Is x/y 0 (2) y

Question

Is  \frac{x}{y} < xy  ?

(1)  xy > 0

(2)  y < -1

Are You Up For the Challenge: 700 Level Questions

chetan2u · Accepted Answer

\frac{x}{y} < xy xy-\frac{x}{y} >0 \frac{xy^2-x}{y}>0 \frac{x(y-1)(y+1)}{y}>0 This means both the numerator x(y-1)(y+1) and the denominator y have same sign. We have to check for the following cases A) When the denominator or y<0 in \frac{x(y-1)(y+1)}{y}>0 , the numerator x(y-1)(y+1)<0, and we get two cases (i) 0>y>-1, and (y-1)(y+1)<0, Now x*(y-1)(y+1)<0, that is x*(negative)<0. This means x>0....(I) (ii) y<-1, and (y-1)(y+1)>0, Now x*(y-1)(y+1)<0, that is x*(positive)<0. This means x<0.......(II) B) When the denominator or y>0 in \frac{x(y-1)(y+1)}{y}>0 , the numerator x(y-1)(y+1)>0, and we get two cases (i) 00, that is x*(negative)>0. This means x<0....(III) (ii) y>1, and (y-1)(y+1)>0, Now x*(y-1)(y+1)<0, that is x*(positive)>0. This means x>0.......(IV) Our statements should clearly give us one of the 4 options as given above. (1) xy > 0 Both x and y have same sign. So case II and IV possible. But we cannot say whether y falls in the ranges y<-1 or y>1. Insufficient (2) y < -1 Nothing about x. Combined xy>0 and y<-1. Exactly as per Case IV above. Answer is yes. C

TarunKumar1234 · Answer

Is x/y0 Either, x>0 and (y-1/y) >0, it means, x>0 and y>1 or, x<0 and (y-1/y) <0, it means, x<0 and 00 It means, either, x>0 and y>0 or, x<0 and y<0, which doesn't have always, x/yxy. Sufficient. So, I think C.

akadiyan · Answer

Is x/y < xy ?

(1) xy>0
We know that both x and y are of same sign. Both x and y can be positive or both negative.

consider x=2, y=1, then x/y = xy
consider x=1, y=2 , then x/y< xy

we get 2 different answers, so Option 1 - Not sufficient.

(2) y<−1
We do not have any information about X, so Option 2 - Not sufficient.

lets consider 1 and 2 together

From statement 2 we know that y < -1, now since xy >0, we know x is also < 0
we know that both x and y are negative and y < -1. So x/y will always be lesser than xy.

Option 1 and 2 together - SUFFICIENT

Ans C

swatib28 · Answer

chetan2u

Can you please help explain , how did you get into the below

We have to check for the following cases
A) y<0
0>y>-1........(y-1)(y+1)<0, so x>0....(I)
y<-1........(y-1)(y+1)>0, so x<0.......(II)
B) y>0
0<y<1........(y-1)(y+1)<0, so x<0.....(III)
y>1.......(y-1)(y+1)>0, so x>0........(IV)

chetan2u · Answer

Hi

The fraction x(y-1)(y+1)/y>0.
This means both numerator and denominator have same sign. 
Four options are thereafter analysed 
I have added few details in the original post. Please go through it.

swatib28 · Answer

Thank you so much  chetan2u  . I got it now.Just wondering, how are we going to understand the 4 cases which we bifurcated to be analyzed in exam?

GMATGuruNY · Answer

Since both statements indicate that y is NONZERO, y^2>0 , implying that we can safely multiply the question stem by y^2 : \frac{x}{y}*y^2 < xy*y^2 xy < xy^3 Question stem, rephrased: Is xy < xy^3 ? Statement 1: xy > 0 Case 1: x=y=1 In this case, xy = xy^3 , so the answer to the rephrased question stem is NO. Case 2: x=1 and y=2 In this case, xy < xy^3 , so the answer to the rephrased question stem is YES. Since the answer is NO in Case 1 but YES in Case 2, INSUFFICIENT. Statement 2: y < -1 No information about x. INSUFFICIENT. Statements combined: xy > 0 and y < -1 Since xy > 0, we can safely divide the rephrased question stem by xy: \frac{xy}{xy} < \frac{xy^3}{xy} 1 < y^2 The question stem becomes: Is y^2 > 1 ? Since y < -1, the answer is YES. SUFFICIENT. C

Rickooreo · Answer

gmatophobia   chetan2u 
 
Can you please share your approach. Also, (@cheatan2u) can please make me understand why and how to make the two cases as mentioned in the solution provided

gmatophobia · Answer

Here is how I would approach this question.

bumpbot · Answer

Automated notice from GMAT Club BumpBot: 

A member just gave Kudos to this thread, showing it’s still useful. I’ve bumped it to the top so more people can benefit. Feel free to add your own questions or solutions.

 This post was generated automatically.

Is x/y < xy ? (1) xy > 0 (2) y < -1

Prep Toolkit

Top 5 GMAT Debrief Videos

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards

GMAT Data Sufficiency (DS) Questions