93Shivam93
📌 Quick Background
Age: 31
Nationality: Indian (Male)
🎓 Education
B.Tech in Civil Engineering from IIT (Class of 2015) – CGPA: 8.14/10
10th – 87% | 12th – 84%
📊 Standardized Tests
GMAT FE(2025): 715
CAT (2019): 99.18 percentile
💼 Work Experience
10 years in a Maharatna PSU (Oil & Gas sector)
3 years as Engineering Officer
7 years as Field Officer – Sales, overseeing the Bangalore region
Solely responsible for 50+ retail outlets with a combined annual turnover of ₹1000 Cr
Led expansion efforts adding 15 new outlets, contributing ₹100 Cr/year in new business
🎯 Career Goals
Exploring a career shift out of the oil & gas sector
Interested in consulting, strategy, or other dynamic sectors
Pursuing an MBA to explore new industries, refine goals, and accelerate the transition
❓ Main Questions
With 10 years of work experience, will I be considered too experienced for top MBA programs—or can this be framed constructively?
Are programs like M7, Ivy League, INSEAD, LBS, HEC realistically within reach based on my profile?
Which MBA programs are best suited for professionals seeking to switch industries, especially into consulting or general management?
Thanks for sharing—your profile is super impressive!
Ten years in a top PSU with serious responsibility shows clear leadership, ownership, and impact. Add to that a strong IIT background, a 715 GMAT, and solid test-taking skills.
To your questions:
You are right, and top MBA programs flag candidates with over 10 years of experience and usually do not recruit candidates with over 12 years. You are borderline...
But, as long as you keep it around 10 and your goals make sense and you show that the MBA is the right next step (not a “late” step), you’ll be taken seriously. We’ve seen candidates with even more experience get into INSEAD, LBS, Kellogg, and others.
Are M7/Ivy/INSEAD realistic? Yes—if your essays and recommendations reflect strong leadership, learning agility, and clear post-MBA goals. A 715 is solid, but if you think you can push it closer to 740+, that would give you even more breathing room, especially for the M7.
On the other hand, the "special" 1Y senior programs like MIT SF, Stanford MSx, LBS Sloanb, Foster GEMBA, care less about high GMATs...
Best fit programs for your goals? INSEAD and LBS or the 1Y programs in the US have the best fit and are excellent for career switchers, especially into consulting.
The 2Y US schools are all amazing (any top 15 school ), but as discussed, you are a bit borderline in terms of experience.
Happy to chat more if you need help shaping the story—framing your experience right will make all the difference! I am always on
shimriw@ARINGO.comBest of luck,
Shimri
Harshita2003
Hi there!
22 year old Indian Female, Tier 1 commerce college, 8.3 GPA, 2024 batch
GMAT: Will attempt in September, 2025, tageting above 720+
Schools: NYU Stern, Columbia, HEC Paris, Yale SOM, INSEAD
Work Exp: 6 months of Investment Banking at a boutique investment firm+1 Year in Founder’s Office roles at a health tech company
Extra-Curriculars:
1. Worked as a marketing & sales head at an international social entrepreneurship organisation
2. Built my own marketplace venture (shut down after 6 months)
Questions:
1. I’ve got decent exposure in my jobs as both of them are client facing, but they’re not big names in their fields. Will I be at a disadvantage because of that?
2. I have recently switched my role from marketing to finance (IB) and currently gaining more exposure in it. Will that switch be seen as an issue?
Thanks for reaching out—you’ve got great potential, and I love the initiative you’ve already shown!
At just 22, with strong academics, solid early work experience and meaningful extracurriculars, you’re off to an excellent start.
That said, as you are young with little work experience, I’d recommend waiting and not applying for 2026. Targeting the 2027 intake or later to allow time to build depth, take on more responsibility, and strengthen your MBA story.
To your questions:
1. Does working at lesser-known firms hurt your chances?
Big names help, but Admissions committees care more about what you did—impact, leadership, initiative and less about where you did it. Many successful applicants come from smaller or lesser-known firms, especially if they show drive and strong career progression.
2. Is switching from marketing to finance a problem?
Not at all. Career pivots are very common early on. What matters is how you frame your journey and if you can explain the logic behind the switch and how it fits into your long-term goals, it will only add to your narrative.
Keep building that experience, aim for a strong GMAT , and start thinking about how to tell your story. You’re absolutely on the right track.
Happy to talk next year (keep my email:
shimriw@ARINGO.com) or when you are ready for the applications process:)
GOOD LUCK!
Shimri
Right, I think we can close this chat session
Thanks, everyone! I really enjoyed today’s discussion and all your great questions.
If you have any personal questions or would like a detailed
profile review, feel free to send me your CV, school wish list, GMAT score, and any other relevant details at
Shimriw@ARINGO.com.
And don’t forget to check us out at
ARINGO.com for more insights and resources.
Looking forward to staying in touch! 😊
Shimri Winters
ARINGO MBA Admissions Consulting