Hi,
Long time lurker here. I'm an international who's been working as a software engineer in the US for 3 years (6 years work ex in total). I'm planning to transition to product management in tech, though I should say that I'm not strongly tied to that and am really open, even eager, to being exposed to other fields and changing direction once I'm in business school. I am sure that I don't want to get into I-banking, that's about it.
I loved all the three schools when I visited. I would put the visit experience as Tepper > Ross = KF , but I wouldn't be out of place at any three, I felt. I will be going to the welcome weekends to get a feel of the incoming class, as well.
Ross
+ Top ranked of the three, with exciting upward momentum
+ Excellent school to get into product management and tech in general
+ A more diverse and exciting class (larger number and more selective)
+ National reach compared to the other two
- The most expensive since no aid. I tried negotiating but no dice.
- Michigan weather (I HATE the cold and is low key miserable during winters)
Tepper
+ Great school for tech, with CMU reputation as well.
+ Really liked the students when I was there, very close knit.
+ New building seems really great, might boost ranking/recruitment even more.
- Class dominated by engineers, other two would be more diverse.
- Pittsburgh seemed a little bleak tbh, compared to Ann Arbor/ Chapel Hill.
- Expensive even with $20k scholarship (Tuition would be $46k after aid)
Kenan-Flagler
+ Loved the community and culture. Students went out of their way to help in everything.
+ Got a full ride, which means I will graduate with much less pressure and a lot more flexibility to move internationally/take lesser paying jobs if I want.
+ Faculty seems to be widely respected - everyone raves about it.
+ The best weather of the three!
- They don't seem to put any emphasis on Tech. I did talk to a couple of students who got into PM jobs with Amazon and other tech giants, but they didn't have a lot of support.
- I am a bit worried by their direction in rankings - they slipped 3 ranks in the last 2 years.
I don't have any strong preferences on where to end up after the MBA, other than wanting to stay in the US. Preferably not in a place with sky high cost of living like NYC/SF/DC.
I apologize for coming across a little vague career-direction wise - that's because I am. I am really looking forward to exploring my options during the MBA and find a niche which excites me. Tech is still the first option because I have some familiarity to it (and the schools were convinced that that it wouldn't be a tough transition for me), but really my first criterion is to have a great MBA experience.
I am also waiting for McCombs at the end of the month. I don't see anything which would put it above these three except that I love Austin, maybe, but for anything less than significant aid, I think I'd pick one of these three.