goforgmat wrote:
CrackVerbalGMAT wrote:
let us simplify the argument given --
1. Facing danger ONLY BECAUSE it affords a certain pleasure --> not Courage -------------(1)
2. Real Courage --> In attaining a goal, a person perseveres in the face of fear prompted by one or more dangers involved -----------(2)
let us look at the answer options now --
Option A - Incorrect
We cannot infer anything about situations that involve "future pain". What if in such a situation, the person perseveres in the face of fear? Then he/she would indeed be courageous according to point #2.
Option B - Incorrect
But what if the person does indeed persevere in face of those one or more dangers? Then he/she would indeed be courageous according to point #2.
Option C - Incorrect
This is an incorrect reading of point #1. If the person faces danger ONLY for pleasure, then he/she cannot be called courageous.
In this case, what if the person ALSO perseveres in the face of fear prompted? That person would then be courageous.
Option D - Correct
This option reads --
A person who faces danger in order to benefit others is acting courageously --> Afraid of the danger
This is more or less, a restatement of point #2. Let us read point #2 carefully. Point #2 talks about courage in ANY situation. The necessary condition involves two things -- 1. fear of the danger 2. perseverance in the face of such fear.
Hence, "afraid of the danger" has to be A necessary condition, the other being "perseverance in the face of such fear". This is true because WITHOUT being afraid of the danger, there is no real courage.
Option E - Incorrect
"cannot be said to be courageous in any situation" -- too extreme. What if the person fears some situations that others do not fear and perseveres? He would then be said to be courageous in THOSE situations.
I dont understand why C is wrong. Please explain your reasoning in detail!
Why is (C) wrong? Well, the text does say that a person who faces danger just for pleasure is not showing courage, at least not in that situation. Answer choice (C), however, goes beyond that. It does not say that the person is facing danger only for pleasure, rather it says that the person
happens to derive pleasure from the danger. Additionally, even if the person is a risk junkie, that does not mean that the person is never courageous. Perhaps he or she engages in risk sports for fun on the weekend but works as firefighter during the week, rescuing people from burning buildings despite the danger involved. Answer choice (C) goes beyond what is stated in the passage.