Bunuel
If \(n > 2\) and \(n^4 - 5n^2 + 4 = 20h\), is h an integer?
(1) \(\frac{n}{4}\) is an integer
(2) \(\frac{n}{5}\) is an integer
Solution
Step 1: Analyse Question Stem
• n > 2
• \(n^4 – 5n^2 + 4 = 20h\)
• We need to find if h is an integer.
o Now, n will be an integer only if \( n^4 – 5n^2 + 4 = 20h\) is a multiple of 20.
o i.e. h is an integer if \((\frac{(n^4 -5n^2 + 4)}{20})_R= 0\)
Step 2: Analyse Statements Independently (And eliminate options) – AD/BCE
Statement 1: \(\frac{n}{4}\) is an integer.
• According to this statement: n = 4k, where k is an integer.
• So, \((\frac{(n^4 -5n^2 + 4)}{20})_R= (\frac{4^4*k^4 -5*4^2*k^2 + 4}{20})_R = (\frac{256*k^4 -80*k^2 + 4}{20})_R \)
• Depending on the values of k there can be many cases, for example, consider the following two cases:
o Case 1: if k = 0,
\( (\frac{256*k^4 -80*k^2 + 4}{20})_R =(\frac{0 -0 + 4}{20})_R = 4 \), which is not equal to 0.
o Case 2: if k = 1,
o \( (\frac{256*k^4 -80*k^2 + 4}{20})_R =(\frac{256 -80 + 4}{20})_R = 0 \)
• We are getting two contradictory results.
Hence, statement 1 is NOT sufficient and we can eliminate answer Options A and D.
Statement 2: \(\frac{n}{5}\) is an integer.
• According to this statement: n = 5m, where m is an integer.
• So, \((\frac{(n^4 -5n^2 + 4)}{20})_R= (\frac{5^4*m^4 -5*5^2*m^2 + 4}{20})_R = (\frac{625*m^4 -125*m^2 + 4}{20})_R \)
• There can be two cases:
o Case 1: if m is even, say m = 0,
In that case \( (\frac{625*k^4 -125*k^2 + 4}{20})_R =(\frac{0 -0 + 4}{20})_R = 4 \), which is not equal to 0.
o Case 2: if m is odd, say m = 1,
\( (\frac{625*m^4 -125*m^2 + 4}{20})_R =(\frac{625 -125 + 4}{20})_R = 4 \), which is not equal to 0.
o Thus, h is not an integer.
Hence, statement 2 is sufficient.
Thus, the correct answer is
Option B.The question states that n>2, if we take k=0, that makes n=0 since n=4k.