hD13
Nexior88
Is this question properly phrased? From statement 2, how do we know which cat took 15 seconds to reach the other end? Was it the one with 6m/s or the other one?
It seems the author thinks that the use of the word 'respectively' in Statement 2 implies it is the cat with speed 6m/s. But I think this usage leaves a strong room for ambiguity.
If you assume it was the second cat that took 15 seconds, then u get a different answer.
It's properly phrased !
It was purposefully phrased such that, a reader might consider 6m/sec to be speed of the faster or slower one, and hence lurking the reader to think statement 2 isn't sufficient.
However statement 2 itself is sufficient.
Look at what are we asked in the Question.
6m/sec was just an extra information asking the reader to obtain speed of the other cat as well which isn't required at first place.
If i made you find out the speed of the other cat or made you think the way you just thought , I guess i did a decent job there.
L
Posted from my mobile deviceYou’re right about the mechanics of the question- order of the cats doesn’t matter. I revisited my answer & found that I had made a calculation mistake.
But, I still don’t agree with the phrasing. The use of the word ‘respectively’ is not correct. The proper usage requires you to differentiate between the cats in the preceding sentence. Thus, some readers (if not all) who are looking for that differentiation, upon not finding it, may proceed to the question stem and assume that the first cat is the one with 6m/s speed. This enables them to calculate time t and think that 2nd statement is sufficient, which is also the actual answer. Readers get the right answer without realizing the full scope of the question.
Instead, if you don’t use the word ‘respectively’ at all or simply write it as 'one cat took so much time & the other so much', maybe it could prove to be more confusing for the reader.
Also, more on the use of the word 'respectively':
(Copied & pasted from a standard website. Gmat club is not allowing me to post URLs yet

. Sorry if it makes the post lengthy)
<<
Use of respectively
‘Respectively’ is an adverb that is often misused by non-native English speakers. It means “in the order given” and should only be used if your sentence would be unclear without it.
Example:
Oxygen, nitrogen and hydrogen detector flows were set at 85, 7, and 4 mL/min, respectively.
The use of respectively here makes it clear that the first gas mentioned goes with the first number, the second gas goes with the second number, and the third gas with the third number.
More examples:
BAD: The two values were 143.2 and 21.6, respectively.
GOOD: The two values were 143.2 and 21.6.
BAD: The two tubes were labeled B and S, respectively.
GOOD: The tubes containing blood and saline were labeled B and S, respectively. >>Ps.: The question never ‘lured’ me into thinking that 2nd statement is insufficient, at least not while solving it in limited time. The thought only occurred to me later!