Brian123
Brian123
Hey
GMATCoachBenI'm wondering if it's a great idea to take a few LSAT tests like you did for a non-expert? The LSAT question are obviously a great resource once official sources have been exhausted, but I'm wondering if taking the LSAT mocks helps. The LSAT sounds much more brutal and taxing than the GMAT and sounds kinda exciting.
I took the LSAT mock on Khan academy today and the analytical reasoning section blew me away (this section is not even close to anything that is tested on the GMAT so I just skipped through it). The RC passages were extremely long and I had to guess on the last 5-6 questions. I was just about able to complete the LR/CR questions (got 41/51 correct). My score turned out to be 159.
Any advice @AndreN,
GMATNinja,
GMATCoachBen,
mcelroytutoring,
MartyTargetTestPrep and other experts on what is the best way to approach LSAT questions? Filtering on GMAT club is definitely a classic way, but I'm wondering if taking LSAT mocks might help. I was definitely much, much more tired while taking the LSAT mock than I've ever been while taking the GMAT/GMAT mocks so LSAT mocks could be good training.
Hello,
Brian123. I think I was supposed to be the person named at the beginning of your list. I agree with the response
GMATCoachBen has given above. Enthusiasm is great; wanting to master CR is an admirable goal. At the same time, I cannot help but caution against feeling as though LSAT questions are somehow
necessary to achieving mastery of GMAT™ CR questions—they are not. I liken the endeavor to a professional athlete, say, a marathoner, deciding to cross-train by cycling. To be an elite marathoner, of course, one
must train to run marathon distances; cycling is just a fun way to exercise.
I know many Experts, including
GMATNinja himself, who get behind this LSAT cross-training notion. However, I have been outspoken against the practice since I started posting, primarily because most students cannot tell the difference between a GMAT™-type question and one that is restricted to the LSAT. (Other Experts who have shared my view include
VeritasKarishma and
RonPurewal.) For more on my own reasoning, see the following posts, a selection from more than a page of responses in which I have referred to the LSAT and offered similar counsel:
1)
15 August 20192)
24 March 20203)
22 June 20204)
20 July 20205)
25 December 20206)
30 March 2021Finally, I think it is important to put the CR task into perspective: You will likely see about 8 such questions on the exam. Is it really necessary to reach beyond
the 1200 or so official CR questions that have been released to do your best on these 8 or so questions? I am skeptical.
Anyway, I do not mean to dampen your enthusiasm. By all means, explore away. Just keep in mind why you are doing it.
- Andrew