First the easy eliminations- As GMATGuruNY, DmitryFarber, IanStewart and others have explained, it makes no sense to say that birth defects are higher. (See
https://gmatclub.com/forum/statistician ... l#p2553473)
If someone said that birth defects are higher, we would understand what they meant, but the language is careless and imprecise.
We can eliminate (A), (B), and (D) immediately. This is the easy part of the question.
The choice between (C) and (E) is a harder one.Quote:
...; birth defects,
children's cancer, and altered birth ratios of males and females are much higher in mining than in non-mining communities.
(C) cancer among children, and altered birth ratios of males and females occur much more frequently
(E) altered male and female ratios at birth, and cancer among children occur much more
The differences between (C) and (E) are
- "altered birth ratios of males and females" vs "altered male and female ratios at birth"
- "occur much more frequently" vs "occur much more"
Is it better to say "altered birth ratios of males and females occur much more frequently"? (As in C)
Or is it better to say "altered male and female ratios at birth occur more"? (As in E)
The official OG explanation gives three reasons why (C) is better:
(1) "The meaning of altered male and female ratios is unclear, as opposed to altered birth ratios of males and females."
(2) In (E), "the modifier at birth implies, nonsensically, that the ratios were altered at the time of birth."
(3) "Furthermore, male and female ratios implies that the ratios themselves are of male or female gender."
Posted from my mobile device