Ncprasad’s MBA Story – Part 3 : Profile Evaluation & School SelectionBy January’07, I was a full-time lurker in the B-school application forum. Just reading posts by the class of 2009 about their application process, decision anxiety and their happiness in getting into their dream B-schools was worth every second that I spent. I was hooked. By February, after much discussion with my wife, I had decided to apply to full-time MBA programs. Having read at least 500 profile evaluations by Paul, Hjort and Scott, I knew it would be difficult to succeed in the admissions process. After I took my 1st GMAT, I submitted a crudely put together profile and waited for Paul’s response. I am reproducing it here from memory as best as I can.
6 yrs work ex, Indian Male IT, 740, 78% in Engg from a top Non-IIT school. Ranked 3rd in graduating class. I don’t remember putting anything about my ECs at that time.
Paul wrote a typically blunt review and basically told me: no shot at elite schools, may be you will get in one due to your GMAT. And don’t even think about UE schools. I pressed Paul to suggest schools where he thinks I might get in. He said UNC was my best-case situation and no school ranked higher than that. Now, UNC is a great school with its own strengths, but I was not thrilled with what I was told. I am bringing this up for one specific reason.
In most cases, people ask for profile evaluations right after they take GMAT or immediately after registering at GMAT club. Typically, profile requests posts are lazily written and with no second thought to what’s being written. I think this is a big mistake. Some of the people with crappy basic profiles(like mine above) in reality have a better profile. By writing a poor evaluation request, they run the risk of applying to schools worse than the schools they are capable of getting into. Simply put, they sell themselves short.
Think about profile evaluation requests as 1-page application files. You need to cover all facets of your candidacy – background, education, EC, Awards, Promotions, Type of Work, Management responsibilities (specify if they are direct/indirect), hardships overcome, Interests or Hobbies and any related accomplishments. Write succinctly, but with good detail. Spend at least a day or two writing your evaluation request and if possible get some one to review it for you before asking Paul or Scott. Do not submit one 15 minutes after you reach home from Pearson. If you want a good example of a well-written profile evaluation request, look for riverripper’s request in the Accepted forum.
4 months after my 1st request, I spent a week writing my second profile request. This time, I spoke in-depth about my goals, my accomplishments, my background, in detail. I included a 5-year and 10-year plan for my career, showed the various steps I see myself taking in my future career and most importantly made a good case for why I want to pursue that career. This time, I got a much more favorable response. I was told that I wont have any trouble getting into Ross, good chance getting into MIT and Wharton, and a may be for HBS. Accordingly, I switched my portfolio. From a reach school, Ross became a definite possibility school(As vindicated by the final decision). Based on the suggestions I received from Hjort, Paul and a few others from another GMAT forum, I came up with this final line-up
Hail Mary - no regrets school : HBS
Stretch school : Wharton
Possible : MIT
Definites : Cornell, Ross, UCLA
Back up : Haas PTDrawn by rhyme’s irresistible charm, I ended up applying to Chicago GSB in addition to this list.
Compare this list with the original portfolio suggested by Paul.
CMU
McCombs
UNC
Babson
MIT (Hail Mary school)In summary, I recommend doing a lot of research prior to making a profile evaluation request. In addition, feel free to go with your instinct and apply to 1 or 2 stretch schools irrespective of what someone says. Your dream school will remain in your dreams if you don’t apply to it. Just combine that with a healthy dose of objective decision-making.