Question 1
AnayB
Hi Experts,
I have tried understanding in terms of the context -
REM -> lots of neural activity ; option E talks about waking up during low levels of neuro-activity sleep which is opposite of REM , how is this the assumption ?
Could someone please explain why option E is the right answer?
Thank-you for taking out the time to explain the same.
Quote:
1. Based on the information in the first paragraph, it is most reasonable to attribute to Snyder which of the following assumptions?
A. Sleep that involves much neural activity is the least restful form of sleep.
There's nothing in the first paragraph (or the entire passage for that matter) about how restful REM sleep is compared to other types of sleep, so (A) can be eliminated.
Quote:
B. The greater the amount of an animal's neural activity, the sharper its perception of the surrounding environment.
The second paragraph does mention that "humans and rats can detect and process information to a surprising degree during REM sleep". However, that doesn't necessarily imply that there's a direct relationship between neural activity and sharpness of the animal's perception of the surrounding environment. And since this information isn't presented in the first paragraph anyway, we can rule out (B).
Quote:
C. REM sleep occurs in most animal species and serves to protect them against predators.
There's nothing in the first paragraph (or in the passage) indicating that REM sleep occurs in MOST animal species, so (C) has to go.
Quote:
D. REM sleep generally does not occur in animals except when they fear a high risk of predation.
The final paragraph suggests that (D) is in fact false: "One would expect that REM sleep would be more prominent in species that suffer high predation or would become so when the perceived risk of predation increases. However, this prediction does not hold."
Regardless, there's nothing in the first paragraph or in the entire passage about the relationship between fear and REM, so (D) is out.
Quote:
E. Animals waking from sleep during low levels of neuroactivity are unlikely to achieve the fastest possible responses.
The first paragraph states that REM "is a state of much neural activity" and that "episodes of REM sleep allow an animal to be ready to escape once awake should a predator attack." The implied assumption here is that episodes of "much neural activity" allow an animal to be ready to escape -- and being ready to escape a predator implies that there's a reasonably fast response time (the sleeping animal reacts before the predator gets to them).
If Snyder is assuming that "much neural activity" means fast response, then he must also be assuming that less neural activity would mean slower response -- which is basically what (E) says in a different way. So (E) is our winner.
I hope that helps!