Hi Everyone – I just finished up my application cycle and have been fortunate enough to have the choice to decide between 2 amazing schools: CBS and Sloan. I’m hoping to make the decision soon so as to meet the deposit deadlines and free up my spot for someone on the waitlist as I know how nerve racking that experience can be.
First a little on my background, I’m a bit of a non-traditional candidate. I majored in Economics at a top 10 undergrad institution but then decided to work in the government/non-profit world for 3 years. I’m hoping to use the MBA to transition into Management Consulting in the short run and then VC/PE in the long run. Here are the factors I’m weighing.
Financial Aid This is perhaps the most important factor at the moment. Unforunately, I graduated with a very large undergraduate debt load and my work experience in gov/non-profit has not allowed me to save much. At the moment, neither school has offered scholarships, but there is still a chance at both merit and need based scholarships. My question here is: which school provides the most need-based scholarships? In addition, how do I navigate the financial aid process in anticipation of approaching deposit deadlines? It seems like I would have to make a decision based in incomplete information from both schools…
Career ProspectsBoth schools place well in consulting it seems. However, for a non-traditional candidate, which would provide for the best support system for securing a job at MBB. I’m particularly interested in knowing people’s thoughts on securing internships at top firms at CBS vs. Sloan. What about in the long run trying to get into VC/PE. It seems MIT has the edge in this area but CBS has been placing well lately especially in NYC.
AcademicsBoth schools have a great core curriculum that will be great for someone like me coming in with a non-traditional background. However, Sloan seems to be more quantitative and intense – particularly in that first semester.
Student LifeIt seems that Sloan is more tight-nit and that students there interact more as opposed to Columbia which is larger (in terms of student body) and more spread out. I could see myself being happy at both Cambridge or NYC. I’m from the Midwest and haven’t spent much time at either school, but location wise, NYC might have the slight edge over Boston.
Overall PrestigeSeems like the two schoosl are on par with each other. MIT might have the slight edge in MBA circles, but CBS is recognized more outside the MBA world.
As you can tell this is really going to be a tough decision (especially since I probably won’t know about financial aid till after the deposit deadlines). That being said, I do value the opinions on this forum so any and all feedback would be very much welcomed.