3 mins to all correct. A pleasing passage.
Gist:
A dilemma regarding the return of cultural artifacts to the countries they were stolen from is presented. The advocates for the movement argue that the cultural significance can only be understood near the origin of the artifacts. However, the museums in Britain and France argue that the artifacts are safe there versus in some backwater country where the artifacts would perish. The second point of these museums is that more people can see the artifacts when they are in their possession. The final paragraph, however, makes some headway to clear the dilemma by presenting evidence that even when the two arguments presented by the museums fail they are still reluctant to return the stolen artifacts.
Always tricky to answer such a question. We need to understand what the main point of the passage is and also see how the author of the passage ends the passage. ( To understand what could it be named)1. Of the following, the most appropriate title for the passage above would be:A. The Elgin Marbles: Timeless Symbols of the Glory That Was Greece
Too far away from the crux of the passage. The marbles were just one example.B. The Role of Great Museums in the Preservation of Cultural Artifacts
Again, 180 opposite of what the author finally ends the passage with.C. Repatriation of Cultural Treasures: The British Museum’s Dirty Little Secret
BINGO - the main topic is "Repatriation of cultural treasures" and the passage ends with the case of reluctance by the British museum even though all the conditions are being met.D. The Value of Cultural Treasures in Defining National Identity
Too vague and again departing from the main point highlighted above.E. A Curious Curator: Lord Elgin and the Rise of the British Museum
Discard for same reason as option (D).Pretty straightforward question since the passage has a palpable flow.2. The third paragraph plays what role in the passage?A. It summarizes all the points expressed in the first two paragraphs.
No such summary is given.B. It raises new arguments that expand on those previously expressed.
Third para does not expand the previous arguments but rather opposes them.C. It suggests a possible area for useful research in the future.
Laughably wrong.D. It rejects the arguments expressed in the first paragraph.
TRAP - while it does reject the arguments of the Museums we need to be careful to see that the first para presents both sides of the aisle and hence this is wrong.E. It provides concrete evidence against arguments expressed in the second paragraph.
BINGO - the second paragraph reveals the arguments used by the museums and the third paragraph gives evidence against those. Perfect.Similar reasoning type question. We are looking for a well established popular museum asking back cultural heritages which have originated in it's country and this request is being denied by another imerial museum whose country had stolen said artifacts. Once we know what to look for this questions becomes easy to tackle. Otherwise it is like searching a needle in a haystack.
3. The situation involving the repatriation of the Elgin Marbles to Athens is most similar to which of the following?A. A Native American tribe in Oregon requests that a museum in Chicago return some ceremonial masks that could help in fundraising efforts to build a proposed museum in Portland.
No well established museum. Discard.B. The nation of Peru in South America threatens the nation of Ecuador with military action if Ecuador does not hand over various gold artifacts of the Inca Empire, which originated in Peru.
Vague as there is no museum involved at all! Discard.C. The National Archeology Museum of Cairo in Egypt requests that the Louvre return eight mummies from the time of Ramses the Great for the Cairo Museum’s new exhibit hall dedicated to artifacts from Ramses’ court.
Looks good. National Museum must be pretty well funded and popular.D. The nation of Greece requests the nation of Turkey to provide Greek archeologists with free access to ancient Greek sites on the Ionian coast of Turkey, and to transfer any cultural artifacts found there to the National Archeology Museum in Athens.
Again, no museum involved and a whole bunch of unrelated stuff. Discard.E. A museum in Baton Rouge, Louisiana, requests that the Texas History Museum in Austin, Texas, send the original “Lone Star” flag to Baton Rouge for a new exhibit entitled, “Texas: Our Neighbor to the East.”
TRAP - the Baton Rouge museum would definitely not be as popular / well funded as the one in Austin ( ofcourse it helps to know that Baton Rouge is a small city as compared to Austin which is the capital of Texas) - hence does not fit the analogy we are looking for.Hope it helps.