OFFICIAL EXPLANATIONProject SC Butler: Sentence Correction (SC2)
THE PROMPTQuote:
Digitized documents have levelled the playing field in humanities scholarship
by removing the need for expensive and time-consuming travel for location of works and meet with other scholars.
• Meaning and construction
The travel is time-consuming and expensive.
The purpose of travel is to do two things that need to be parallel: to
locate and
meet or for
locating and
meeting.
THE OPTIONSQuote:
A) by removing the need for expensive and time-consuming travel for
location of works and
meet• not parallel
→ The use of
location and
meet is not parallel.
ELIMINATE A
Quote:
B)
through the removal of the need for research that requires expensive and time-consuming travel to
locate works and for
meeting• not parallel
Locate and
meeting are not parallel.
• diction and style; rhetorical construction
→
through the removal of is not concise, not idiomatic, and not forceful.
When we want to describe the means by which something was accomplished, we almost always use
CLAUSE + COMMA + BY + GERUND (verbING)
The phrase "by removing," preceded by a comma in options A, C, and D is the standard way to explain how digitized documents have leveled the playing field.
ELIMINATE B
Quote:
C) by removing the need for travel that is time-consuming and
expensive to locate works and meet
• nonsensical
→ the travel is not "expensive to locate works." ("Travel that is . . .)
• more nonsense
→ The phrase
expensive to locate works might belong to "for," in which case the sentence absurdly states that the need "for expensive to locate works" is being removed.
We could say
works that are expensive to locate.At worst, we could say "the need for expensive-to-locate works." Ugh.
Either way is insensible.
ELIMINATE C
Quote:
D) by removing the need for expensive and time-consuming travel to locate works and
[to] meet
• correct
→ This sentence makes
locate and meet
parallel.
→ I see no errors.
By the way, as I have indicated, the word
to "carries over" to or "distributes" to the word
meet.
The travel has two purposes: to locate works and [to] meet with other scholars.
KEEP
Quote:
E)
through the removal of the need for expensive and time-consuming travel,
and for locating works and meeting
• diction and style; rhetorical construction
→
through the removal of creates the same problems as the phrase does in option B
• meaning error
The use of
and distorts the meaning of the sentence by suggesting that the requirement to locate works and meet scholars is also being removed.
ELIMINATE E
The correct answer is D.COMMENTSYet again, this group represents a nicely representative cross-section of the SC Butler crew.
As always, I remind other aspirants that they have a standing invitation to post and absolutely nothing to lose.
I like the fact that the each answer contains at least one slightly distinct thread of analysis: well done!
Future readers can glean lots of resonant details from this thread.
Kudos to all.