Freuds essay on the Uncanny can be said to have defined, for our

Question

Freud’s essay on the “Uncanny” can be said to
have defined, for our century, what literary criticism
once called the Sublime. This apprehension of a
beyond or of a daemonic—a sense of transcendence—
 (5)  appears in literature or life, according to Freud, when
we feel that something uncanny is being represented, or
conjured up, or at least intimated. Freud locates the
source of the uncanny in our tendency to believe in the
“omnipotence of thought,” that is, in the power of our
 (10)  own or of others’ minds over the natural world. The
uncanny is, thus, a return to animistic conceptions of
the universe, and is produced by the psychic defense
mechanisms Freud called repression.

It would have seemed likely for Freud to find his
 (15)  literary instances of the uncanny, or at least some of
them, in fairy tales, since as much as any other fictions
they seem to be connected with repressed desires and
archaic forms of thought. But Freud specifically
excluded fairy tales from the realm of the uncanny.
 (20)  “Who would be so bold,” Freud asks, “as to call it an
uncanny moment, for instance, when Snow White
opens her eyes once more?” Why not? Because, he
goes on to say, in those stories everything is possible,
so nothing is incredible, and, therefore, no conflicts in
 (25)  the reader’s judgment are provoked. Thus Freud, alas,
found fairy tales to be unsuited to his own analysis.

However, the psychoanalyst Bruno Bettelheim,
with a kind of wise innocence, has subjected fairy tales
to very close, generally orthodox, and wholly reductive
 (30)  Freudian interpretations. Bettelheim’s book, although
written in apparent ignorance of the vast critical
traditions of interpreting literary romance, is
nevertheless a splendid achievement, brimming with
useful ideas and insights into how young children read
 (35)  and understand.

Bruno Bettelheim’s major therapeutic concern has
been with autistic children, so inevitably his
interpretive activity is directed against a child’s
tendency to withdraw defensively or abnormally.
 (40)  According to Bettelheim, a child’s desperate isolation,
loneliness, and inarticulate anxieties are addressed
directly by fairy tales. By telling the child such stores
themselves, parents strengthen the therapeutic effect of
fairy tales, for in the telling, parents impart to the child
 (45)  their approval of the stories.

But why should fairy tales, in themselves, be
therapeutic? Bettelheim’s answer depends on the
child’s being an interpreter: “The fairy tale is
therapeutic because children find their own solutions,
 (50)  through contemplating what the story seems to imply
about their inner conflicts at this moment in their
lives.” Bettelheim proceeds on the basis of two
complementary assumptions: that children will
interpret a story benignly, for their own good; and that
 (55)  Freudian interpretations will yield an accurate account
of children’s interpretations. The child, questing for
help, and the analyst, attempting to find helpful
patterns in the stories, thus read alike, though in
different vocabularies.    1 
 1. According to the author, Bettelheim believes that fairy tales help troubled children by

(A) creating fantasy worlds into which they can escape
(B) helping them find solutions to their own problems
(C) providing a means of communication with their parents
(D) showing them other problems worse than their own
(E) solving their problems for them

2 
 2. According to the passage, Bettelheim believes that parents’ telling fairy tales to troubled children strengthens the tales’ therapeutic effect because

(A) most troubled children do not read independently
(B) most children believe whatever their parents tell them
(C) the parents’ telling the stories imparts to the children the parents’ sanction of the tales
(D) the parents can help the children interpret the stories according to the parents’ belief
(E) the parents can reassure the children that the tales are imaginary

3 
 3. It can be inferred from the passage that Freud believed that in fairy tales, “nothing is incredible” (line 24) because, in his view,

(A) fairy tales can be read and understood even by young children
(B) everything in fairy tales is purely imaginary
(C) fairy tales are so fantastic that in them nothing seems out of the ordinary
(D) it is uncanny how the patterns of fairy tales fit our unconscious expectations and wishes
(E) the reader represses those elements of fairy tales which might conflict with his or her judgment

4 
 4. According to the passage, Bettelheim believes that when children interpret a story benignly, they

(A) find in fairy tales answers to their own needs
(B) do not associate fairy tales with the uncanny
(C) do not find underlying meanings in fairy tales
(D) are aware that fairy tales are fictions
(E) are reassured by parental approval

5 
 5. Which one of the following best describes the author’s attitude toward Bettelheim’s work?

(A) approving of Bettelheim’s rejection of orthodox and reductive Freudian interpretations of fairy tales
(B) appalled at Bettelheim’s ignorance of the critical traditions of interpreting literary romance
(C) unimpressed with Bettelheim’s research methods
(D) skeptical of Bettelheim’s claim that fairy tales are therapeutic
(E) appreciative of Bettelheim’s accomplishments and practical insights.

Sumi1010 · Answer

Para 1- Freud's interpretation on “Uncanny”
Para 2- Freud excluded fairy tales from the realm of the uncanny.
Para 3- Bettelheim on Freud's exclusion of fairy tales.
Para 4 - Bettelheim’s concern with autistic children.
Para 5- Bettelheim’s answer on therapeutic tales.

1. According to the author, Bettelheim believes that fairy tales help troubled children by

(A) creating fantasy worlds into which they can escape
 (B) helping them find solutions to their own problems 
(C) providing a means of communication with their parents
(D) showing them other problems worse than their own
(E) solving their problems for them

"The fairy tale is therapeutic because children find their own solutions.."

2. According to the passage, Bettelheim believes that parents’ telling fairy tales to troubled children strengthens the tales’ therapeutic effect because

(A) most troubled children do not read independently
(B) most children believe whatever their parents tell them
 (C) the parents’ telling the stories imparts to the children the parents’ sanction of the tales 
(D) the parents can help the children interpret the stories according to the parents’ belief
(E) the parents can reassure the children that the tales are imaginary

"By telling the child such stores themselves, parents strengthen the therapeutic effect of
fairy tales, for in the telling, parents impart to the child (45) their approval of the stories."

3. It can be inferred from the passage that Freud believed that in fairy tales, “nothing is incredible” (line 24) because, in his view,

(A) fairy tales can be read and understood even by young children
(B) everything in fairy tales is purely imaginary
 (C) fairy tales are so fantastic that in them nothing seems out of the ordinary 
(D) it is uncanny how the patterns of fairy tales fit our unconscious expectations and wishes
(E) the reader represses those elements of fairy tales which might conflict with his or her judgment

"in those stories everything is possible, so nothing is incredible, and, therefore, no conflicts in
 the reader’s judgment are provoked. Thus Freud, alas, found fairy tales to be unsuited to his own analysis"

4. According to the passage, Bettelheim believes that when children interpret a story benignly, they

(A) find in fairy tales answers to their own needs 
(B) do not associate fairy tales with the uncanny
(C) do not find underlying meanings in fairy tales
(D) are aware that fairy tales are fictions
(E) are reassured by parental approval

“The fairy tale is therapeutic because children  find their own solutions , through contemplating what the story seems to imply
about their inner conflicts at this moment in their lives.” Bettelheim proceeds on the basis of two
complementary assumptions: that children will interpret a story  benignly, for their own good "

5. Which one of the following best describes the author’s attitude toward Bettelheim’s work?

(A) approving of Bettelheim’s rejection of orthodox and reductive Freudian interpretations of fairy tales
(B) appalled at Bettelheim’s ignorance of the critical traditions of interpreting literary romance
(C) unimpressed with Bettelheim’s research methods
(D) skeptical of Bettelheim’s claim that fairy tales are therapeutic
 (E) appreciative of Bettelheim’s accomplishments and practical insights.

"Bettelheim’s book, although written in apparent ignorance of the vast critical 
traditions of interpreting literary romance, is nevertheless a  splendid achievement,  brimming with
useful ideas "

Sajjad1994 · Answer

Explanation

5. Which one of the following best describes the author’s attitude toward Bettelheim’s work?

Explanation

Paragraph 3  is instrumental in establishing the author’s attitude toward Bettelheim’s work. Phrases like  “wise innocence”  and  “Bettelheim’s book . . . is nevertheless a splendid achievement, brimming with useful ideas and insights. . .”  strongly suggest that our author approves of Bettelheim’s’ work. Hopefully you caught these positive vibes and were able to eliminate

(B), (C),  and  (D)  quickly based on the first word of each:  “appalled,” “unimpressed,”  and  “skeptical”  are just too negative to accurately describe the author’s tone here.

(A)’s “approving”  and  (E)’s “appreciative”  remain, so we must look deeper at these. The rest of  (A) , after its promising start, is contradicted explicitly in  lines 28-30:  The author seems interested in Bettelheim’s work specifically because he did embrace orthodox and reductive Freudian interpretations in his analysis of fairy tales, so  (A)  is an au-contraire choice.  (E)  therefore has to pan out, and it does: it’s simply a paraphrase of the lines cited above regarding the author’s praise of Bettelheim’s insights and accomplishment.

Answer: E

Explanation Credit: Kaplan LSAT

mSKR · Answer

4/5 correct. 
The language in passage is not simple but questions are straightforward. However 5th was little tricky.

1.  B :  The fairy tale is therapeutic because children  find their own solutions , 
2.  C :  the therapeutic effect of fairy tales, for in the telling,  parents impart to the child their approval of the storie s. 
3.  C : B is a close option.  he goes on to say, in those stories everything is possible, so nothing is incredible, and, therefore,  no conflicts in the reader’s judgment are provoked  . I choose C because no conflicts because there was nothign to argur against. Till now it is not mentioned everything was imaginary. So we could n't infer that according to passage.
4.  A  :  The fairy tale is therapeutic because children  find their own solutions ,

TBT · Answer

In Q4. why E is wrong? Is it too extreme?

Sajjad1994 · Answer

(E) , like  (B) , offers faulty use of details—but at least this one is in closer proximity to the relevant issue. While (B)’s  “the uncanny”  appears in  paragraphs 1  and  2 , the issue of parental approval is raised at the end of  Paragraph 4 . However, the relevant issue here, the issue of children interpreting the stories benignly, is unrelated to this and comes nine lines later, deep into  paragraph 5  territory.

VerbalBot · Answer

Automated notice from GMAT Club VerbalBot: 

A member just gave Kudos to this thread, showing it’s still useful. I’ve bumped it to the top so more people can benefit. Feel free to add your own questions or solutions.

 This post was generated automatically.

Freuds essay on the Uncanny can be said to have defined, for our

Prep Toolkit

Top 5 GMAT Debrief Videos

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards

GMAT Reading Comprehension (RC) Questions

Freuds essay on the Uncanny can be said to have defined, for our

Prep Toolkit

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards