If a and b are nonzero integers, is a^b an integer?

Question

Competition Mode Question

If a and b are nonzero integers, is  a^b  an integer?

(1)  b^a  is negative
(2)  a^b  is negative

Are You Up For the Challenge: 700 Level Questions

GMATinsight · Answer

Question : is  a^b  an integer?

Statement 1 :  b^a  is negative

i.e. b is Negative and a is ODD integer

Case 1 :  3^{-1} = 1/3  i.e. NOT an integer
 Case 2 :  1^{-1} = 1  i.e. an integer

NOT SUFFICIENT

Statement 2 :  a^b  is negative

i.e. a is Negative and b is ODD integer
 Case 1 :  (-3)^{-1} = -1/3  i.e. NOT an integer
 Case 2 :  (-1)^{-1} = -1  i.e. an integer

NOT SUFFICIENT

Combining the two statements

i.e. a and b both are Negative and both are ODD integer
 Case 1 :  (-3)^{-1} = -1/3  i.e. NOT an integer
 Case 2 :  (-1)^{-1} = -1  i.e. an integer

NOT SUFFICIENT

Answer: Option E

QuantMadeEasy · Answer

When a and b are nonzero integers, consider following two cases for a^b:
Case 1: when b is positive integer, then a^b is integer
Case 2: when b is negative integer, then a^b is a fraction ie non-integer

To determine whether a^b is an integer or not, we only require sign of b without sign of a.
Hence, rephrasing the question as what is the sign of integer b?

(1) When b^a is negative only when b is negative integer. Sufficient

(2) When a^b is negative, a is negative integer, whereas b can be positive or negative integer. Insufficient

A is correct

Staphyk · Answer

If a and b are nonzero integers, is a^b an integer? 
Constraint: a and b ain’t zero
Asked : a^b = Integer ,Yes /No?

(1) b^a is negative 
b^a < 0 ,then  b must be negative  and  a must be odd 
.: when a = 1 ,b = -1
a^b = (1)^(-1) = 1 = Integer? Yep!
 when a= 3 ,b =-2
a^b= (3)^(-2) = 1/(3^2)= 0.111=Integer? Nope!
(Not sufficient)

(2) a^b is negative 
a^b < 0, then a must be negative and b must be odd.
But a^b can be negative Integer such as -1 or negative non-Integer such as -1/2
(Not sufficient)

(1+2)  We know a= odd and negative, b= odd and negative 
Still not sufficient to determine wether a^b =Integer/Non-Integer 
Eg -1^(-1) vs -3^(-1)
(Not sufficient)

Hit that  E

Posted from my mobile device

exc4libur · Answer

(1) b^a is negative   sufic

b^a<0 then b<0, and a=anything≠0.
a,b=1,-1: -1^1=-1 and 1^-1=integer
a,b=3,-2: -2^3=-1/8 and 3^-2=1/9≠integer

(2) a^b is negative   insufic

a^b<0 then a<0, and b=anything≠0.
a,b=3,2: -3^2=9=integer
a,b=3,-2: -3^-2=1/9≠integer

(1&2)   insufic

a<0 and b<0;
a,b=-1,-1: -1^-1=-1=integer
a,b=-2,-3: -2^-3=-1/8≠integer

Ans (E)

ostrick5465 · Answer

If a and b are nonzero integers, is a^b an integer?
Constraint: a and b ain’t zero
Asked : a^b = Integer ,Yes /No?

(1) b^a is negative
b^a < 0 ,then b must be negative and a must be odd
.: when a = 1 ,b = -1
a^b = (1)^(-1) = 1 = Integer? Yep!
when a= 3 ,b =-2
a^b= (3)^(-2) = 1/(3^2)= 0.111=Integer? Nope!
(Not sufficient)

(2) a^b is negative
a^b < 0, then a must be negative and b must be odd.
But a^b can be negative Integer such as -1 or negative non-Integer such as -1/2
(Not sufficient)

(1+2) We know a= odd and negative, b= odd and negative
Still not sufficient to determine wether a^b =Integer/Non-Integer
Eg -1^(-1) vs -3^(-1)
(Not sufficient)

Hit that E

Posted from my mobile device

unraveled · Answer

If a and b are nonzero integers, is a^b an integer?
Constraint: a and b ain’t zero
Asked : a^b = Integer ,Yes /No?

(1) b^a is negative
b^a < 0 ,then b must be negative and a must be odd
.: when a = 1 ,b = -1
a^b = (1)^(-1) = 1 = Integer? Yep!
when a= 3 ,b =-2
a^b= (3)^(-2) = 1/(3^2)= 0.111=Integer? Nope!
(Not sufficient)

(2) a^b is negative
a^b < 0, then a must be negative and b must be odd.
But a^b can be negative Integer such as -1 or negative non-Integer such as -1/2
(Not sufficient)

(1+2) We know a= odd and negative, b= odd and negative
Still not sufficient to determine wether a^b =Integer/Non-Integer
Eg -1^(-1) vs -3^(-1)
(Not sufficient)

Hit that E

Posted from my mobile device

eakabuah · Answer

Given that a and b are non-zero integers, we are to determine if a^b is an integer.

Statement 1: b^a is negative.
For b^a to be negative, then a must be odd and b must be a negative number. Let a=3 and b=-2
then b^a = -2^3 = -8.
a^b = 3^-2 = 1/9 No.
However when a=-1, and b=-3, then b^a = -3^-1 = -1/3
a^b = -1^-3 = -1. Yes.
Statement 1 is insufficient.

Statement 2: a^b is negative.
Statement 1 implies a is negative and b is odd.
when a =-1 and b=-3, a^b = -1 yes.
However when a=-2 and b=-3, then a^b = -2^-3 = -1/8, No.
Statement 2 is insufficient.

1+2
To satisfy both 1 and 2, we must have both a and b as odd negative values.
a=-1 and b=-3, a^b = -1^-3 = -1 and b^a = -3^-1 = -1/3. The answer is yes.
when a=b=-3, then a^b = b^a = -1/27. The answer is No.

Both statements even taken together are not sufficient.

The answer is E.

lacktutor · Answer

If a and b are nonzero integers, is a^{b} an integer? (Statement1): b^{a} is negative. --> b <0, a could be any odd integer. if b=-1 and a = 1, then a^{b}= 1^{-1}= 1 (yes) if b=-2 and a=3, then a^{b}= 3^{-2}= \frac{1}{9} (NO) Insufficient (Statement2): a^{b} is negative. --> a <0, b could be any odd integer. if a=-1 and b= 1, then a^{b}= (-1)^{1}= -1 (Yes) if a= -2 and b=-3, then a^{b}= (-2)^{-3}= -\frac{1}{8} (NO) Insufficient Taken together 1&2, a,b --any odd negative integers (a<0, b<0) if a=-1 and b=-1, then a^{b}= (-1)^{-1}= -1 (Yes) if a=-3 and b=-3, then a^{b}= (-3)^{-3}= -\frac{1}{27} (No) Insufficient The answer is E.

freedom128 · Answer

a and b are nonzero integers, is a^b an integer?

(1) b^a is negative
If a=-1 and b=-1, then b^a is negative and a^b is an integer
If a=-3 and b=-3, then b^a is negative but a^b is not an integer
NOT SUFFICIENT
 
(2) a^b is negative
If a=-1 and b=-1, then a^b is negative and a^b is an integer
If a=-3 and b=-3, then a^b is negative but a^b is not an integer
NOT SUFFICIENT

1)+2)
Using the same scenarios, it is still uncertain whether a^b is an integer.
NOT SUFFICIENT

FINAL ANSWER IS (E)

debjit1990 · Answer

Ans: E

a)b^a= -ve
(-1)^(-1)=-1(b=a=-1), so, a^b=-1 int yes
(-1)^(3)=-1 (b=-1,a=3), so, a^b=1/3 not int no
not sufficient

b)a^b=-ve
(-1)^(-1)=-1(a=b=-1) yes
(-3)^(-3)=-1/27(a=b=-3) No
not sufficient

taking both a & b
(-1)^(-1)=-1(a=b=-1) yes
(-3)^(-3)=-1/27(a=b=-3) No

Not possible

minustark · Answer

If a and b are nonzero integers, is a^b an integer?

(1)  b^a  is negative
(2)  a^b  is negative

For  a^b  to be an integer, b has to be positive. but if we can get to know whether a =1, the sign of b will not be a matter.

1) from this statement, we can deduce that b is negative and a is an odd integer. when a = 1, then   a^b   can be an integer, but for any other value of a,  a^b  is not an integer. insufficient.

2) a is negative and b is odd. no information about the sign of b. insufficient.

Together, a and b are both negative and odd. For any value of a except 1,  a^b  won't be an integer. but we don't know about the value of a. insufficient.

E is the answer.

Archit3110 · Answer

possible when a=1 and b = -3
and a = and b =-3

#1b^a is negative
yes /no insufficient
#2
a^b is negative
yes/no insufficient
nothing in common
IMO E

If a and b are nonzero integers, is a^b an integer?

(1) b^a is negative
(2) a^b is negative

Thekingmaker · Answer

This isn't very tough nut to crack if you commute all the different combination that validate let me show you:-
A b^a negative could be -1^1 accoedingly 1^-1 integer however {-1/2)^3 accordingly 3^-1/2 not an integer insuff 
B similarly we get it also as insuff even combined doesn't make the matter any better 
Therefore IMO E

bumpbot · Answer

Automated notice from GMAT Club BumpBot: 

A member just gave Kudos to this thread, showing it’s still useful. I’ve bumped it to the top so more people can benefit. Feel free to add your own questions or solutions.

 This post was generated automatically.

If a and b are nonzero integers, is a^b an integer?

Prep Toolkit

Top 5 GMAT Debrief Videos

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards

GMAT Data Sufficiency (DS) Questions

If a and b are nonzero integers, is a^b an integer?

Prep Toolkit

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards