Given that x is a positive integer, what is the greatest common diviso

Question

Given that x is a positive integer, what is the greatest common divisor (GCD) of the two positive integers, (x+m) and (x-m)?

(1) m^2 – 10m + 16 = 0
(2) x + 26 is a prime number.

ENGRTOMBA2018 · Accepted Answer

Given x >0 and is an integer. GCD (x+m, x-m)=?

1. Statement 1 gives m=8 or 2.

This is not sufficient as follows:

Assume x is 16 .

Then we get x+8=24, x-8=8 : GCD =8

But GCD (16+2,16-2)=2

Thus not sufficient

2. Statement 2 tells x+26= prime

Thus x+26 = 29,31,37,41,43... giving x=3,5,11,15,17...

Again, this is not sufficient as m can be any value.

Combining, we get m=2 or 8 and x=3,5,11,15,17...

we see that GCD (x+8,x-8)=1, take x=11, GCD(19,3)=1, similarly, x=15, GCD (23,7)=1 etc.

and GCD(x+2,x-2)=1 , take x=3, GCD(5,1)=1, similarly, x=15, GCD (17,13)=1 etc.

GCD =1 is the only possible soution and thus C is the correct answer.

chetan2u · Answer

Hi,

lets look at the statements..
1) first statement gives value of m as 8 or 2...
so the two numbers become x+8 and x-8 or x+2 and x-2..
this tells us that either the difference in number is 16 or it is 4 and the two numbers are either both even or both odd...
what does this tell us? it tells us that  the numbers will have some common even GCD if x is even or the two numbers will be coprime if the two numbers are odd, giving GCD as 1 ... INSUFF
2) x+26 is a prime number and x is a +ive int..  x has to be odd .. in suff

combined we know X is odd and as explained in stat 1 , the GCD will be 1.. suff
C

reto · Answer

Statement 1: (m-2)(m-8)=0 >> m can be 8 or 2 > insufficient
Statement 2: x+26 = prime >> x can be 1, or 3 or 5...

Together: We have two statements which do not complete each other. No further information can be extracted. Answer E.

ENGRTOMBA2018 · Answer

Reto, per statement 2, how can x be 1 when x+26= prime? This will give you 1+26=27 and 27 is not a prime number.

reto · Answer

Yes you are right. I need to focus more

MBAHopeful99 · Answer

1) Factor this equation, and you find out that m is equal to 2 or 8.
m^2 – 10m + 16 = 0
(m-8)(m-2)=0
m=8
m=2

This doesn't help, since you still don't know x.  Insufficient.

2) From this, you can see that x can be 3, 5, 11 etc. x must be an odd number. However, this doesn't say what m can be.  Insufficient.

Using both of these together in (x+m) and (x-m):
Using 3 and 2, you get 5 and 1. The GCF is 1.
Using 5 and 2, you get 7 and 3. The GCF is 1.
Using 3 and 8, you get 11 and 5. The GCF is 1.
Using 5 and 8, you get 13 and 3. The GCF is 1.

Remember to use ZONEF (Zeros, One, Negatives, Extreme, and Fractions) (only extreme applies). I used 101 as a prime, so x is 75.
Using 75 and 2, you get 77 and 73. The GCF is 1.
Using 75 and 8, you get 83 and 67. The GCF is 1.

Answer is C.

GMATinsight · Answer

Given: x is a Positive integer and m is an Integers and x>m (because x-m is a positive iteger)

Question : Greatest common divisor (GCD) of the two positive integers, (x+m) and (x-m)?

Statement 1 :m^2 – 10m + 16 = 0 
m^2 – 8m - 2m + 16 = 0
i.e. m(m – 8) - 2(m - 8) = 0
i.e. (m-8) (m-2) = 0
i.e. m = 2 or 8
@x=9 and m=2, (x-m) = 7 and (x+m) = 11 i.e. GCD = 1
@x=8 and m=2, (x-m) = 6 and (x+m) = 10 i.e. GCD = 2

NOT SUFFICIENT

Statement 2 :x + 26 is a prime number. 
But m is unknown so  NOT SUFFICIENT 
e.g.@x+26=29(Prime), i.e. x=3, and m=2, (x-m) = 1 and (x+m) = 5 i.e. GCD = 1
and @x+26=31(Prime), i.e. x=5, and m=3, (x-m) = 2 and (x+m) = 8 i.e. GCD = 3

Combining the Two statements  
If x+26=(Prime) then x MUST be and ODD number
odd+m(2or8) = ODD
odd-m(2or8) = ODD

i.e. Diffience between (x+m) and (x-m) will be = 2m = 4 or 16
two odd number at the difference of 4 or 16 will always have GCD = 1
i.e.  SUFFICIENT

Answer: Option C

HappyQuakka · Answer

Hi,

I got this question wrong, albeit it took me nearly 5 minutes to do it..
As for Stmt 2, is this a trial and error thing, or is there a number property I am not aware of?

Here's how I approached it:

Stmt 1
M^2 - 10m + 16 = 0
At first, I tried to factor it and realized that I can't - which was a useless attempt - wasted some time here.

Then I solved for m by trial and error, more or less. It was pretty obvious that m was 2, so not much time wasted here.
m^2 - 10m = -16

So I came up with (x+2) & (x-2)
but this is insufficient since when x is 26, it's GCD ( 28, 24) = 4
but when x is 31, it's GCD (33,29) = 1

Stmt 2
x+26 is a prime number.
so potential values for x are (29, 31, 37, 41, 43, 47....) - 4, making it (3, 5, 11, 15, 17, 21...)
Which, by itself, is insufficient because

if m = 5,
when x=11, GCD (16,6) = 2
when x=15, GCD (20, 10) = 10

Stmt 1 + Stmt 2

I made a (quick) table of

x = 3 GCD (5, 1) = 1
x = 5 GCD (7, 3) = 1
x = 11 GCD (13, 9) = 1
x = 15 GCD (17,13) = 1
x = 17 GCD (19, 15) = 1

so I concluded that it's C.

I feel like my trial and error was a little excessive, but I was terrified that I didn't want to be too quick to judge and miss a question I could've gotten wrong

aserghe1 · Answer

Hi  chetan2u ,
For statement 1, how did you determine that the two numbers will be coprime if the two numbers are odd?

tyildirim92 · Answer

Here is the official Veritasprep explanation. https://gmatclub.com/forum/divisibility ... l#p1589618

bumpbot · Answer

Automated notice from GMAT Club BumpBot: 

A member just gave Kudos to this thread, showing it’s still useful. I’ve bumped it to the top so more people can benefit. Feel free to add your own questions or solutions.

 This post was generated automatically.

Given that x is a positive integer, what is the greatest common diviso

Prep Toolkit

Top 5 GMAT Debrief Videos

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards

GMAT Data Sufficiency (DS) Questions

Given that x is a positive integer, what is the greatest common diviso

Prep Toolkit

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards