Hi shixag,Good news first: your final answer of
1/3 is right, and your first two rounds are genuinely solid. Let me show you the one spot where the pair-logic quietly slips.
Your first two rounds are airtight:
-
Round 1: of the
16 letter-envelope pairs,
4 are correct -
4/16 = 1/4. ✓
-
Round 2: one letter is placed, leaving
3 letters and
3 envelopes =
9 pairs,
3 correct -
6/9 = 2/3. ✓ (All three leftover letters still have their own envelope available, so "
3 correct pairs" is really true.)
The crack shows up in
round 3. You treated it as "
2 letters,
2 envelopes -
4 pairs,
2 correct -
1/2." But that quietly assumes both remaining letters still have their correct envelope free - and they don't always.
Watch a concrete branch. Say L1-E1 (correct), then L2-E3 (wrong). Now L3, L4 are left with E2, E4. But L3's own envelope is
E3 - already used, so L3 can never be correct here. Among the
4 leftover pairs, only
one (L4-E4) is correct, not two. So in this branch the "incorrect" probability is really
3/4, not
1/2.
So "
2 correct out of
4 pairs" isn't literally true round by round. It just happens to average out to the right total for
4 letters - which is exactly the subtlety the experts in this thread were arguing about with the
1/2 step. Your
1/2 is right, but for a subtler reason than the pair-count suggests.
The clean fix that keeps your method honest: after placing the wrong second letter, always focus next on a letter that
still has its envelope available. That letter genuinely has a
1/2 chance of going wrong, and the last one is then forced.
Bottom line: correct answer, correct first two fractions, and your x
4 (the
4!/3!) is fine too - just know the round-
3 "
1/2" rests on an assumption that isn't always true, so don't lean on this exact pair-count if the number of letters ever grows past
four.
Answer: Dshixag
Used a different approach here, please someone check if this is correct, or if there is any inconsistency. Thank you!
4 Envelopes, 4 Letters
Total 16 pairs of letters and envelopes possible: (E1L1, E1L2........E4,L4)
From the set, 4 pairs are pair of correct letters and envelopes, and rest are incorrect,
therefore, probability of correct would be selecting any 4 of the 16, hence 4/16, or 1/4
once we've picked a pair, we're left with 3 Es and 3 Ls, therefore, 9 pairs, of which 3 are correct.
P(selecting incorrect pair) = 6/9, or 2/3
same logic applies for another 2 rounds, giving 2/4 or 1/2 for 2 pairs left and 1/1 for the last pair
we multiple all these together and 4!/3! (to adjust for arrangements) to get 1/4 * 2/3 * 1/2 *1/1 * 4!/3!
ans: 1/3