders to start posting in the right place but will also require everyone else to choose the forum and have an extra step. We do have about 200 forums by the way, so selecting one from a drop down isn't a super fast and easy choice process.

We do have a moderator process for warning and eventually banning users who are frequent offenders rather than casual confused individuals.... there are a lot more offenses happening by the way, that we control and moderate - tagging, posting questions properly, underlining SC's, etc. Moderators do a lot of work!
_________________

bb



Presently the 'sort kudos' functions on the page user is in. For eg: in my earlier snap, the user is on page 1
so kudos on page 1 are arranged in increasing order, but what if post with highest no of kudos in on page 5?
but ideally the functionality should sort kudos in increasing order irrespective of page 1 to 6.

What is happening right now is - user has to click 'sort by kudos' first and then select each page manually.

Oh.... that's how how it is supposed to work. It is supposed to take all posts from the entire discussion and arrange them by Kudos.
It seems to work correctly in this discussion: https://gmatclub.com/forum/best-gmat-ma ... ml?kudos=1
You can see there is quite a spread of dates.

_________________