Nontraditional black women filmmakers share with the broader community

Question

Nontraditional black women filmmakers share with
the broader community of radical filmmakers a
problematic relation to mainstream, realist cinematic
practice. Realist filmmakers manipulate the use of the
  (5)   camera and techniques of editing and lighting in ways
that create the illusion that cinema is like life, that it
may indeed be the same as life. In contrast, avant-garde
and many minority and feminist filmmakers who seek
to tell new stories resist the conventions of cinematic
  (10)   realism precisely because these practices conceal the
artificiality of the filmmaking process, thereby
implying that narrative structures, and thus social
relations, are inevitable, and that circumstances are as
they should be. For example, precisely because one
  (15)   might expect that a scene depicting a family dinner
would entail a continuous view of several people
seated together eating and conversing, an avant-garde
filmmaker might intersperse images of the dining
family with a seemingly arbitrary image-people
  (20)   standing in a breadline during the Depression of the
1930s, for example. The outcome, according to many
film theorists, is that our notion of reality is violated:
the images do not make immediate sense, and we are
therefore forced to question our convictions about the
  (25)   "reality" to which we are committed. The very
techniques that create the illusion of visual continuity,
some theorists say, smooth over contradictions and
incoherences that might reflect a reality that
Hollywood-and the majority culture that is its
  (30)   audience-does not want to admit or know.

The ideological content of these conservative
cinematic techniques notwithstanding, some
nontraditional black women filmmakers do tend to
explore the formal possibilities of realism in
  (35)   documentaries instead of experimenting with more
daring modes. They may choose to work within the
realist form because it is more accessible to a broad
audience, or because of the financial constraints under
which they labor. It is important to emphasize,
  (40)   however, that the prevailing notion that such
filmmakers cannot be called experimental, because
only technical experimentation counts as
"experimental," places an undue emphasis on form at
the expense of content. A realist work that centers on a
  (45)   nontraditional subject might rightfully be called
experimental in its own way.

For example, Fannie's Film (1981) by Fronza
Woods provides the opportunity for a working woman
to tell her own story. This film belongs to a group of
  (50)   films that, by presenting the stories of "ordinary"
women whose experiences have usually been
trivialized or ignored by mainstream media, expose the
thematic assumptions and stylistic conventions of
realistic filmmaking. Documentaries have also
  (55)   attracted these directors because documentaries
provide opportunities for revising the list of traditionally
acknowledged prominent figures by creating more
accounts of black public figures. Films like Michelle
Parkerson's ... But Then, She's Betty Carter (1980),
  (60)   by examining and preserving the lives and works of
the visual and performing artists who are their subjects,
urge their audiences to question their own expectations
about who gains public recognition and why.    1 
 1. Which one of the following best states the main idea of the passage?

(A) Nontraditional black women filmmakers share with the broader community of radical filmmakers a problematic relation to conservative techniques of editing and lighting.
(B) Some nontraditional black women filmmakers successfully use what are commonly regarded as mainstream cinematic techniques to make experimental films.
(C) Experimental filmmakers manipulate techniques of editing and lighting in order to dispel the illusion that cinema is like life.
(D) Mainstream and experimental filmmakers have not acknowledged the impact of black women filmmakers on cinematic practice.
(E) Mainstream filmmakers prefer to avoid dealing with controversial topics in their films.

2 
 2. It can be inferred that the author of the passage believes which one of the following about the "prevailing notion" (line 40) of what constitutes an experimental film?

(A) The notion mistakenly relies upon a narrow definition of technical experimentation espoused by mainstream filmmakers.
(8) The notion fails to acknowledge the unique potential of conservative cinematic techniques for expressing radical ideas.
(C) The notion pays insufficient attention to the way nontraditional black women filmmakers exploit experimental cinematic techniques in their films.
(D) The notiop ignores the fact that the content of a cinematic work may be as crucial to the work's experimental character as is the work's form.
(E) The notion ignores the fact that the form of a cinematic work may not be as important to the work's mainstream character as is the work's content.

3 
 3. Each of the following is accomplished by one of the documentary films described by the author of the passage EXCEPT:

(A) calling the thematic assumptions of realistic filmmaking into question
(B) examining the lives of black public figures who have not received substantial public recognition
(C) examining the lives of women neglected by mainstream media
(D) influencing how women are portrayed in mainstream media
(E) moving audiences to question their assumptions about why certain people are denied public recognition

4 
 4. It can be inferred from the passage that the theorists referred to in line 27 would most probably agree with which one of the following statements about mainstream filmmakers?

(A) Most of them cater to audiences who are not sufficiently knowledgeable to be able to appreciate films that employ experimental techniques.
(B) Some of them seek to combat majority culture ignorance about minority cultures.
(C) Many of them make films whose techniques conceal from audiences what those audiences would prefer not to know.
(D) They usually do not exploit the documentary form because this form relies less on techniques that create illusions of visual continuity.
(E) They do not make many experimental films because they are not knowledgeable about the techniques of experimental filmmaking.

5 
 5. The primary purpose of the passage is to

(A) contrast and assess some of the works of nontraditional black women filmmakers
(B) critique the subjects and techniques of realist filmmaking
(C) define which black women filmmakers can be considered experimental
(D) examine the relationship of nontraditional black women filmmakers to realist cinematic practice
(E) contextualize and categorize the works of avantgarde and feminist filmmakers

Sajjad1994 · Answer

Explanation

1. Which one of the following best states the main idea of the passage?

Explanation

A)  This option partially captures the idea that nontraditional black women filmmakers resist mainstream cinematic practices. However, it is too narrow because the passage suggests that this problematic relation is not limited to editing and lighting techniques, but rather is a broader issue with realist cinematic practice.

B)   This option accurately reflects the idea that some nontraditional black women filmmakers use mainstream cinematic techniques in their films, but it goes further to suggest that they use these techniques in experimental ways. It also acknowledges the idea that the prevailing notion of what counts as  "experimental " places an undue emphasis on form at the expense of content.

C)  This option misrepresents the main idea of the passage because it is too narrow. While it is true that experimental filmmakers often manipulate techniques of editing and lighting, this is not the main focus of the passage. Additionally, the passage suggests that some nontraditional black women filmmakers do not reject realist techniques altogether.

D)  This option is inaccurate because the passage does not discuss whether or not mainstream or experimental filmmakers have acknowledged the impact of black women filmmakers on cinematic practice. The passage is focused on the relationship between nontraditional black women filmmakers and realist cinematic practice.

E)  This option is inaccurate because the passage does not suggest that mainstream filmmakers avoid controversial topics in their films. The passage is focused on the relationship between nontraditional black women filmmakers and realist cinematic practice.

Answer: B

Sajjad1994 · Answer

Explanation

2. It can be inferred that the author of the passage believes which one of the following about the "prevailing notion" (line 40) of what constitutes an experimental film?

Explanation

(A)  This statement aligns with the author's criticism of the prevailing notion. The author suggests that the prevailing notion of experimental filmmaking relies on a narrow definition of technical experimentation, which is espoused by mainstream filmmakers.

(B)  While the passage discusses the use of conservative cinematic techniques by some nontraditional black women filmmakers, it doesn't directly address whether the prevailing notion acknowledges their potential for expressing radical ideas. It focuses more on the definition of experimental filmmaking.

(C)  The passage doesn't explicitly discuss whether the prevailing notion pays attention to how nontraditional black women filmmakers use experimental cinematic techniques. It's more concerned with the definition of experimental filmmaking itself.

(D)   This statement aligns with the author's criticism. The author suggests that the prevailing notion of experimental filmmaking places an undue emphasis on form at the expense of content, which implies that the content is as crucial to a work's experimental character as its form.

(E)  This statement does not accurately capture the author's argument. The author is more concerned with the prevailing notion's emphasis on form and how it affects the classification of films as experimental, rather than the relative importance of form and content in mainstream cinema.

Answer: D

Raman109 · Answer

1. Which one of the following best states the main idea of the passage?

(A) Nontraditional black women filmmakers share with the broader community of radical filmmakers a problematic relation to conservative techniques of editing and lighting. - While yes some part of this option highlights a broader issue, there is a big problem with respect to some "Nontraditional black women filmmakers" who use conservative techniques but at the same time focus on non-traditional subjects such as working women, black public figures rather than using the flashy traditional actors to differentiate their work still. So yes, while some "Nontraditional black women filmmakers" are at odds with "radical filmmakers" because some "Nontraditional black women filmmakers" use conservative techniques (that are at odds with radical filmmakers), the result of work created by "Nontraditional black women filmmakers" is similar to "radical filmmakers" as it still challenges the conventional filmmaking which creates an illusion =12.0pt that cinema is like life .

(B) Some nontraditional black women filmmakers successfully use what are commonly regarded as mainstream cinematic techniques to make experimental films. - Yes. It's experimental because while it uses conservative techniques (the form), the subjects are different (working women, black public figures) than what typical Hollywood movies will use.

(C) Experimental filmmakers manipulate techniques of editing and lighting in order to dispel the illusion that cinema is like life. - Yes, they do, but it's limited in scope.

(D) Mainstream and experimental filmmakers have not acknowledged the impact of black women filmmakers on cinematic practice. - We don't know. Out of scope.

(E) Mainstream filmmakers prefer to avoid dealing with controversial topics in their films. - Out of scope.

CodingGmat · Answer

It can be inferred that the author of the passage believes which one of the following about the "prevailing notion" (line 40) of what constitutes an experimental film?

(A)  The notion mistakenly relies upon a narrow definition of technical experimentation espoused by mainstream filmmakers. ->  Close. But the can we be sure here that the notion relies on a narrow definition of technical experimentation? What is the definition here? Also this option talks about the definition of technical experimentation, while the prevailing notion is about being termed as experimental. A better option could have been that "the notion mistakenly relies upon a narrow definition of classifying a film/ filmmaker experimental". Nowhere does the notion use the definition of technical experimentation. Instead it relies on "being experimental" part. Nonetheless a tricky option.

(B)  The notion fails to acknowledge the unique potential of conservative cinematic techniques for expressing radical ideas.  -> Nope. The notion doesn’t question that the conservative techniques do not have the potential to express radical ideas.

(C)  The notion pays insufficient attention to the way nontraditional black women filmmakers exploit experimental cinematic techniques in their films.  -> The notion doesn’t only revolve around nontraditional balck women. Instead is applied for all filmmakers.

(D)  The notion ignores the fact that the content of a cinematic work may be as crucial to the work's experimental character as is the work's form. ->  Correct! As mentioned in the passage, the content can make a mainstream work featuring an unconventional subject can be marked as experimental.

(E)  The notion ignores the fact that the form of a cinematic work may not be as important to the work's mainstream character as is the work's content.  -> Nowhere is it mentioned that the form of a work is NOT as important as the content. Instead it is indicated that the work's content is often ignored/ not acknowledged to classify a work as experimental.

A 750+ question in my opinion.

Utkersh · Answer

Can you please post explanation of Q5?

samarpan.g28 · Answer

Hi  Utkersh , let me help you. Let us focus on the first few lines of paragraph 2, see here " The ideological content of these conservative cinematic techniques notwithstanding, some nontraditional black women filmmakers do tend to explore the formal possibilities of realism in (35) documentaries instead of experimenting with more daring modes. They may choose to work within the realist form because it is more accessible to a broad audience, or because of the financial constraints under which they labor. "

Now focus on these two lines " ....some nontraditional black women filmmakers do tend to explore the formal possibilities of realism in (35) documentaries.... " and " They may choose to work within the realist form because it is more accessible to a broad audience.... ".

What does option (D) say? " examine the relationship of nontraditional black women filmmakers to realist cinematic practice " which means there must be some relation between nontraditional black women filmmakers to the realistic cinema which we will examine. The above two lines clearly suggest that they do practice realism in filmmaking. Now they primarily focus on documentaries but that is also one kind of cinematic practice, isn't it? Therefore, option (D) perfectly aligns with the primary purpose of the passage.

Hope this helps.

Sajjad1994 · Answer

Explanation

3. Each of the following is accomplished by one of the documentary films described by the author of the passage EXCEPT:

Explanation

This is an EXCEPT question so find something not proved by the passage.

A.  Mentioned explicitly:  "expose the thematic assumptions and stylistic conventions of realistic filmmaking" (line 51-53).

B.  Michelle Parkerson's film is described as examining black public figures and urging audiences to question who gains recognition.  B  is correct

C.  Fannie's Film tells stories of  "ordinary"  women whose experiences were ignored or trivialized by mainstream media.  C  is correct.

D.  The passage does not say these films change or influence how women are portrayed in mainstream media. The passage states these documentaries tell stories that were ignored or trivialized by mainstream media and urge questioning assumptions, but it does not claim the documentaries directly influence mainstream media portrayals. Hold on.

E.  This is directly stated about Michelle Parkerson's film (lines 58-62).

Answer: D

Sajjad1994 · Answer

Explanation

4. It can be inferred from the passage that the theorists referred to in line 27 would most probably agree with which one of the following statements about mainstream filmmakers?

Explanation

(A)  The passage does not mention the knowledge level or sophistication of the audience as a reason for mainstream filmmakers' choices. The theorists' critique focuses on the effect of hiding reality, not audience sophistication. So  (A)  is not supported.

(B)  The passage clearly separates mainstream filmmakers (Hollywood) from minority/feminist/avant-garde filmmakers. The theorists criticize mainstream filmmakers for smoothing over contradictions and hiding uncomfortable realities. No suggestion mainstream filmmakers aim to fight ignorance about minorities. So  (B)  is not supported.

(C)  This aligns exactly with the passage, especially  lines 29-31.  The theorists say the visual continuity conceals contradictions that Hollywood and its audience  "does not want to admit or know."  This matches the theorists’ view perfectly.

(D)  The passage says nontraditional black women filmmakers use documentaries for formal possibilities and accessibility. But the theorists’ statement about mainstream filmmakers is about techniques smoothing over contradictions, not about whether they use documentaries. No mention that mainstream filmmakers avoid documentaries for this reason. So  (D)  is unsupported.

(E)  The passage does not mention lack of knowledge as a reason. It critiques ideological content and audience preferences, not knowledge. So  (E)  is unsupported.

Only  (C)  matches the passage and the theorists' argument that mainstream filmmakers use techniques to conceal realities audiences prefer not to face.

Answer: C

Sajjad1994 · Answer

Explanation

5. The primary purpose of the passage is to

Explanation

The passage does mention specific films, but the focus is not mainly on contrasting or assessing specific works in detail. It’s more conceptual, about their overall relation to realism and filmmaking practices. So  (A)  is too narrow and not the main purpose.

(B)  The passage explains realist filmmaking and critiques it from the viewpoint of radical filmmakers. But this is only part of the passage—the passage also discusses how some black women filmmakers work within realism, not just critique it.

(C)  The passage touches on debates about experimental filmmaking and the role of form vs. content. But defining who counts as experimental is a smaller, secondary point. Not the main focus. So is too narrow.

(D)  This fits well: the passage opens with the problematic relationship to mainstream realist practice. It discusses how some resist it (avant-garde) while some work within it (documentaries). It also explains why and how they do this.

(E)  The passage mentions avant-garde and feminist filmmakers, but the main focus is on nontraditional black women filmmakers. Avant-garde and feminist filmmakers are introduced mainly as a broader group that shares some characteristics. So  (E)  is too broad and not central.

Answer: D

VerbalBot · Answer

Automated notice from GMAT Club VerbalBot:

A member just gave Kudos to this thread, showing it’s still useful. I’ve bumped it to the top so more people can benefit. Feel free to add your own questions or solutions.

This post was generated automatically.

Nontraditional black women filmmakers share with the broader community

Prep Toolkit

Top 5 GMAT Debrief Videos

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards

GMAT Reading Comprehension (RC) Questions

Nontraditional black women filmmakers share with the broader community

Prep Toolkit

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards