Bunuel wrote:
In 2009, Congress mandated that science-based limits be used to prevent overfishing, a move that changed the lives of many commercial fishermen across New England.
A. that science-based limits be used to prevent overfishing, a move that changed
B. that science-based limits will be used to prevent overfishing and change
C. science-based limits are used to prevent overfishing, and it was a move that has changed
D. that science-based limits should be used to prevent overfishing, a move that has changed
E. that science-based limits are used to prevent overfishing, changing
VERITAS PREP OFFICIAL EXPLANATION:
The most prominent decision point in this problem is the choice between “be used,” “are used” and “will/should be used”. While this type of verb choice is usually easy to assess, it is more difficult in this example. When certain verbs are used to express demands or suggestions such as insist, require, recommend, suggest, etc. the verb that follows requires a special conjugation in what is called the subjunctive mood (versus the normal indicative mood). Since these verbs are quite common in language, they are tested regularly on the GMAT and you must be on the lookout for this scenario. The rule is quite simple to learn: if you have a subjunctive verb followed by “that” then the verb that follows should be in the base form (the infinitive form without the “to”).
So in this example you have the subjunctive verb “mandated” followed by “that” so the correct form of the verb is the base form “be” NOT the normal “are” that you would use in the indicative mood. Also, the use of “will” or “should” in (B) and (D) with the verb “mandate” is redundant: the verb already implies that it “will” or “should” be done. Since only (A) uses the correct structure “mandate that limits BE used…”it is correct.