Farming practices in the United States have changed since the days of

Question

Project RC Butler 2020  -  Participate and win GMAT Club Tests.   
Passage # 31, Date: 16-Apr-2020
 This post is a part of Project RC Butler 2020 .  Click here for Details

Farming practices in the United States have changed since the days of the traditional family farm. The term “agribusiness” refers to the many businesses associated with modern farming, including machinery, retail sales, and marketing. Agribusiness is often contrasted with the family farm and is associated with the practice of corporate farming, in which the business and corporate aspects of producing food have become more important than the service benefits of buying from a small producer.

At the beginning of the 20th century, family farms produced less food per acre than they do today. The U.S. Department of Agriculture reports that 98 percent of all farms in the United States today are family farms, but large- scale corporate farms supply 14 percent of the country’s total agricultural output. Family farms have historically thrived because smaller production enables farmers to develop close relationships with their customers and then produce goods that satisfy the customers' needs. Operating a smaller farm also enables farmers to collect and utilize information related to their land’s unique productivity.

However, operating a large farm has proven to be beneficial in its business aspects. Larger farms are able to bargain more effectively than smaller farms and can better sustain themselves financially through less productive seasons. Large farms are also able to develop corporate partnerships more readily than smaller farms, so they often have a technological advantage. The development of agribusiness has further benefited large farms because it has fostered the growth of agricultural research departments and associated academic disciplines. This information can, in turn, allow farmers to make business decisions based on proven research. Despite the greater productivity of large farms, many buyers fear that the personal service and individual attention they receive from owners of small farms will soon be lost.    1 
 1. Which of the following statements best summarizes the main idea of this passage?

A. Agribusiness protects family farms from future economic crises.
B. Large farms have a technological advantage because they are able to develop corporate partnerships.
C. Family farms are less productive than large farms.
D. Large farms are on the decline because agribusiness is starting to regulate farm size.
E. Agribusiness benefits large farms but may reduce the amount of personal service that these farms can offer.

2 
 2. The passage implies which of the following about family farms as compared to large-scale corporate farms?

A. Family farms have higher profit margins.
B. Family farms are more likely to develop corporate relationships.
C. Family farms contribute less per farm to the country’s total agricultural output.
D. Family farms contribute more to the international economy.
E. Family farms require more work per acre.

3 
 3. The passage does NOT cite which of the following as a benefit of large-scale farming?

A. A technological advantage due to corporate partnerships
B. Greater bargaining power
C. More environmentally sustainable farming practices
D. More financial stability
E. Greater productivity

AnirudhaS · Accepted Answer

Answers are in  bold .

1. Which of the following statements best summarizes the main idea of this passage?
A. Agribusiness protects family farms from future economic crises.
B. Large farms have a technological advantage because they are able to develop corporate partnerships.
C. Family farms are less productive than large farms.
D. Large farms are on the decline because agribusiness is starting to regulate farm size.
 E. Agribusiness benefits large farms but may reduce the amount of personal service that these farms can offer.

Explanation of question 1 
The main idea of the passage should encompass both sides of the argument. The author says pros and cons of both large and family farms. If a choice has only one side of this explained, it wont be the main idea of the passage as we would soon find out - 
A - only talks about family farms. No mention of the other side (large farms) as we discussed in our summary above.
B - Again talking about only one side
C - Now this talks about both types of farms. However it only constricts itself to one point - less productivity. It does not encompass anything else.
D - Talks only about large firms.
E - Yes this is a more balanced main idea of the passage, although it explicitly talks about effect of agribusiness on large farms.
_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

2. The passage implies which of the following about family farms as compared to large-scale corporate farms?
A. Family farms have higher profit margins.
B. Family farms are more likely to develop corporate relationships.
 C. Family farms contribute less per farm to the country’s total agricultural output. 
D. Family farms contribute more to the international economy.
E. Family farms require more work per acre.

Explanation of question 2 
A - Not mentioned in the passage
B - On the contrary larger firms are more likely to develop coorporate relationships. opposite answer.
C - Passage states - "Agriculture reports that 98 percent of all farms in the United States today are family farms, but large- scale corporate farms supply 14 percent of the country’s total agricultural output. " If it was equal proportion of production then only 2% of of country's total agricultural produce should have come for large farms, as opposed to 14%. This therefore implies family farms contribute LESS PER FARM to the country's total agri produce.
D - Not mentioned
E - Author only mentions family farms produced less FOOD per acre. This does not imply that they require more WORK per acre. (Although this might be true because family farm might not employ the industrial methods of farming).
_______________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

3. The passage does NOT cite which of the following as a benefit of large-scale farming?
A. A technological advantage due to corporate partnerships
B. Greater bargaining power
 C. More environmentally sustainable farming practices 
D. More financial stability
E. Greater productivity

Explanation of question 3 
A - stated in the passage - " Large farms are also able to develop  corporate partnerships  more readily than smaller farms, so they often have a technological advantage."
B - stated in the passage - "Larger farms are able to  bargain more effectively  than smaller farms..."
C - In the passage it only stresses on the fact that how financially viable it is. it does not mentions how environmentally sustainable it is.
D - stated in the passage - "Larger farms are able to bargain more effectively than smaller farms and  can better sustain themselves financially  through less productive seasons."
C is our answer.
E - stated in the passage "Despite the  greater productivity  of large farms,many buyers fear that the personal service and individual attention they receive from owners of small farms will soon be lost."

kris19 · Answer

1. Which of the following statements best summarizes the main idea of this passage?

passage summary: Agribusiness is associated with corporate farming, however there are advantages in the family farming. Even though corporate farming is more productive, service aspect associated with family farming cannot be expected in the corporate farming

A. Agribusiness protects family farms from future economic crises.
 not correct: protecting from future economic crises is not discussed

B. Large farms have a technological advantage because they are able to develop corporate partnerships.
 not correct: this is mentioned in third para

C. Family farms are less productive than large farms.
 not correct: no such comparison is given

D. Large farms are on the decline because agribusiness is starting to regulate farm size.
 not correct: no discussion on regulating farm size

E. Agribusiness benefits large farms but may reduce the amount of personal service that these farms can offer.
 correct: this is close to the passage summary

2. The passage implies which of the following about family farms as compared to large-scale corporate farms?

A. Family farms have higher profit margins.
 not correct: no discussion on profit margins

B. Family farms are more likely to develop corporate relationships.
 not correct: corporate relationships are associated with large farms

C. Family farms contribute less per farm to the country’s total agricultural output.
 correct: The U.S. Department of Agriculture reports that 98 percent of all farms in the United States today are family farms, but large- scale corporate farms supply 14 percent of the country’s total agricultural output

D. Family farms contribute more to the international economy.
 not correct: contribution to the int economy is not discussed

E. Family farms require more work per acre.
 not correct: no discussion on work per acre

3. The passage does NOT cite which of the following as a benefit of large-scale farming?

A. A technological advantage due to corporate partnerships
 not correct: discussed in the third para

B. Greater bargaining power
 not correct: discussed in the third para

C. More environmentally sustainable farming practices
 correct: no discussion

D. More financial stability
 not correct: discussed in the third para

E. Greater productivity
 not correct: discussed in the third para

SiffyB · Answer

1. Which of the following statements best summarizes the main idea of this passage?
 
A. Agribusiness protects family farms from future economic crises.
B. Large farms have a technological advantage because they are able to develop corporate partnerships.
  C. Family farms are less productive than large farms. 
 D. Large farms are on the decline because agribusiness is starting to regulate farm size.
E. Agribusiness benefits large farms but may reduce the amount of personal service that these farms can offer.

(A), (D) and (E) are incorrect statements. So, they are out. Facts stated in (B) and (C) are correct, but we have to choose the main idea between the two. Since, (B) does not even mention small farms (which forms a good part of our discussion), I will rule out (B) as the main idea of the passage. Thus, IMO option (C) is the correct answer.

2. The passage implies which of the following about family farms as compared to large-scale corporate farms?
 
A. Family farms have higher profit margins.
B. Family farms are more likely to develop corporate relationships.
  C. Family farms contribute less per farm to the country’s total agricultural output. 
 D. Family farms contribute more to the international economy.
E. Family farms require more work per acre.

The fact that "The U.S. Department of Agriculture reports that 98 percent of all farms in the United States today are family farms, but large- scale corporate farms supply 14 percent of the country’s total agricultural output" clearly means that family farms have less productivity per farm as compared to large-scale corporate farms. Thus, choice (C) is the correct option.

3. The passage does NOT cite which of the following as a benefit of large-scale farming?
 
A. A technological advantage due to corporate partnerships
B. Greater bargaining power
  C. More environmentally sustainable farming practices 
 D. More financial stability
E. Greater productivity

All of the options except (C) are mentioned in the final paragraph of the passage. The passage does not state that large-scale farming involves sustainable farming practices.

GDT · Answer

Following is the gist of the passage

Para 1 : What is agribusiness and how it is different from family farms/ farming by small producer 
 Para 2 : 98% farms= family farms but 14% supply= large scale corporate farms
 Family farms -2 benefits (service aspects..)
 Para 3 : But corporate farms - benefits (biz aspects)

1. Which of the following statements best summarizes the main idea of this passage?

A. Agribusiness protects family farms from future economic crises.  Incorrect. It is not mentioned 
B. Large farms have a technological advantage because they are able to develop corporate partnerships.  Incorrect. It is mentioned in para 3 but doesn't convey the main idea of the passage 
C. Family farms are less productive than large farms.  Incorrect. It is mentioned in para 2, but it is a very small part of the passage and definitely doesn't convey the main idea of the passage 
D. Large farms are on the decline because agribusiness is starting to regulate farm size.  Incorrect. It is not mentioned in the passage 
E. Agribusiness benefits large farms but may reduce the amount of personal service that these farms can offer.   Correct by POE + It covers the main idea of the passage as it tells us that agribiz is beneficial for large farms but at the same time it lacks the personal service aspect of family farms

2. The passage implies which of the following about family farms as compared to large-scale corporate farms?

A. Family farms have higher profit margins.  Incorrect. It is not mentioned 
B. Family farms are more likely to develop corporate relationships.  Incorrect. It is mentioned for corporate farms 
C. Family farms contribute less per farm to the country’s total agricultural output.   Correct. we are given that family farms own 98% of land but contribute 86% of supply, on the other hand, corporate farms own only 2% land but contribute 14% supply. So, comparatively family farms contribute less supply per acre  
D. Family farms contribute more to the international economy.  Incorrect. It is not mentioned 
E. Family farms require more work per acre.  Incorrect. It is not mentioned

3. The passage does NOT cite which of the following as a benefit of large-scale farming?

A. A technological advantage due to corporate partnerships  Incorrect. It is mentioned 
B. Greater bargaining power  Incorrect. It is mentioned 
C. More environmentally sustainable farming practices   Correct. It is not mentioned  
D. More financial stability  Incorrect. It is mentioned 
E. Greater productivity  Incorrect. It is mentioned

Gowtham91 · Answer

Q1.
A. This is true for Large farms themselves and not for family farms, as mentioned in para3. "Larger farms are able to bargain more effectively than smaller farms and can better sustain themselves financially through less productive seasons."
B. This is true, but this is not the main idea of the passage. 
 C. Correct  Para1 introduces how farming practices are changing over the time and contrasts family farming vs agribusines. Para2 describes about small farms and how their produce/acre is less than large farms. para3 deals with the advantages of large farms and concludes by mentioning that the benefit of small farms will soon be vanished. Hence this is the main idea of the passage. 
D. This can't be inferred from the passage and this can't be the main idea of the passage. 
E. This is a misleading answer choice and partially correct. Agribusiness benefits the large farms but will reduce the personal services offered by Small farms and not large farms.

Q2.
A. No info on profit.
B. This is true for large farms. 
 C. Correct.  From para2, we can infer that 98% of land is family farm but it contributes to only 86% of agricultural produce. This means family farms are family farms contribute less per farm than large farms. 
D. No mention. 
E. Same as D.

Q3. Only  Option C  is not mentioned. It is mentioned that the large farms are financially sustainable but it is not mentioned that they use environmentally sustainable practices.

SSandy066 · Answer

1. Which of the following statements best summarizes the main idea of this passage?

A. Agribusiness protects family farms from future economic crises.
B. Large farms have a technological advantage because they are able to develop corporate partnerships.-only in Para2. wrong
C. Family farms are less productive than large farms.-
D. Large farms are on the decline because agribusiness is starting to regulate farm size.
E. Agribusiness benefits large farms but may reduce the amount of personal service that these farms can offer. -> Correct. 
Explanation:
Para-1 Farming practice in USA. what is agribusiness and Contrast with Family farming.
Para-2 beginning 20th century Product per acre increase in Family farming. Family framing & Large Scale corporate farming % contribution in total USA food production,(contribution per family farm compare to per Large scale corporates farm is less). Benefit of Family farming.
Para 3- Benefit of Large scale corporate farming and buyer doubt.

2. The passage implies which of the following about family farms as compared to large-scale corporate farms?

A. Family farms have higher profit margins.
B. Family farms are more likely to develop corporate relationships.
C. Family farms contribute less per farm to the country’s total agricultural output. ->Correct
Explanation:
Para 2- 98% are total farms(T) in USA are family firm=98%T
 Total contribution of Family firm in USA Total food production(P)=(100%-14%)xT=86%P
 Per family firm contribution=86%P/98%T=0.8776(P/T)
 2% Total farms(T) in USA are Large Scale corporate firms=2%T
 Total contribution of Large Scale corporate firms in USA total food production(P)=14%P
 Per Large Scale corporate contribution=14%P/2%T=7(P/T) 
D. Family farms contribute more to the international economy.
E. Family farms require more work per acre.

3. The passage does NOT cite which of the following as a benefit of large-scale farming?

A. A technological advantage due to corporate partnerships. - Mentioned in Para 3 "....Large farms are also able to develop corporate partnerships more readily than smaller farms, so they often have a technological advantage"-Wrong 
B. Greater bargaining power -Mentioned in Para 3 "...Larger farms are able to bargain more effectively than smaller farms...". Wrong 
C. More environmentally sustainable farming practices. -> Correct 
D. More financial stability. - Mentioned in Para 3 "...Larger farms …...can better sustain themselves  financially t hrough less productive seasons". Wrong 
E. Greater productivity  -Mentioned in Para 3 "... Despite the greater productivity of large farms..". Wrong

yashikaaggarwal · Answer

1. Which of the following statements best summarizes the main idea of this passage?

A. Agribusiness protects family farms from future economic crises.(it's one of the advantage Agribusiness have not the main point)

B. Large farms have a technological advantage because they are able to develop corporate partnerships.(same as A, another advantage not main point)

C. Family farms are less productive than large farms.( One of the effect)

D. Large farms are on the decline because agribusiness is starting to regulate farm size.(Can't be concluded)

E. Agribusiness benefits large farms but may reduce the amount of personal service that these farms can offer.( Introduced and concluded through the passage)

IOC is E

2. The passage implies which of the following about family farms as compared to large-scale corporate farms?

A. Family farms have higher profit margins.(large farm have more profit margins)

B. Family farms are more likely to develop corporate relationships.(Family farm develop close relationship not corporate)

C. Family farms contribute less per farm to the country’s total agricultural output. (Can't be concluded)

D. Family farms contribute more to the international economy.( Can't be true because of size and obsolete method of farming)

E. Family farms require more work per acre.( Because large farm have advance technology while family farm lack that)

IOC is E

3. The passage does NOT cite which of the following as a benefit of large-scale farming?

A. A technological advantage due to corporate partnerships ( True, Given above)

B. Greater bargaining power( could be attained)

C. More environmentally sustainable farming practices(large farm tend to exploit nature because of profitable farming not environmental friendly farming)

D. More financial stability ( Large scale farming make them financial stable)

E. Greater productivity ( large farm have greater productivity)

IOC is C.

Posted from my mobile device

bM22 · Answer

1. Which of the following statements best summarizes the main idea of this passage?

A. Agribusiness protects family farms from future economic crises.
B. Large farms have a technological advantage because they are able to develop corporate partnerships.
C. Family farms are less productive than large farms.
D. Large farms are on the decline because agribusiness is starting to regulate farm size.
E. Agribusiness benefits large farms but may reduce the amount of personal service that these farms can offer.  Correct

Bit confused b/w B & E, but here is my deduction.

Correct Answer - E, 
Explanation - option E is mentioned in the last para as "The development of agribusiness has further benefited large farms because it has fostered the growth of agricultural research departments and associated academic disciplines. This information can, in turn, allow farmers to make business decisions based on proven research. Despite the greater productivity of large farms, many buyers fear that the personal service and individual attention they receive from owners of small farms will soon be lost."
Options A, D: Incorrect as out of scope.
Option C : incorrect, because even though its mentioned in the passage, its not the main idea of the passage.
Option B : incorrect, since its only partly correct, and doesnt contribute to the main idea of the passage.

2. The passage implies which of the following about family farms as compared to large-scale corporate farms?

A. Family farms have higher profit margins.
B. Family farms are more likely to develop corporate relationships. 
C. Family farms contribute less per farm to the country’s total agricultural output.  Correct 
D. Family farms contribute more to the international economy.
E. Family farms require more work per acre.

Correct Answer C. 
Explanation - Option C is mentioned the passage: "The U.S. Department of Agriculture reports that 98 percent of all farms in the United States today are family farms, but large- scale corporate farms supply 14 percent of the country’s total agricultural output.", which implies that even though family farms contribute to 98% of all farms in US, large farms contribute 14% of the supply, which in turn implies that family farms per farm contribute less.
Option A - incorrect as not mentioned in the passage.
Option B,D & E are incorrect as its not the family farm that higher profit margins, or contribute more to the international economy, or equire more work per acre. Its the large farms.

3. The passage does NOT cite which of the following as a benefit of large-scale farming?

A. A technological advantage due to corporate partnerships
B. Greater bargaining power
C. More environmentally sustainable farming practices  Correct 
D. More financial stability
E. Greater productivity

Correct Answer - C 
Explanation - All of the rest of the options are mentioned in the last para as: "However, operating a large farm has proven to be beneficial in its business aspects. Larger farms are able to bargain more effectively than smaller farms and can better sustain themselves financially through less productive seasons. Large farms are also able to develop corporate partnerships more readily than smaller farms, so they often have a technological advantage." Only option C is not present.

Sajjad1994 · Answer

Hello all here are the OAs of this RC

1. E
2. C
3. C

AnirudhaS, bm2201 and GDT you have done good Job. I will update the difficulty level of these questions shortly.

Sajjad1994 · Answer

The difficulty level of these questions is as follow:

1. 600
2. 550
2. 500

Overall 550 (Easy).

Nrj0601 · Answer

OFFICIAL KAPLAN EXPLANATION

Question 1 
Identify the Question Type:
This is a Global question, asking for the main idea of the passage as a whole.

Research Relevant Text:
Since Global questions ask about the passage as a whole, they can be answered from the passage map and analysis of Topic, Scope, and Purpose.

Predict the Answer:
The main idea is the author’s bottom line, or main point. Here, the author‘s Purpose is to outline benefits and drawbacks of corporate farms contrasted with smaller family farms. The main idea expresses that purpose from the author’s point of view: family farms are less productive but have better customer relations and understanding of the land, while large farms are better for business.

Evaluate the Choices:
(E) matches the prediction, and is correct. Overall, the passage looks at how agribusiness benefits large farms but reduces the amount of personal service that these farms can offer. The passage’s final sentence reinforces this idea by saying, “Despite the greater productivity of large farms, many buyers fear that the personal service and individual attention they receive from owners of small farms will soon be lost.”
(A) is incorrect because the passage does not indicate that agribusiness protects family farms, nor can such protection or lack of protection be considered the main idea of the passage.
(B) is something mentioned in paragraph 3, but only as a supporting detail. (B) is too narrow to be considered the passage’s main idea.
(C) is mentioned in paragraph 2, but only as a supporting detail. (C) is too narrow to be considered the passage’s main idea.
(D) is not stated or implied by the passage at all, so it certainly is not the main idea.

TAKEAWAY: With Global questions, be wary of choices that focus on details or that introduce concepts not discussed in the passage.

Question 2 
Identify the Question Type:
This is an Inference question, as indicated by the word "implies."

Research Relevant Text:
The clue in the question stem, "large-scale corporate farms," appears in paragraph 2, in a direct comparison with family farms. Paragraph 2 states that “The U.S. Department of Agriculture reports that 98 percent of all farms in the United States today are family farms, but large-scale corporate farms supply 14 percent of the country’s total agricultural output.”

Predict the Answer:
Large-scale corporate farms represent no more than 2 percent of all farms in the US, yet supply 14 percent of the total agricultural output. That must mean that on average, the family farm supplies less agricultural output per farm than does the average corporate farm.

Evaluate the Choices:
(C) matches the prediction, and is correct. The data cited in paragraph 2 says that only 2 percent of farms are corporate farms, but that they produce 14 percent of the country’s output. It can be inferred that corporate farms produce more per farm than family farms. By reverse reasoning, it can be inferred that family farms produce less per farm than do corporate farms.
(A) is incorrect because the passage does not state or imply that family farms have higher profit margins than corporate farms.
(B) is a 180, as the passage states in paragraph 3 that corporate farms are more likely to develop corporate partnerships.
(D) is incorrect because there is nothing at all in the passage about the international economy. The passage only discusses farming practices in the U.S.
(E) is wrong because the passage does not state or imply that small farms require more work per acre than corporate farms.

TAKEAWAY: Wrong answer choices on Inference questions can exaggerate views expressed in the passage or go beyond the scope of the passage by introducing material not mentioned.

Question 3 
Identify the Question Type:
This is a Detail EXCEPT question. It asks for something NOT cited in the passage. That means the four wrong choices are cited in the passage.

Research Relevant Text:
The question stem refers to benefits of large-scale farming, which can be found in the second and third paragraphs. Look up each answer choice, focusing on those two paragraphs.

Predict the Answer:
The right answer to an EXCEPT question cannot be predicted. Research and eliminate each choice that can be found directly in the text.

Evaluate the Choices:
(C) is correct. The passage does not state that large farms have more environmentally sustainable farming practices.
(A) is mentioned, so it is not the correct choice. Paragraph 3 mentions that large farms are able “to develop corporate partnerships more readily than smaller farms, so they often have a technological advantage.”
(B) is mentioned, so it is not the correct choice. Paragraph 3 mentions that large farms are able “to bargain more effectively than smaller farms.”
(D) is mentioned, so it is not the correct choice. Paragraph 3 mentions that large farms are able “to sustain themselves better financially through less productive seasons.”
(E) is mentioned, so it is NOT the correct choice Paragraph 2 mentions that large farms produce fourteen percent of the country’s total agricultural output even though they comprise less than ninety-eight percent of the country’s farms. This detail suggests that large farms have greater productivity than small farms.

TAKEAWAY: In a Detail NOT question, the four wrong choices will be supported by material explicitly found in the passage. The correct will not.

Farming practices in the United States have changed since the days of

Prep Toolkit

Top 5 GMAT Debrief Videos

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards

GMAT Reading Comprehension (RC) Questions

Farming practices in the United States have changed since the days of

Prep Toolkit

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards