Given your inclination towards consulting, I would leave out Ross and focus on the other two. Kellogg should be the way to go keeping in mind everything you have mentioned in your post:
1. Consulting: Kellogg is the best MBB feeder among the options you have and sends a ton of people every year to other consulting firms as well - who have their own Kellogg specific hiring teams - in the consulting game, it makes a ton of difference. I would however strongly suggest not being too indexed towards MBB (we all were at some point) but along the way you will realise it’s easier to crack MBB if you do not love them too much 🙂
2. Location: this would be a great time to ask yourself why do your location choices make sense given your professional goals? Kellogg sends a lot of folks into Southern consulting offices and it also has Bay Area presence (I learnt while recruiting for consulting myself) but I would re-think the location preference because Chicago being a melting pot of ops, logistics, healthcare and even some tech and finance offers a diverse mix of industries if you are agnostic about which industry you want to consult in
3. Acads: Kellogg follows a case based approach too, as do any other school I know because HBS created something that works effectively. The difference in Darden and Kellogg acads is Darden is more academically rigorous and indexes much more on class work : you must think whether this is beneficial or an impediment to your professional goals. I found myself struggling for time to manage academics and the quest for consulting interviews. Also, Kellogg gives you the flexibility to choose an academically rigorous experience if you want to
4. Scholarship: I would not make this a deciding factor given the amount. For a future million dollar worth consulting partner 🙂 A good next step for you would be to negotiate your scholarship: see whether you can increase your Darden offer now that you have Kellogg or vice versa. That could be a huge differentiator in the equation.
5. Two cents: Branding matters in the business world 🙂 more than we can start to comprehend
I know this is such a tricky part of your pre-MBA journey but I am confident you are thinking about the right variables to make an informed decision. Consider the above as my perspective, happy to share factual details if they would help
All the best solving the B-school problem and thanks
bb for looping me in!
Posted from my mobile device