Dawna Clarke, head admissions person at Tuck, said (at the diversity conference) they do see the rankings while reviewing your app. In response to the question, does it matter? She said if Tuck, or any other school, was our first choice, then make sure we rank them #1. While her words didn't really reveal anything stunning, the way she said it, and her mannerisms suggested the following subtext: Ya, it fu**ing matters. How much it matters, who knows. And take what I say with a grain of salt, I'm kind of neurotic and could have been reading too much into things.