Harry started a 6-mile hike with a full 10-cup canteen of wa

Question

Harry started a 6-mile hike with a full 10-cup canteen of water and finished the hike in 2 hours with 1 cup of water remaining in the canteen. If the canteen leaked at the rate of 1 cup per hour and Harry drank 3 cups of water during the last mile, how many cups did he drink per mile during the first 5 miles of the hike?

(A) 4/5 
(B) 5/6
(C) 1
(D) 6/5
(E) 5/4

HowManyToGo · Answer

A.

No of cups leaked during the trip = 2 cups.
No of cups Harry drank = 7 cups.
No of cups harry drank during the first 5 miles = 4.
drink / mile = 4/5

HMTG.

baer · Answer

since the trip took 2 hours total, and it says that the canteen leaked at 1 cup per hour, you know that 2 cups leaked. You also know that he drank 3 cups at the last mile... so he had 4 cups during the first 5 miles... answer is A 4/5

virupaksh2010 · Answer

10 cups at beginning.

1 cup remaining at end so total 9 cups of water lost

1 cup per hour leakage , so in 2 hrs 2 cups of water lost

9-2 = 7

last 1 mile he drank 3 cups , so for first 5 miles total water used = 7-3 = 4

so per mile 4/5

AmritaSarkar89 · Answer

How many of us lost our cool looking at the questions. 
Well I did, I had faced this during a test and blah I hate these long questions.

Anyways assuming this is a super simple question I will really focus on the understanding and breaking down the question in the hour of need.

Initial data
Total mile=6
Total time=2 hours
total reserve =10 cups
remaining reserver =10-1=9 cups

Due to leakage lost canteen cups =2
Drank in last stint=3
Total canteen lost+used=5
Remamining canteen =9-5=4
miles in question =5

Hence the ans=4/5

GMAT Please give me such questions in the main test.

arhumsid · Answer

I read all of the explanations above and i wasn't convinced on one thing. I had the below reasoning while solving this question and never reached the correct answer. Plz tell me whats wrong with this:

The question asked about the  first 5 miles  of the trip. So, IMO, the quantity of water that was lost  due to  because of the leak should also be calculated  for the first 5 miles and not for the complete trip . Thus the water lost would be less than 2.

Here's what i calculated:
Total water initially = 10 cups
Total water used (including leak) in 6 miles = 9 cups
Total water used (including leak) in first 5 miles = 9-3 = 6 cups

Problem starts here (all say 2 cups leaked and subtract it from 6 to get 4, i differ)

Time taken to cover first 5 miles:  \frac{5}{3}  hours (speed is 3 mph)
Water leaked in 5/3 hours:  \frac{5}{3}  cups (leak speed is 1 cup per hr)
Total water he drank during the first 5 miles:  6-\frac{5}{3}  cups
 =  \frac{13}{3}  cups
Water drank per mile during the first 5 miles:  \frac{13}{15}

Why am i wrong?

ivangerz · Answer

Hi, this was my solution and I was wondering why it is not correct:

Before hike : 10 cups
After hike : 1 cup
 - after hike, he had to drink 3 cups so we know that he had 4 cups at the 5 hour mark.
@5 hour mark : 4 cups

Therefore, for the first 5 hours, the total rate of water loss is  6/5  (10 - 4 cups per 5 miles)

Since we know that water is leaking at 1 cup per hour and he finished the hike in 2 hours, 
1cup/hr * 2hrs/6miles =  1/3  (1 cup per 3 miles) --> rate of water leak.

To solve the amount of water he drank per mile during the 5 hour span:

6/5 = 1/3 + x
x = 15/15 = 1

Please let me know why this is wrong. Thanks so much!

ziwith · Answer

Used 9 cups of water during 6 mile hike. 
Given: 3 cups were used during the last mile. 
So 6 cups of water were used during the first 5 miles

If 6miles take 2 hours to complete then 5miles takes 5/3 hours(1.6hrs) to complete. During 1.6 hours, 1 cup of water is lost. So the water drank by him is 5 cups during the first 5 miles.

Therefore number of cups he drank per mile during the first 5 miles is (5/5)=1

Correct me if I'm wrong.

bumpbot · Answer

Automated notice from GMAT Club BumpBot:

A member just gave Kudos to this thread, showing it’s still useful. I’ve bumped it to the top so more people can benefit. Feel free to add your own questions or solutions.

This post was generated automatically.

Harry started a 6-mile hike with a full 10-cup canteen of wa

Prep Toolkit

Top 5 GMAT Debrief Videos

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

GMAT Problem Solving (PS) Questions

Harry started a 6-mile hike with a full 10-cup canteen of wa

Prep Toolkit

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia