I really like the intention behind this thread but I think it might be getting a bit outdated. Not sure if the OP is still active and trying to keep this up to date. Would love to start a new thread if not.
I also agree that IMD should be in the Ultra Elite bucket. IMD grads have the highest earnings out of any international MBA 3 months out, 3 years out, and 5 years out. IMD has also long established itself as the king of industry, general management, and leadership.
Consulting placement is also pretty great at 29% last year. That's actually quite a bit better than INSEAD the supposed king of consulting when you take away their sponsored consulting students.
Due to its smaller size with only 90 students IMD doesn't really care about rankings and so it gets dinged on certain metrics that benefit from scale like: number of nationalities (Insead has 60 nationalities for 1000 students and IMD has 40 nationalities for 90 students), class size (LBS and Insead will have 60-70 person classes but IMD will have 90 person classes since that's the entire program), etc. The fact that IMD can send 70% of its grads to industry and still have higher earnings for its grads than INSEAD and LBS that target more traditionally higher paying sectors like finance and consulting says something.
At the end of the day, most people that go into consulting use it to accelerate their careers and then go into industry. IMD provides a route for its graduates to skip that if they choose and land senior management jobs out of school. But if you do want to go into consulting MBB still recruit very heavily there.
The smaller MBA alumni network is largely mitigated by the huge executive MBA network since IMD is the king of executive education with 9000 executives going through each year.
How many of the other schools in the Elite cluster can claim any of the above?
Posted from my mobile device