facdan
Hi,
Hi please GMATNINJA or
E-GMAT can you help me on this? I still have a problem with the difference between B and D.
The word ‘’courts’’ is a non modifier I think. So for me, what the verb ‘’to be’’ modifies is public resource. I thought it should be ‘is’ and not ‘are’. This is why I choose B over D.
Posted from my mobile deviceWe attempted to address the singular vs. plural issue in
this post. In short, there's no reason why you can't describe the courts directly with a noun modifier: "courts in theory ARE available to all but in fact ARE unequally distributed between rich and poor." This is fine, so turning this into a noun modifier ("which in theory...") is also fine.
Also, notice that (D) wouldn't make much sense without "the courts":
"Judge Lois Forer’s study asks why some litigants have a preferred status to another in the use of a public resource, in theory available to all but in fact not equally distributed between rich and poor."
What public resource? And how are we supposed to imagine the "distribution" of this public resource without knowing what it is?
We need "the courts" to understand the meaning: "the courts" tells us what "public resource" we're talking about, and the "which" clause gives us more information about the courts. So (B) is perfectly fine.
In (D), notice that "another" seems to refer to a singular noun in (D), suggesting the following interpretation:
"Judge Lois Forer’s study asks why some litigants have a preferred status to another status in the use of a public resource..."
This seems to compare the status
of some litigants to the status
of some other status, and that doesn't make any sense.
(D) doesn't work, so (B) is our winner.