Author 
Message 
TAGS:

Hide Tags

Manager
Joined: 01 Apr 2006
Posts: 140
Location: Toronto, Canada

Is the square root of (x  5)^2 = 5  x ? (1) xx > 0 (2) 5  x > 0
[#permalink]
Show Tags
13 Jan 2007, 11:52
Question Stats:
63% (01:43) correct 37% (01:52) wrong based on 881 sessions
HideShow timer Statistics
Is \(\sqrt{(x5)^2} = 5  x\)? (1) \(xx > 0\) (2) \(5  x > 0\)
Official Answer and Stats are available only to registered users. Register/ Login.




Math Expert
Joined: 02 Sep 2009
Posts: 59157

Re: Is the square root of (x  5)^2 = 5  x ? (1) xx > 0 (2) 5  x > 0
[#permalink]
Show Tags
09 Sep 2009, 15:41
dhushan wrote: Just want to make sure that my line of thinking is right. I got D as well.
sqrt(x5)^2 = 5x ==> x5 = 5x
which means that if
x5<0, (x5) = 5x = no solution, therefore x<5
x5>0, x5 = 5x, which means that x>5 and x = 5
from (1) xx > 0, we know that x has to be negative (x)x is the only way to get a number greater than 0. Therefore, this means that of the three possible solutions for x, only this x<5 hold true.
from (2) 5x>0, therefore x<5.
Can someone please point out if there is something wrong with my reasoning. Is \(\sqrt{(x5)^2}=5x\)?First of all, recall that \(\sqrt{x^2}=x\). Is \(\sqrt{(x5)^2}=5x\)? > is \(x5=5x\)? > is \(x5\leq{0}\)? > is \(x\leq{5}\)? (1) \(xx > 0\) > \(x\) is never negative (positive or zero), so for \(xx\) to be positive, \(x\) must be positive \(x>0\) > \(x<0\). Sufficient. (2) \(5x>0\) > \(x<5\). Sufficient. Answer: D.
_________________




VP
Joined: 01 May 2006
Posts: 1480

Re: Is the square root of (x  5)^2 = 5  x ? (1) xx > 0 (2) 5  x > 0
[#permalink]
Show Tags
13 Jan 2007, 12:11
For me (D)
sqrt( (x5)^2) = 5  x ?
<=> x5 = 5x ?
<=> 5x = 5x ?
This is true if 5x >= 0 <=> x =< 5
So we end up with checking if x =< 5 ?
Stat 1
x x > 0
<=> x < 0 < 5
SUFF.
Stat 2
5  x > 0
<=> x < 5
SUFF.




Intern
Joined: 30 Jul 2009
Posts: 14

Re: Is the square root of (x  5)^2 = 5  x ? (1) xx > 0 (2) 5  x > 0
[#permalink]
Show Tags
09 Sep 2009, 12:01
Just want to make sure that my line of thinking is right. I got D as well.
sqrt(x5)^2 = 5x ==> x5 = 5x
which means that if
x5<0, (x5) = 5x = no solution, therefore x<5
x5>0, x5 = 5x, which means that x>5 and x = 5
from (1) xx > 0, we know that x has to be negative (x)x is the only way to get a number greater than 0. Therefore, this means that of the three possible solutions for x, only this x<5 hold true.
from (2) 5x>0, therefore x<5.
Can someone please point out if there is something wrong with my reasoning.



Manager
Joined: 25 Aug 2009
Posts: 107
Location: Streamwood IL
Schools: Kellogg(Evening),Booth (Evening)
WE 1: 5 Years

Re: Is the square root of (x  5)^2 = 5  x ? (1) xx > 0 (2) 5  x > 0
[#permalink]
Show Tags
31 Dec 2009, 09:40
The question basically wants to know if x<=5 else RHS will be x5 Statement 1 xx>0 or xx<0 (multiply by 1 both sides and reverse the sign) either x<0 or x<0 since x is always positive or 0 x<0 is true. if x<0 then x<5 hence sufficient Statement 2 5x>0 5>x This is what we are looking for hence sufficient Answer is D.
_________________



Math Expert
Joined: 02 Sep 2009
Posts: 59157

Re: Is the square root of (x  5)^2 = 5  x ? (1) xx > 0 (2) 5  x > 0
[#permalink]
Show Tags
06 Sep 2010, 12:30
metallicafan wrote: Is \(sqrt(x5)^2 = 5x?\)
(1) xlxl > 0 (2) 5x > 0
PS. Is always this true?: \(sqrt{x^2}\) = lxl ? Is \(\sqrt{(x5)^2}=5x\)? Remember: \(\sqrt{x^2}=x\). So "is \(\sqrt{(x5)^2}=5x\)?" becomes: is \(x5=5x\)? \(x5=5x\) is true only for \(x\leq{5}\), as in this case \(\{LHS=x5=5x\}=\{RHS=5x\}\). So we have that if \(x\leq{5}\), then \(x5=5x\) is true. Basically question asks is \(x\leq{5}\)? (1) \(xx > 0\) > \(x\) is never negative (positive or zero), so in order to have \(xx > 0\), \(x\) must be positive \(x>0\) > \(x<0\), so \(x\) is less than 5 too. Sufficient. (2) \(5x>0\) > \(x<5\). Sufficient. Answer: D. Hope it helps. P.S. Explanation of: \(\sqrt{x^2}=x\). The point here is that as square root function cannot give negative result then \(\sqrt{some \ expression}\geq{0}\). So \(\sqrt{x^2}\geq{0}\). But what does \(\sqrt{x^2}\) equal to? Let's consider following examples: If \(x=5\) > \(\sqrt{x^2}=\sqrt{25}=5=x=positive\); If \(x=5\) > \(\sqrt{x^2}=\sqrt{25}=5=x=positive\). So we got that: \(\sqrt{x^2}=x\), if \(x\geq{0}\); \(\sqrt{x^2}=x\), if \(x<0\). What function does exactly the same thing? The absolute value function: \(x=x\), if \(x\geq{0}\) and \(x=x\), if \(x<0\). That is why \(\sqrt{x^2}=x\).
_________________



Intern
Status: Last few days....Have pressed the throttle
Joined: 20 Jun 2010
Posts: 49
WE 1: 6 years  Consulting

Re: Is the square root of (x  5)^2 = 5  x ? (1) xx > 0 (2) 5  x > 0
[#permalink]
Show Tags
07 Sep 2010, 02:44
Bunuel wrote: metallicafan wrote: Is \(sqrt(x5)^2 = 5x?\)
(1) xlxl > 0 (2) 5x > 0
PS. Is always this true?: \(sqrt{x^2}\) = lxl ? Is \(\sqrt{(x5)^2}=5x\)? Remember: \(\sqrt{x^2}=x\). So "is \(\sqrt{(x5)^2}=5x\)?" becomes: is \(x5=5x\)? \(x5=5x\) is true only for \(x\leq{5}\), as in this case \(\{LHS=x5=5x\}=\{RHS=5x\}\). So we have that if \(x\leq{5}\), then \(x5=5x\) is true. Basically question asks is \(x\leq{5}\)? (1) \(xx > 0\) > \(x\) is never negative (positive or zero), so in order to have \(xx > 0\), \(x\) must be positive \(x>0\) > \(x<0\), so \(x\) is less than 5 too. Sufficient. (2) \(5x>0\) > \(x<5\). Sufficient. Answer: D. Hope it helps. Hi Bunuel, I get confused in the following concept. Can you please help me: \(xx > 0\) > \(x\) is never negative (positive or zero), so in order to have \(xx > 0\), \(x\) must be positive \(x>0\) > \(x<0\), so \(x\) is less than 5 too Can't we solve it as follows: As \(x\) is never negative > \(xx > 0\) = x*x = x^2 >0 = x^2<0 (multiplying by ve sign and flipping sign) x^2<0 => \(sqrt{x^2}\) <0 => lxl <0 (as \(sqrt{x^2}\) =lxl ) Since lxl cannot be negative and lxl <0 that implies X<0 I have reached to same conclusion as yours but wanted to confirm if my approach is right. Please explain.Thanks
_________________
Consider giving Kudos if my post helps in some way



Math Expert
Joined: 02 Sep 2009
Posts: 59157

Re: Is the square root of (x  5)^2 = 5  x ? (1) xx > 0 (2) 5  x > 0
[#permalink]
Show Tags
07 Sep 2010, 05:01
oldstudent wrote: Bunuel wrote: metallicafan wrote: Is \(sqrt(x5)^2 = 5x?\)
(1) xlxl > 0 (2) 5x > 0
PS. Is always this true?: \(sqrt{x^2}\) = lxl ? Is \(\sqrt{(x5)^2}=5x\)? Remember: \(\sqrt{x^2}=x\). So "is \(\sqrt{(x5)^2}=5x\)?" becomes: is \(x5=5x\)? \(x5=5x\) is true only for \(x\leq{5}\), as in this case \(\{LHS=x5=5x\}=\{RHS=5x\}\). So we have that if \(x\leq{5}\), then \(x5=5x\) is true. Basically question asks is \(x\leq{5}\)? (1) \(xx > 0\) > \(x\) is never negative (positive or zero), so in order to have \(xx > 0\), \(x\) must be positive \(x>0\) > \(x<0\), so \(x\) is less than 5 too. Sufficient. (2) \(5x>0\) > \(x<5\). Sufficient. Answer: D. Hope it helps. Hi Bunuel, I get confused in the following concept. Can you please help me: \(xx > 0\) > \(x\) is never negative (positive or zero), so in order to have \(xx > 0\), \(x\) must be positive \(x>0\) > \(x<0\), so \(x\) is less than 5 too Can't we solve it as follows: As \(x\) is never negative > \(xx > 0\)= x*x = x^2 >0 = x^2<0 (multiplying by ve sign and flipping sign) x^2<0 => \(sqrt{x^2}\) <0=> lxl <0 (as \(sqrt{x^2}\) =lxl ) Since lxl cannot be negative and lxl <0 that implies X<0 I have reached to same conclusion as yours but wanted to confirm if my approach is right. Please explain.Thanks This approach is not right. The red parts are not correct. \(xx > 0\) cannot be written as \(x*x>0\), as \(x\geq{0}\) does not mean \(x\) itself cannot be negative > \(x=x\) if \(x\geq{0}\) and \(x=x\) if \(x\leq{0}\), so when you are writing \(x\) instead of \(x\) you are basically assuming that \(x\geq{0}\) and then in the end get the opposite result \(x<0\). Next, \(x^2<0\) has no solution, square of a number cannot be negative, so no \(x\) can make this inequality hold true.
_________________



Manager
Joined: 17 Mar 2010
Posts: 128

Re: Is the square root of (x  5)^2 = 5  x ? (1) xx > 0 (2) 5  x > 0
[#permalink]
Show Tags
07 Sep 2010, 23:42
I think for this question we dont need any statement... without statement itself it is possible to say if the equality is correct or wrong. Can someone comment on this... Bunuel please?



Math Expert
Joined: 02 Sep 2009
Posts: 59157

Re: Is the square root of (x  5)^2 = 5  x ? (1) xx > 0 (2) 5  x > 0
[#permalink]
Show Tags
08 Sep 2010, 06:59
amitjash wrote: I think for this question we dont need any statement... without statement itself it is possible to say if the equality is correct or wrong. Can someone comment on this... Bunuel please? This not correct. \(x\) must be less than or equal to 5 inequality \(\sqrt{(x5)^2}=5x\) to hold true. For example if \(x=10>5\) then \(\sqrt{(x5)^2}=5\neq{5}=5x\)
_________________



Veritas Prep GMAT Instructor
Joined: 16 Oct 2010
Posts: 9791
Location: Pune, India

Re: Is the square root of (x  5)^2 = 5  x ? (1) xx > 0 (2) 5  x > 0
[#permalink]
Show Tags
19 Mar 2011, 20:20
arjunrampal wrote: Please explain the approach to solve the problem and point to any relevant material available in the GMAT club. Attachment: square_root_D.JPG Let me point out something here: You cannot square both sides to get Is \((\sqrt{(x5)^2})^2 = (5x)^2\) ? People sometimes get confused here. Why can you not square it? It is a question similar to 'Is x = 5?' Can you square both sides here and change the question to 'Is \(x^2 = 25\)?' Please remember, they are not the same. x^2 can be 25 even if x is not 5 ( when x = 5, even then x^2 = 25). Only if it is given to you that x = 5, then you can say that x^2 = 25. You can rephrase the question in the following manner (and many more ways) Is \((\sqrt{(x5)^2}) = (5x)\) ? Is \(x5 = (5x)\) ? or Is \(5x = (5x)\)? We know that x = x only when x >= 0 So \(5x = (5x)\) only when 5  x >= 0 or when x <= 5 Stmnt 1: xx > 0 Since x is always positive (or zero), x must be positive too. So x must be negative. If x < 0, then x is obviously less than 5. Sufficient. Stmnt 2: 5  x> 0 x < 5. Sufficient Answer D
_________________
Karishma Veritas Prep GMAT Instructor
Learn more about how Veritas Prep can help you achieve a great GMAT score by checking out their GMAT Prep Options >



Intern
Joined: 04 Jan 2015
Posts: 7

Re: Is the square root of (x  5)^2 = 5  x ? (1) xx > 0 (2) 5  x > 0
[#permalink]
Show Tags
12 Jul 2015, 08:32
kshitij89Modulus always results in an positive value. If x5>0 then x−5 should be equal to x5 However, If x5<0 then modulus would result the positive value of it i.e. (x5)=5x Thus, is x−5=5−x? > is x−5<0? > is x<5? Solving as Bunuel ,you'll get D.



Intern
Joined: 05 Oct 2017
Posts: 43
Location: Bangladesh
Concentration: Accounting, Social Entrepreneurship

Re: Is the square root of (x  5)^2 = 5  x ? (1) xx > 0 (2) 5  x > 0
[#permalink]
Show Tags
07 Dec 2018, 21:01
Bunuel wrote: dhushan wrote: Just want to make sure that my line of thinking is right. I got D as well.
sqrt(x5)^2 = 5x ==> x5 = 5x
which means that if
x5<0, (x5) = 5x = no solution, therefore x<5
x5>0, x5 = 5x, which means that x>5 and x = 5
from (1) xx > 0, we know that x has to be negative (x)x is the only way to get a number greater than 0. Therefore, this means that of the three possible solutions for x, only this x<5 hold true.
from (2) 5x>0, therefore x<5.
Can someone please point out if there is something wrong with my reasoning. Is \(\sqrt{(x5)^2}=5x\)?First of all, recall that \(\sqrt{x^2}=x\). Is \(\sqrt{(x5)^2}=5x\)? > is \(x5=5x\)? > is \(x5\leq{0}\)? > is \(x\leq{5}\)?(1) \(xx > 0\) > \(x\) is never negative (positive or zero), so for \(xx\) to be positive, \(x\) must be positive \(x>0\) > \(x<0\). Sufficient. (2) \(5x>0\) > \(x<5\). Sufficient. Answer: D. in the highlighted portion, why we can not also write that x is greater than or equal to 5. if we take out modulus, x5 can be positive and can be negative. there are two possible values of x. you consider only negative possibility. please help. i don't understand.
_________________
.... You are already NAKED. There is NO reason not to FOLLOW your heart.



Retired Moderator
Joined: 22 Aug 2013
Posts: 1416
Location: India

Re: Is the square root of (x  5)^2 = 5  x ? (1) xx > 0 (2) 5  x > 0
[#permalink]
Show Tags
07 Dec 2018, 22:18
rashedBhai wrote: Bunuel wrote: dhushan wrote: Just want to make sure that my line of thinking is right. I got D as well.
sqrt(x5)^2 = 5x ==> x5 = 5x
which means that if
x5<0, (x5) = 5x = no solution, therefore x<5
x5>0, x5 = 5x, which means that x>5 and x = 5
from (1) xx > 0, we know that x has to be negative (x)x is the only way to get a number greater than 0. Therefore, this means that of the three possible solutions for x, only this x<5 hold true.
from (2) 5x>0, therefore x<5.
Can someone please point out if there is something wrong with my reasoning. Is \(\sqrt{(x5)^2}=5x\)?First of all, recall that \(\sqrt{x^2}=x\). Is \(\sqrt{(x5)^2}=5x\)? > is \(x5=5x\)? > is \(x5\leq{0}\)? > is \(x\leq{5}\)?(1) \(xx > 0\) > \(x\) is never negative (positive or zero), so for \(xx\) to be positive, \(x\) must be positive \(x>0\) > \(x<0\). Sufficient. (2) \(5x>0\) > \(x<5\). Sufficient. Answer: D. in the highlighted portion, why we can not also write that x is greater than or equal to 5. if we take out modulus, x5 can be positive and can be negative. there are two possible values of x. you consider only negative possibility. please help. i don't understand. Hello I will try to explain. If x is >= 5 (greater than or equal to 5), then x5 will be positive, and square root of (x5)^2, will be equal to x5 only, it will never be equal to 5x. Eg, lets take x=6, here x5 = 1, which is positive. Here (x5)^2 = 1^2 = 1, and its square root is 1, which is x5 only, NOT 5x. But if we take x=4, here x5 = 1, which is negative. Here (x5)^2 = (1)^2 = 1, and its square root is 1, which is NOT x5: rather its 5x.



Intern
Joined: 13 Dec 2018
Posts: 12

Re: Is the square root of (x  5)^2 = 5  x ? (1) xx > 0 (2) 5  x > 0
[#permalink]
Show Tags
18 Aug 2019, 22:23
Hi Bunuel , Can you please tell me where I am doing wrong ? I think for this question we don't need any statement because as the question is asking Is sqrt(x5)^2 = 5x ? We can write above one like this : sqrt(x5)^2 = (x5) Now Squaring both sides (x5)^2 = {(x5) }^2 Hence , (x5)^2 = (x5)^2. Please correct me, where I am getting it wrong. Thanks



Math Expert
Joined: 02 Sep 2009
Posts: 59157

Re: Is the square root of (x  5)^2 = 5  x ? (1) xx > 0 (2) 5  x > 0
[#permalink]
Show Tags
18 Aug 2019, 22:31
a12bansal wrote: Hi Bunuel , Can you please tell me where I am doing wrong ? I think for this question we don't need any statement because as the question is asking Is sqrt(x5)^2 = 5x ? We can write above one like this : sqrt(x5)^2 = (x5) Now Squaring both sides (x5)^2 = {(x5) }^2 Hence , (x5)^2 = (x5)^2. Please correct me, where I am getting it wrong. Thanks I addressed this doubt here: https://gmatclub.com/forum/isrootx5 ... ml#p777283Also, you can only square equations when both sides are nonnegative. 5  x COULD be negative when x > 5 so when squaring you might get wrong result.
_________________



NonHuman User
Joined: 09 Sep 2013
Posts: 13610

Re: Is sqrt ((x5) ^ 2) = 5x? (1) xx > 0 (2) 5  x > 0
[#permalink]
Show Tags
19 Oct 2019, 03:18
Hello from the GMAT Club BumpBot! Thanks to another GMAT Club member, I have just discovered this valuable topic, yet it had no discussion for over a year. I am now bumping it up  doing my job. I think you may find it valuable (esp those replies with Kudos). Want to see all other topics I dig out? Follow me (click follow button on profile). You will receive a summary of all topics I bump in your profile area as well as via email.
_________________




Re: Is sqrt ((x5) ^ 2) = 5x? (1) xx > 0 (2) 5  x > 0
[#permalink]
19 Oct 2019, 03:18






