SajjadAhmad
A city councilman has proposed a controversial new plan to increase city revenues from the parking places downtown. He has proposed that instead of charging $1.20 per hour for parking in these spots, the city should make all parking spots five minute loading zones, and then assess $15 parking fines on anyone who parks in the spots for more than five minutes.
Which of the following, if true, provides the strongest argument that the councilman’s plan will not increase the city’s revenue?A. A system that promotes parking fines will anger citizens, and they will consequently vote the councilman out of office if the plan goes through.
B. The city owns only 14 parking spots in the downtown area.
C. The costs of assessing and collecting the parking fines will surpass the revenues likely to be collected from the new plan.
D. Ray’s parking garage, the only competition for the city-owned parking places downtown, charges $18 per day for its parking places.
E. It has been observed that on an average day, approximately three different cars park in each of the city-owned parking spots downtown.
Source: McGraw-Hill's GMAT (5th)
Council man's plan - the city should make all parking spots five minute loading zones instead of charging 1.20$ per hour.
Assess $15 parking fines on anyone who parks in the spots for more than five minutes.
So we have to find a weakener for the conclusion that the council man's plan will not increase city's revenue.
Prethinking - The council man assumes two things i) removing the 1.20$ per hour parking charge will not decrease the revenue, what if most cars park for less than five minutes then the revenue will not be expected to increase 2) Also what if the cost of assessing the plan is much more than the revenue that will be generated, in that case council man's plan is not likely to increase the revenue. 3) Also it is possible that the number of cars parked decrease so much that revenue is decreased.
Answer choice analysis A. A system that promotes parking fines will anger citizens, and they will consequently vote the councilman out of office if the plan goes through.
the success/failure of the plan doesn't depend on whether council man stays or notB. The city owns only 14 parking spots in the downtown area.-n
o of parking spots will not affect the revenue generated. Even if these 14 parking spots generate more revenue than it is possible that revenue will increaseC. The costs of assessing and collecting the parking fines will surpass the revenues likely to be collected from the new plan.-
in line with our thinking.CorrectD. Ray’s parking garage, the only competition for the city-owned parking places downtown, charges $18 per day for its parking places.
doesn't affect the conclusionE. It has been observed that on an average day, approximately three different cars park in each of the city-owned parking spots downtown.
It doesn't state that whether the number of cars decreased or increased after the plan