Author 
Message 
TAGS:

Hide Tags

Math Expert
Joined: 02 Sep 2009
Posts: 64248

If x and y are positive integers greater than 3, what is the remainder
[#permalink]
Show Tags
06 Dec 2017, 08:05
Question Stats:
49% (02:28) correct 51% (02:14) wrong based on 181 sessions
HideShow timer Statistics
GMAT Club's Fresh Challenge Problem. If x and y are positive integers greater than 3, what is the remainder when xy is divided by 9? (1) The positive difference between x and y is 2. (2) x and y are both primes numbers.
Official Answer and Stats are available only to registered users. Register/ Login.
_________________



Intern
Joined: 26 Oct 2017
Posts: 25

Re: If x and y are positive integers greater than 3, what is the remainder
[#permalink]
Show Tags
06 Dec 2017, 09:30
Imo C St1: X=9, y=7 Remainder = 0 X=6, y= 4 Remainder = 6 Not sufficient St2: X=5 Y=7 Remainder = 8 X=5 Y= 5 Remainder = 7 Not sufficient Combining 1 and 2 X=9, y=7 X=13, y=11 X= 19, y= 17 All gives same remainder 8 Sufficient Sent from my ONEPLUS A3003 using GMAT Club Forum mobile app



Math Expert
Joined: 02 Aug 2009
Posts: 8614

Re: If x and y are positive integers greater than 3, what is the remainder
[#permalink]
Show Tags
06 Dec 2017, 09:52
Bunuel wrote: GMAT Club's Fresh Challenge Problem. If x and y are positive integers greater than 3, what is the remainder when xy is divided by 9? (1) The positive difference between x and y is 2. (2) x and y are both primes numbers. a proper method would be (1) The positive difference between x and y is 2.many cases possible.. 9 and 7, remainder is 0 7 and 5 , remainder is 8 insuff (2) x and y are both primes numbers.5 and 7 will give 8 as remainder 7 and 11 will give 5 as remainder Insuff Combinedthe numbers would be of type 6n+1 and 6n1.. product = \((6n+1)(6n1) = 36n^21\).. \(36n^2\) is div by 9, so remainder will be 1 but remainder has to be positive so 91=8 suff C
_________________



Intern
Joined: 03 Jun 2017
Posts: 49
Location: United Kingdom
GMAT 1: 610 Q47 V27 GMAT 2: 700 Q49 V34
GPA: 4

Re: If x and y are positive integers greater than 3, what is the remainder
[#permalink]
Show Tags
09 Dec 2017, 00:27
chetan2u wrote: Bunuel wrote: GMAT Club's Fresh Challenge Problem. If x and y are positive integers greater than 3, what is the remainder when xy is divided by 9? (1) The positive difference between x and y is 2. (2) x and y are both primes numbers. a proper method would be (1) The positive difference between x and y is 2.many cases possible.. 9 and 7, remainder is 0 7 and 5 , remainder is 8 insuff (2) x and y are both primes numbers.5 and 7 will give 8 as remainder 7 and 11 will give 5 as remainder Insuff Combinedthe numbers would be of type 6n+1 and 6n1.. product = \((6n+1)(6n1) = 36n^21\).. \(36n^2\) is div by 9, so remainder will be 1 but remainder has to be positive so 91=8 suff C How did you get numbers of that form 6n+1 and 6n1?



Math Expert
Joined: 02 Aug 2009
Posts: 8614

Re: If x and y are positive integers greater than 3, what is the remainder
[#permalink]
Show Tags
09 Dec 2017, 03:33
stickman wrote: chetan2u wrote: Bunuel wrote: GMAT Club's Fresh Challenge Problem. If x and y are positive integers greater than 3, what is the remainder when xy is divided by 9? (1) The positive difference between x and y is 2. (2) x and y are both primes numbers. a proper method would be (1) The positive difference between x and y is 2.many cases possible.. 9 and 7, remainder is 0 7 and 5 , remainder is 8 insuff (2) x and y are both primes numbers.5 and 7 will give 8 as remainder 7 and 11 will give 5 as remainder Insuff Combinedthe numbers would be of type 6n+1 and 6n1.. product = \((6n+1)(6n1) = 36n^21\).. \(36n^2\) is div by 9, so remainder will be 1 but remainder has to be positive so 91=8 suff C How did you get numbers of that form 6n+1 and 6n1? All the PRIMES above 3 will be ODD and NOT divisible by 2 and 3 so 6n+1 and 6n1 will give you all numbers not div by 2 and 3 AND only two consecutive odd numbers will be prime as the THIRD will be surely be multiple of 3.. example 5,7, 9........ 9,11,13.....11,13, 15
_________________



Intern
Joined: 03 Jun 2017
Posts: 49
Location: United Kingdom
GMAT 1: 610 Q47 V27 GMAT 2: 700 Q49 V34
GPA: 4

Re: If x and y are positive integers greater than 3, what is the remainder
[#permalink]
Show Tags
09 Dec 2017, 03:43
chetan2u wrote: stickman wrote: How did you get numbers of that form 6n+1 and 6n1? All the PRIMES above 3 will be ODD and NOT divisible by 2 and 3 so 6n+1 and 6n1 will give you all numbers not div by 2 and 3 AND only two consecutive odd numbers will be prime as the THIRD will be surely be multiple of 3.. example 5,7, 9........ 9,11,13.....11,13, 15Perfect thanks. So say the same qs was rephrased but instead of greater than 3, it was greater than 5, would it be 30n1 and 30n+1?



Math Expert
Joined: 02 Aug 2009
Posts: 8614

If x and y are positive integers greater than 3, what is the remainder
[#permalink]
Show Tags
09 Dec 2017, 03:57
stickman wrote: chetan2u wrote: stickman wrote: How did you get numbers of that form 6n+1 and 6n1? All the PRIMES above 3 will be ODD and NOT divisible by 2 and 3 so 6n+1 and 6n1 will give you all numbers not div by 2 and 3 AND only two consecutive odd numbers will be prime as the THIRD will be surely be multiple of 3.. example 5,7, 9........ 9,11,13.....11,13, 15Perfect thanks. So say the same qs was rephrased but instead of greater than 3, it was greater than 5, would it be 30n1 and 30n+1? .. No, it will always remain 6n+1 and 6n1.. 30n+1 and 30n1 will miss many prime numbers .. if n =1 , the number becomes 31 and 29, both are prime but it misses out on many other prime like 7,11,13.. reason we take 6n+1 and 6n1 is that MOST of the numbers are div by 2 and 3 and therefore, possibility of missing any prime is 0.. n=1.....7 and 5 n=2.....13 and 11 n=3.....19 and 17 so here we are avoiding EVEN numbers and multiples of 3  9,15,21 and so on.. BUT remember it is not necessary that 6n+1 and 6n1 will be prime but PRIME will always be 6n+1 and 6n1
_________________



Intern
Joined: 03 Jun 2017
Posts: 49
Location: United Kingdom
GMAT 1: 610 Q47 V27 GMAT 2: 700 Q49 V34
GPA: 4

If x and y are positive integers greater than 3, what is the remainder
[#permalink]
Show Tags
09 Dec 2017, 04:00
chetan2u wrote: No, it will always remain 6n+1 and 6n1..
30n+1 and 30n1 will miss many prime numbers .. if n =1 , the number becomes 31 and 29, both are prime but it misses out on many other prime like 7,11,13..
reason we take 6n+1 and 6n1 is that MOST of the numbers are div by 2 and 3 and therefore, possibility of missing any prime is 0.. n=1.....7 and 5 n=2.....13 and 11 n=3.....19 and 17
so here we are avoiding EVEN numbers and multiples of 3  9,15,21 and so on..
BUT remember it is not necessary that 6n+1 and 6n1 will be prime but PRIME will always be 6n+1 and 6n1
I understand  thank you.



Math Expert
Joined: 02 Sep 2009
Posts: 64248

Re: If x and y are positive integers greater than 3, what is the remainder
[#permalink]
Show Tags
09 Dec 2017, 04:07
stickman wrote: chetan2u wrote: No, it will always remain 6n+1 and 6n1..
30n+1 and 30n1 will miss many prime numbers .. if n =1 , the number becomes 31 and 29, both are prime but it misses out on many other prime like 7,11,13..
reason we take 6n+1 and 6n1 is that MOST of the numbers are div by 2 and 3 and therefore, possibility of missing any prime is 0.. n=1.....7 and 5 n=2.....13 and 11 n=3.....19 and 17
so here we are avoiding EVEN numbers and multiples of 3  9,15,21 and so on..
BUT remember it is not necessary that 6n+1 and 6n1 will be prime but PRIME will always be 6n+1 and 6n1
I understand  thank you. chetan2u is referring to the following property: Any prime number p, which is greater than 3, could be expressed as \(p=6n+1\) or \(p=6n+5\) or \(p=6n1\), where n is an integer greater than 1.Any prime number p, which is greater than 3, when divided by 6 can only give the remainder of 1 or 5 (remainder cannot be 2 or 4 as in this case p would be even and the remainder cannot be 3 as in this case p would be divisible by 3). So, any prime number p, which is greater than 3, could be expressed as \(p=6n+1\) or \(p=6n+5\) or \(p=6n1\), where n is an integer greater than 1. But:Not all number which yield a remainder of 1 or 5 upon division by 6 are primes, so viseversa of the above property is not true. For example 25 yields the remainder of 1 upon division be 6 and it's not a prime number. Hope it's clear.
_________________



Math Expert
Joined: 02 Sep 2009
Posts: 64248

Re: If x and y are positive integers greater than 3, what is the remainder
[#permalink]
Show Tags
24 Dec 2018, 01:50
Bunuel wrote: GMAT Club's Fresh Challenge Problem. If x and y are positive integers greater than 3, what is the remainder when xy is divided by 9? (1) The positive difference between x and y is 2. (2) x and y are both primes numbers. Par of GMAT CLUB'S New Year's Quantitative Challenge Set
_________________



Manager
Joined: 24 Nov 2018
Posts: 107
Location: India
GPA: 3.27
WE: General Management (Retail Banking)

Re: If x and y are positive integers greater than 3, what is the remainder
[#permalink]
Show Tags
25 Dec 2018, 21:33
Bunuel wrote: GMAT Club's Fresh Challenge Problem. If x and y are positive integers greater than 3, what is the remainder when xy is divided by 9? (1) The positive difference between x and y is 2. (2) x and y are both primes numbers. Statement 1) The positive difference between x and y is 2. Assume x=4, y=6. The remainder (24/9)=6. Assume x=5, y=7 Remainder(35/90)=8. Two different answers. Not Sufficient. Statement 2) x and y are both primes numbers. Any prime integer can be expressed as 6*n+1 or 6*n1. There are three possibilities for the product of x and y. They are (6*m+1)*(6*n1), (6*m1)*(6m1) or (6m+1)*(6m+1){Both expressions are the same.} and (6*n1)*(6*n1). Possibility 1 (6*m+1)*(6*n1) applies to all prime numbers. Taking m=3 and n=5, so xy= 19*29. The remainder (19*29/9)=2. For m=7 and n=5, the remainder (43*29/9)=5. Two answers, Not Sufficient. Possibility 2 explores when x=y= any prime number. So, the product will be a square of the prime number. e.g. 5^2/9, the remainder is 7 or 7^2/9, the remainder is 4. Two different answers. Not Sufficient. Possibility 3 explores when the prime numbers differ by 2. So, simplifying possibility 3, (6*n1)*(6*n1)=(36n^21). Remainder when (36n^21) is divided by 9 is 1 or (91)=8. It will always be 1 or 8 irrespective of n. So, in summary, only possibility 3 of 3 possibilities gives us an accurate answer. Statement 2 on whole is Insufficient. (1)+(2) This is what possibility 3 discussed in 2 above assumes that the difference between x and y is 2. Hence, Sufficient. Option C is the correct answer.



SVP
Joined: 24 Nov 2016
Posts: 1567
Location: United States

If x and y are positive integers greater than 3, what is the remainder
[#permalink]
Show Tags
24 Oct 2019, 07:29
Bunuel wrote: GMAT Club's Fresh Challenge Problem. If x and y are positive integers greater than 3, what is the remainder when xy is divided by 9? (1) The positive difference between x and y is 2. (2) x and y are both primes numbers. \((x,y)>3; remainder(xy/9)=?\) \(primes=[5,7,11,13,17,19,23,29,31…]\) (1) The positive difference between x and y is 2. insufic.\(xy=2:(x,y)=(6,4)…24/9…r=6\) \(xy=2:(x,y)=(8,6)…48/9…r=3\) (2) x and y are both primes numbers. insufic.\((x,y)=(5,7)…35/9…r=8\) \((x,y)=(7,11)…77/9…r=5\) (1 & 2) sufic.\((x,y)=(5,7)…35/9…r=8\) \((x,y)=(11,13)…143/9=…r=8\) \((x,y)=(29,31)…889/9=…r=8\) Answer (C)



CEO
Joined: 03 Jun 2019
Posts: 2910
Location: India
GMAT 1: 690 Q50 V34
WE: Engineering (Transportation)

Re: If x and y are positive integers greater than 3, what is the remainder
[#permalink]
Show Tags
24 Oct 2019, 07:43
Bunuel wrote: GMAT Club's Fresh Challenge Problem. If x and y are positive integers greater than 3, what is the remainder when xy is divided by 9? (1) The positive difference between x and y is 2. (2) x and y are both primes numbers. Asked: If x and y are positive integers greater than 3, what is the remainder when xy is divided by 9? (1) The positive difference between x and y is 2. x = 4, y = 6; xy = 24 divided by 9 gives remainder 6 x = 5; y = 7; xy = 35 divided by 9 gives remainder 8 NOT SUFFICIENT (2) x and y are both primes numbers. x = 7; y = 13; xy = 91 divided by 9 gives remainder 1 x = 5; y = 7; xy = 35 divided by 9 gives remainder 8 NOT SUFFICIENT (1) + (2) (1) The positive difference between x and y is 2. (2) x and y are both primes numbers. x = 5; y = 7; xy = 35 divided by 9 gives remainder 8 x = 11, y=13; xy divided by 9 gives remainder 8 x = 17; y = 19; xy divided by 9 gives remainder 8 SUFFICIENT IMO C
_________________
Kinshook Chaturvedi Email: kinshook.chaturvedi@gmail.com




Re: If x and y are positive integers greater than 3, what is the remainder
[#permalink]
24 Oct 2019, 07:43




