HumbleBee
Hey all. Long time lurker. First time poster.
I have to echo what others have said about the alum interviews. My interviewer came across as an intellectual snob with an inferiority complex about Booth. "Why is Booth your number one choice above everyone else?" It's almost like it's either them or no one else at all. It's such a loaded question.
I was honest and gave reasons about why Booth was a great fit for me and my goals and talked about classes, and clubs that I was going to participate in, even where I was going to stay! But this wasn't enough.
I won't share the question i got asked which really put me off, but suffice to say, it just made it sound like they wanted hard core finance guys who can price derivatives in their head. I can't do that, and if that's who Booth want, then obviously i'm not going to Booth...shame I really liked what I read. Just didn't translate via this particular alum.
That sounds like a bad experience, HumbleBee. I agree with runnergirl that you should provide feedback to the school.
Keep in mind, however, that interviewers do ask why candidates would choose their schools above all else. It's a valid question and, in essence, is the same question as "If you got into every school you applied to, why would you choose school X?". Back when I interviewed for R1, I expressed an interest in Marketing and I can see why my alum interviewer wanted to know if I'd choose Booth over peer schools (
here're the questions I was asked). At the end of the interview, my interviewer shared with me what she liked about Booth's Marketing and Strategy programs and said that she actually only took one course in Finance!
It's true that Booth does have a strong reputation in Finance. However, it isn't the only strength of the school. I, for one, don't intend to major in Finance and can't price derivatives in my head either, but they still let me in .