Question 10 - Official Solution:
If \(m\) is a positive number and \(n\) is a negative number, and \(|m| > |n|\), then which of the following has the greatest value ?
A. \(|\frac{m - n}{n}|\)
B. \(|\frac{m - n}{m}|\)
C. \(|\frac{m + n}{m - n}|\)
D. \(|\frac{m + n}{n}|\)
E. \(|\frac{m + n}{m}|\)
Probably the easiest wat to solve this problem would be plug the values. Let \(m=2\) and \(n=-1\) (this satisfies conditions given in the stem), then:
A. \(|\frac{m - n}{n}|=|\frac{2 - (-1)}{-1}|=|-3|=3\).
B. \(|\frac{m - n}{m}|=|\frac{2 - (-1)}{2}|=|1.5|=1.5\).
C. \(|\frac{m + n}{m - n}|=|\frac{2 + (-1}{2 - (-1)}|=|\frac{1}{3}|=\frac{1}{3}\)
D. \(|\frac{m + n}{n}|=|\frac{2 + (-1)}{-1}|=|-1|=1\).
E. \(|\frac{m + n}{m}|=|\frac{2 + (-1)}{2}|=|\frac{1}{2}|=\frac{1}{2}\)
As we can see the answer is
option A. Still, to test our absolute value skills, let's also solve the question using absolute value properties. Let's establish two points:
(i) \(|m - n| > |m + n|\)
(this is because it's given that \(m\) is a positive number and \(n\) is a negative number. For example, \((|5 - (-1)| = 6) > (|5 + (-1)| = 4)\)).
(ii) \(|\frac{a}{b}|=\frac{|a|}{|b|}|\). So:
A. \(|\frac{m - n}{n}|=\frac{|m - n|}{|n|}\)
B. \(|\frac{m - n}{m}|=\frac{|m - n|}{|m|}\)
C. \(|\frac{m + n}{m - n}|=\frac{|m + n|}{|m - n|}\)
D. \(|\frac{m + n}{n}|=\frac{|m + n|}{|n|}\)
E. \(|\frac{m + n}{m}|=\frac{|m + n|}{|m|}\)
A and B have the same numerator so let's compare these two options first (
both the denominator and numerator are positive, so the one with smaller denominator will have the larger value). Since given that \(|m| > |n|\), the A > B.
B, C and E have the same numerator, so let's compare these three options next (
again, both the denominator and numerator are positive, so the one with smaller denominator will have the larger value). The denominator of E is less then that of D
(it's given that \(|m| > |n|\)) and since also given that \(m\) is a positive number and \(n\) is a negative number, the denominator of E is also less then that of C.
So, we are left to compare A and E. The numerator of A is greater than that of E
(check (i) above) plus the denominator of A is less than that of E
(it's given that \(|m| > |n|\)), so A > E. Therefore, A has the greatest value.
Answer: A