The Federal Aviation Administration, commonly known as the FAA, is the

Question

The Federal Aviation Administration, commonly known as the FAA, is the government agency tasked with regulating civil aviation in the United States. One of the FAA’s more prominent functions is to regulate the safety of the airline industry, which it does by creating and enforcing rules that govern the manufacture and operation of commercial aircraft. However, the FAA is also charged with a number of other responsibilities, including a mandate to promote civil aviation. Many of the FAA’s critics have argued that this role is directly incompatible with the agency’s primary duty to regulate safety and have called on Congress to redefine the FAA’s mission to exclude the duty to promote civil aviation from the agency’s list of responsibilities.

The critics’ concern is that the safety of the airline industry cannot be adequately regulated by the same agency that is supposed to promote the industry as a whole. According to the critics, if a safety issue were to arise, the FAA would have to weigh the potential harm that the airline industry would suffer due to increased regulation against the benefits of remedying the safety concern, which might lead to inaction by the FAA. For example, several leading safety advocates have recommended that the FAA prohibit the practice of allowing infants under two years old to fly as “lap children” and instead require a separate seat for all passengers regardless of age. Because many parents would opt out of flying if they were required to purchase separate tickets for their young children, the advocates’ recommendation would, if adopted, lead to a decline in airline ticket sales. The failure of the FAA to act on this proposal is, to many critics, a sign that the agency is more concerned with the potential loss of revenue to the airline industry than the potential loss of a young child’s life.

The critics’ claim is not entirely without merit, as it is common for the FAA to consider potential financial consequences when contemplating a new regulation. However, the critics fundamentally misunderstand the role that this  cost-benefit analysis  plays in the agency’s decision-making process. If the FAA enacts regulations that make plane tickets prohibitively expensive, people will instead travel by car, statistically a much more dangerous mode of transportation than flying. Thus, when the FAA declines to revise its “lap child” policy, it does so not to protect the airline industry’s revenues but to reduce the risks associated with travel for children and their parents. Moreover, there is a built-in safeguard to prevent the FAA from protecting revenues at the expense of travelers’ safety: if the FAA failed to act on a significant safety concern, the public would lose confidence in airline travel, causing harm to the industry itself. Ultimately, the FAA’s duty to promote commercial aviation serves to reinforce its safety mission rather than undermine it.   1 
 1. Which of the following best describes the author’s main idea?

A) The FAA’s mandate to promote civil aviation is fundamentally incompatible with its duty to regulate the safety of commercial airline travel.
B) The FAA is the government agency that oversees commercial aviation within the United States.
C) In response to the critics’ claim that the FAA has incompatible mandates, Congress should remove the duty to promote civil aviation from the FAA’s list of responsibilities.
D) Despite claims to the contrary, the FAA’s duty to promote civil aviation is not incompatible with its responsibility to regulate airline safety.
E) The FAA’s decision to continue the practice of allowing lap children will ultimately save lives.

2 
 2. The author refers to the “cost-benefit analysis” ( Highlighted ) undertaken by the FAA most likely in order to

A) summarize the primary responsibilities of the FAA 
B) explain the rationale that underpins a policy decision made by the FAA
C) question the ability of the FAA to balance two competing obligations
D) criticize a policy decision made by the FAA
E) defend the FAA’s ability to successfully manage its list of responsibilities

RC Butler 2021  -  Practice 2 RCs Daily.   
Passage # 28 Date: 20-Jan-2021
 This question is a part of RC Butler 2021 .  Click here for Details

santosh93 · Accepted Answer

I have a concern with the current OA to question-2

According to the passage, 
 
This clearly indicates FAA has a list of responsibilities besides regulating the safety of the airline.

The author brings up a "cost-benefit analysis" to explain the FAA's stance to allow lap-children.

I have an issue with Option-E. Though the word "defend" is attractive but the issue is with later part, it uses the word "successfully" and "list". 
 --Because we don't know if FAA is successful after allowing lap-children and
 --"list of responsibilities", though in the passage it is stated that FAA has more functions but passage only focused on one responsibility i.e. safety. We don't know about the remaining items in the list and how FAA managed them.

I believe Option B is more convincing because of the words it used i.e. explains the reason(rationale) and supports(underpin) FAA's decision(to allow lap-children).

This is my understanding from the passage, I welcome any feedback on this explanation.

RahulHGGmat · Answer

Hi Expert,

Please explain the rationale behind question number 2.

akshaya0002 · Answer

Question 2 explanation pls ??

Posted from my mobile device

03SrishtiAgrawal · Answer

Please explain why option B is not the answer in Q2.

Sajjad1994 · Answer

Official Explanation

2. The author refers to the “cost-benefit analysis” (Highlighted) undertaken by the FAA most likely in order to

Difficulty Level:   700

Explanation

This question asks why the author discusses the FAA’s  “cost-benefit analysis,”  and the line reference places this quoted text in the  third paragraph . Once again, this question does not require any additional research beyond the notes you’ve already taken. According to your notes, the  third paragraph  introduces and explains the author’s position, which is that the FAA’s duties are not incompatible. Because this is a defense of the FAA against the critics who claim that the agency is incapable of managing its competing responsibilities,  (E)  is the correct answer.

(A)  is incorrect because the author’s summary of the FAA’s responsibilities is in the  first paragraph , not the third.

(B)  is incorrect because the author’s primary concern in the  third paragraph  is to defend the FAA, not merely to explain a lone policy decision. While the author offers a justification for the FAA’s position on lap children, she does so in order to support her broader point, which is that the agency is able to balance its responsibilities.

(C)  and  (D)  are incorrect because the author does not  “question”  or  “criticize”  the FAA in the  third paragraph.  Those characterizations are more closely aligned with the critics, whose opinions are discussed in the  first and second paragraphs.

Answer: E

GAngstA · Answer

to describe main ideA of passage , it is needto read whole passage
are main idea of passage in first passage?

Sajjad1994 · Answer

One need to read the whole passage to know the main idea of the passage correctly, First paragraphs usually introduces the topic.

Anush56 · Answer

Explanation for question 1 please ? 
I thought A was correct.

Foreheadson · Answer

Yes, the primary concern is to defend, but this question asks something else. Why did the author mention "cost benefit analysis"? If the question was "why did the author write the 3rd paragraph, than I would answer E.

As per my logic, the author mentioned "cost benefit analysis" not to define primary concern of the passage. The author mentions this to tell us that this analysis took place and the critics just misunderstood how and why the FAA takes it into consideration. For this reason, B seems to be the more correct answer to me.

I would be glad to hear others' thoughts.

arieframadhanm · Answer

"...underpins a policy decision made by the  FAA "

it is not made by FAA, rather it is made by Congress

Akarshkhan86 · Answer

Not by Congress I feel, it is written as the agency's decision making policies.

VerbalBot · Answer

Hello from the GMAT Club VerbalBot!

Thanks to another GMAT Club member, I have just discovered this valuable topic, yet it had no discussion for over a year. I am now bumping it up - doing my job. I think you may find it valuable (esp those replies with Kudos).

Want to see all other topics I dig out? Follow me (click follow button on profile). You will receive a summary of all topics I bump in your profile area as well as via email.

The Federal Aviation Administration, commonly known as the FAA, is the

Prep Toolkit

Top 5 GMAT Debrief Videos

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards

GMAT Reading Comprehension (RC) Questions

The Federal Aviation Administration, commonly known as the FAA, is the

Prep Toolkit

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards