If xy + x is a prime number, is xy + x a multiple of 3?

Question

(1) xy = 3
(2) x = 2

M36-56

niks18 · Answer

as  xy+x  is a prime no, so  x  cannot be  0  and only prime that is a multiple of  3  is  3  itself so the question is asking is  xy+x=3

Statement 1 :  xy=3 , add  x  to both sides,  xy+x=3+x

as explained earlier  x  is not equal to  0  so  3+x  cannot be equal to  3 , hence  xy+x  is not a multiple of  3 .  Sufficient

Statement 2 : substitute the value of  x  in question stem to get  2y+2

Now if  y=\frac{1}{2} , then  xy+x=3  and if  y=\frac{3}{2} , then  xy+x=5 . Hence no unique answer.  Insufficient

Option  A

Mo2men · Answer

Bunuel

Is the question correct? or is there any typo?

Statement 1: xy = 3

Let x =1 & y = 3...........xy+x = 3+1= NOT Prime ........condition highlighted failed.

Let x =3 & y = 1...........xy+x = 3+3 = NOT Prime ........condition highlighted failed.

Let x =3/2 & y = 2...........xy+x = 3 +3/2= NOT Prime ........condition highlighted failed.

Let x =3 & y = 3/2...........xy+x = 3/2+2 = NOT Prime ........condition highlighted failed.

Can you elaborate please????

niks18 · Answer

Hi  Mo2men

use x=2 & y=1/2 then you will get xy+x=3=Prime

Mo2men · Answer

Hi  niks18 ,

If I use your example above....then x * y does not equal 3 as per statement 1.

niks18 · Answer

Hi  Mo2men

(xy+x) is prime and not xy so if x=2 & y=1/2, then  2*\frac{1}{2}+2 =1+2=3

Mo2men · Answer

Maybe I can't see something. Can you help me with statement 1 and come up with example that maintain both Statement 1 xy =3 & condition in the stem xy+x = Prime?

niks18 · Answer

Hi  Mo2men 
x=2 & y =3/2, then xy=2*3/2=3=Prime and xy+x=3+2=5=Prime

Mo2men · Answer

Hi niks18 Thanks for bearing with me. I know where I got wrong. I totally missed up my 4th example when asked Bunuel . It seems my brain get burned after some study

kudos to you

Bunuel · Answer

Par of  GMAT CLUB'S New Year's Quantitative Challenge Set

Ypsychotic · Answer

Statement 1) xy=3, If xy+x is a prime number, then 3+x is a prime number and for it to be divisible by 3, x has to be zero because all other prime numbers greater than 3 are not divisible by 3. But x can't be 0 as xy=3. So, xy+x isn't divisible by 3. Sufficient.

Statement 2) x=2. For y=1/2, xy+x=3, divisible by 3. For y=3/2, xy+x=5, not divisible by 3. Insufficient.

Hence, Option A is correct.

UdayPratapSingh · Answer

If xy+x is a prime no. as given in question then we already know that it is not multiple of any other than 1 and itself.
We don't even need any of the two statements to say that. Then why isn't the answer 'D'?

Posted from my mobile device

fitzpratik · Answer

xy+x is a prime number and is it a multiple of 3?

so, as it is a prime number, x(y+1) is a prime number

Now as 3 is a prime number, any prime number which is a multiple of 3 has to be 3.

Now x(y+1) = 3, so X cant be Zero....this is important!

A: xy = 3 and X is not 0, so Xy+ x is not a multiple of 3...............Sufficient

B: x=2 now substitute x= 2, and y as 1 we get xy+y = 3 ........a multiple of 3
 x= 2, and y as 1/2 we get xy+y = 5..........NOT a multiple of 3..........Statement 2 ALONE is insufficient

Kinshook · Answer

Asked: If xy + x is a prime number, is xy + x a multiple of 3?

(1) xy = 3
Since xy+x is a prime number; xy is an integer; x is an integer
x = {0,2,4,8,10.....}
If x = 0; xy + x = 0 is NOT a prime number
For all other values of x; xy+x is NOT a multiple of 3
SUFFICIENT

(2) x = 2
2(y+1) is a prime number
y={0,.5,1.5,...}
For y = .5; xy+x is a multiple of 3
for all other values of y, xy+x is NOT a multiple of 3
NOT SUFFICIENT

IMO A

Bunuel · Answer

Official Solution:

If  xy + x  is a prime number, is  xy + x  a multiple of 3? 
 
There is only one prime which is a multiple of 3, 3 itself. So, the question basically asks whether  xy + x=3 .
 
(1)  xy = 3 
 
The question becomes: does  3+ x=3 ? Or: does  x=0 ? If  x  were 0, then  xy + x  would be 0, which is NOT a prime number as given in the stem. So,  x 
eq 0  and thus  xy + x 
eq 3 . Sufficient.
 
(2)  x = 2 
 
The question becomes: does  2y+ 2=3 ? Or: does  y=\frac{1}{2} ? Well, we don't know that.  y  could be  \frac{1}{2}  but it might as well be some other number making  xy + x  a prime number, for example  \frac{3}{2}  or  \frac{5}{2}  or ... Not sufficient.

Answer: A

bumpbot · Answer

Automated notice from GMAT Club BumpBot: 

A member just gave Kudos to this thread, showing it’s still useful. I’ve bumped it to the top so more people can benefit. Feel free to add your own questions or solutions.

 This post was generated automatically.

If xy + x is a prime number, is xy + x a multiple of 3?

Prep Toolkit

Top 5 GMAT Debrief Videos

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards