cheetarah1980
swbluedevil
What schools are you targeting? Please don't take this the wrong way, but Toastmasters and Big Brothers Big Sisters are such vanilla ECs and won't do anything to differentiate you from the competition. What are you interested in? What are your passions?
I don't think a blanket statement like this can be made. It's about the quality of involvement in ECs more than what the EC is itself. I don't think a person needs ECs that no one else does to differentiate themselves.
Get involved with ECs that you enjoy and you'll participate at a differentiated level. I've been a Big Sister for years and while I don't think that alone got me an admit, but I do think it added to the story that I was committed to being active in the community and would continue to do so on campus.
Actually, I'm pretty justified in making the statement I made. I never stated that you had to participate in an EC that no one else participated in. I simply suggested that the OP pursue less overly common activities than Big Brothers and Big Sisters and Toastmasters. I think you'll agree that differentiation and diversity are good things for an applicant, especially if the OP is from a very competitive applicant pool.
I think it's wonderful you've been a Big Sis for many years and congrats on your admit. I'm sure you were able to write some fantastic essays that showed impact. Unfortunately, assuming the OP does not get into any schools this year, he/she will be a reapplicant with ~7-8 months of involvement in two very common ECs. I think most (if not all) adcoms will see clearly that the OP joined those ECs simply to beef up their application. Furthermore, how many other applicants/reapplicants can (and will) join Big Brother/Big Sister, Toastmasters, Habitat for Humanity, etc right before they start applying?
And I think it's great for applicants to point to their participation in organizations to signal to adcoms that they'll be equally active on campus. I just believe it's more compelling for an applicant to have unique/less common ECs to signal to adcoms that they'll do more on campus than simply join the consulting club, marketing club, etc.