Virtually everything astronomers known about objects outside the solar

Question

Virtually everything astronomers known about objects outside the solar system is based on the detection of photons—quanta of electromagnetic radiation. Yet there is another form of radiation that permeates the universe: neutrinos. With (as its name implies) no electric charge, and negligible mass, the neutrino interacts with other particles so rarely that a neutrino can cross the entire universe, even traversing substantial aggregations of matter, without being absorbed or even deflected. Neutrinos can thus escape from regions of space where light and other kinds of electromagnetic radiation are blocked by matter. Furthermore, neutrinos carry with them information about the site and circumstances of their production: therefore, the detection of cosmic neutrinos could provide new information about a wide variety of cosmic phenomena and about the history of the universe.

But how can scientists detect a particle that interacts so infrequently with other matter? Twenty-five years passed between Pauli’s hypothesis that the neutrino existed and its actual detection: since then virtually all research with neutrinos has been with neutrinos created artificially in large particle accelerators and studied under neutrino microscopes.  But a neutrino telescope, capable of detecting cosmic neutrinos, is difficult to construct. No apparatus can detect neutrinos unless it is extremely massive, because great mass is synonymous with huge numbers of nucleons (neutrons and protons), and the more massive the detector, the greater the probability of one of its nucleon’s reacting with a neutrino. In addition, the apparatus must be sufficiently shielded from the interfering effects of other particles.

Fortunately, a group of astrophysicists has proposed a means of detecting cosmic neutrinos by harnessing the mass of the ocean. Named DUMAND, for Deep Underwater Muon and Neutrino Detector, the project calls for placing an array of light sensors at a depth of five kilometers under the ocean surface. The detecting medium is the seawater itself: when a neutrino interacts with a particle in an atom of seawater, the result is a cascade of electrically charged particles and a flash of light that can be detected by the sensors. The five kilometers of seawater above the sensors will shield them from the interfering effects of other high-energy particles raining down through the atmosphere.

The strongest motivation for the DUMAND project is that it will exploit an important source of information about the universe. The extension of astronomy from visible light to radio waves to x-rays and gamma rays never failed to lead to the discovery of unusual objects such as radio galaxies, quasars, and pulsars. Each of these discoveries came as a surprise. Neutrino astronomy will doubtless bring its own share of surprises.   1 
 A 
 1. Which of the following titles best summarizes the passage as a whole?

(A) At the Threshold of Neutrino Astronomy
(B) Neutrinos and the History of the Universe
(C) The Creation and Study of Neutrinos
(D) The DUMAND System and How It Works
(E) The Properties of the Neutrino

2 
 C 
 2. With which of the following statements regarding neutrino astronomy would the author be most likely to agree?

(A) Neutrino astronomy will supersede all present forms of astronomy.
(B) Neutrino astronomy will be abandoned if the DUMAND project fails.
(C) Neutrino astronomy can be expected to lead to major breakthroughs in astronomy.
(D) Neutrino astronomy will disclose phenomena that will be more surprising than past discoveries.
(E) Neutrino astronomy will always be characterized by a large time lag between hypothesis and experimental confirmation.

3 
 A 
 3. In the last paragraph, the author describes the development of astronomy in order to

(A) suggest that the potential findings of neutrino astronomy can be seen as part of a series of astronomical successes
(B) illustrate the role of surprise in scientific discovery
(C) demonstrate the effectiveness of the DUMAND apparatus in detecting neutrinos
(D) name some cosmic phenomena that neutrino astronomy will illuminate
(E) contrast the motivation of earlier astronomers with that of the astrophysicists working on the DUMAND project

4 
 D 
 4. According to the passage, one advantage that neutrinos have for studies in astronomy is that they

(A) have been detected for the last twenty-five years
(B) possess a variable electric charge
(C) are usually extremely massive
(D) carry information about their history with them
(E) are very similar to other electromagnetic particles

5 
 E 
 5. According to the passage, the primary use of the apparatus mentioned in lines 24-32 would be to

(A) increase the mass of a neutrino
(B) interpret the information neutrinos carry with them
(C) study the internal structure of a neutrino
(D) see neutrinos in distant regions of space
(E) detect the presence of cosmic neutrinos

6 
 A 
 6. The passage states that interactions between neutrinos and other matter are

(A) rare
(B) artificial
(C) undetectable
(D) unpredictable
(E) hazardous

7 
 E 
 7. The passage mentions which of the following as a reason that neutrinos are hard to detect?

(A) Their pervasiveness in the universe
(B) Their ability to escape from different regions of space
(C) Their inability to penetrate dense matter
(D) The similarity of their structure to that of nucleons
(E) The infrequency of their interaction with other matter

8 
 D 
 8. According to the passage, the interaction of a neutrino with other matter can produce

(A) particles that are neutral and massive
(B) a form of radiation that permeates the universe
(C) inaccurate information about the site and circumstances of the neutrino’s production
(D) charged particles and light
(E) a situation in which light and other forms of electromagnetic radiation are blocked

9 
 C 
 9. According to the passage, one of the methods used to establish the properties of neutrinos was

(A) detection of photons
(B) observation of the interaction of neutrinos with gamma rays
(C) observation of neutrinos that were artificially created
(D) measurement of neutrinos that interacted with particles of seawater
(E) experiments with electromagnetic radiation

benguy · Accepted Answer

Virtually everything astronomers known about objects outside the solar system is based on the detection of photons—quanta of electromagnetic radiation. Yet there is another form of radiation that permeates the universe: neutrinos. With (as its name implies) no electric charge, and negligible mass, the neutrino interacts with other particles so rarely that a neutrino can cross the entire universe, even traversing substantial aggregations of matter, without being absorbed or even deflected. Neutrinos can thus escape from regions of space where light and other kinds of electromagnetic radiation are blocked by matter. Furthermore, neutrinos carry with them information about the site and circumstances of their production: therefore, the detection of cosmic neutrinos could provide new information about a wide variety of cosmic phenomena and about the history of the universe.

But how can scientists detect a particle that interacts so infrequently with other matter? Twenty-five years passed between Pauli’s hypothesis that the neutrino existed and its actual detection: since then virtually all research with neutrinos has been with neutrinos created artificially in large particle accelerators and studied under neutrino microscopes. But a neutrino telescope, capable of detecting cosmic neutrinos, is difficult to construct. No apparatus can detect neutrinos unless it is extremely massive, because great mass is synonymous with huge numbers of nucleons (neutrons and protons), and the more massive the detector, the greater the probability of one of its nucleon’s reacting with a neutrino. In addition, the apparatus must be sufficiently shielded from the interfering effects of other particles.

Fortunately, a group of astrophysicists has proposed a means of detecting cosmic neutrinos by harnessing the mass of the ocean. Named DUMAND, for Deep Underwater Muon and Neutrino Detector, the project calls for placing an array of light sensors at a depth of five kilometers under the ocean surface. The detecting medium is the seawater itself: when a neutrino interacts with a particle in an atom of seawater, the result is a cascade of electrically charged particles and a flash of light that can be detected by the sensors. The five kilometers of seawater above the sensors will shield them from the interfering effects of other high-energy particles raining down through the atmosphere.

The strongest motivation for the DUMAND project is that it will exploit an important source of information about the universe. The extension of astronomy from visible light to radio waves to x-rays and gamma rays never failed to lead to the discovery of unusual objects such as radio galaxies, quasars, and pulsars. Each of these discoveries came as a surprise. Neutrino astronomy will doubtless bring its own share of surprises.  1. Which of the following titles best summarizes the passage as a whole?
(A) At the Threshold of Neutrino Astronomy
(B) Neutrinos and the History of the Universe
(C) The Creation and Study of Neutrinos
 the passage is not about creation of Neutrino, but about detecting neutrino  
(D) The DUMAND System and How It Works
 it is the one that best summerizes the passage 
(E) The Properties of the Neutrino
 nothing about properties of neutrino 
 A

2. With which of the following statements regarding neutrino astronomy would the author be most likely to agree?
(A) Neutrino astronomy will supersede all present forms of astronomy.
(B) Neutrino astronomy will be abandoned if the DUMAND project fails.
 (C) Neutrino astronomy can be expected to lead to major breakthroughs in astronomy.
the detection of cosmic neutrinos could provide new information about a wide variety of cosmic phenomena and about the history of the universe
therefore, its expected to lead to major breakthroughs in astronomy 
(D) Neutrino astronomy will disclose phenomena that will be more surprising than past discoveries.
(E) Neutrino astronomy will always be characterized by a large time lag between hypothesis and experimental confirmation.
 C

3. In the last paragraph, the author describes the development of astronomy in order to
(A) suggest that the potential findings of neutrino astronomy can be seen as part of a series of astronomical successes
 Neutrino astronomy will doubtless bring its own share of surprises 
correct!

(B) illustrate the role of surprise in scientific discovery
(C) demonstrate the effectiveness of the DUMAND apparatus in detecting neutrinos
(D) name some cosmic phenomena that neutrino astronomy will illuminate
(E) contrast the motivation of earlier astronomers with that of the astrophysicists working on the DUMAND project
 A

4. According to the passage, one advantage that neutrinos have for studies in astronomy is that they
(A) have been detected for the last twenty-five years
(B) possess a variable electric charge
(C) are usually extremely massive
(D) carry information about their history with them
 neutrinos carry with them information about the site and circumstances of their production 
correct!

(E) are very similar to other electromagnetic particles
 D

5. According to the passage, the primary use of the apparatus mentioned in lines 24-32 would be to
(A) increase the mass of a neutrino
(B) interpret the information neutrinos carry with them
(C) study the internal structure of a neutrino
(D) see neutrinos in distant regions of space
(E) detect the presence of cosmic neutrinos
 No apparatus can detect neutrinos unless it is extremely massive 
correct!
 E

6. The passage states that interactions between neutrinos and other matter are
(A) rare
 the neutrino interacts with other particles so rarely that a neutrino can cross the entire universe... 
(B) artificial
(C) undetectable
(D) unpredictable
(E) hazardous
 A

7. The passage mentions which of the following as a reason that neutrinos are hard to detect?
(A) Their pervasiveness in the universe
(B) Their ability to escape from different regions of space
(C) Their inability to penetrate dense matter
(D) The similarity of their structure to that of nucleons
(E) The infrequency of their interaction with other matter
 the neutrino interacts with other particles so rarely that a neutrino can cross the entire universe., even traversing substantial aggregations of matter, without being absorbed or even deflected. .

a particle that interacts so infrequently with other matter?  
 E

8. According to the passage, the interaction of a neutrino with other matter can produce
(A) particles that are neutral and massive
(B) a form of radiation that permeates the universe
(C) inaccurate information about the site and circumstances of the neutrino’s production
(D) charged particles and light
 when a neutrino interacts with a particle in an atom of seawater, the result is a cascade of electrically charged particles and a flash of light

(E) a situation in which light and other forms of electromagnetic radiation are blocked
 D

9. According to the passage, one of the methods used to establish the properties of neutrinos was
(A) detection of photons
(B) observation of the interaction of neutrinos with gamma rays
(C) observation of neutrinos that were artificially created
 since then virtually all research with neutrinos has been with neutrinos created artificially

(D) measurement of neutrinos that interacted with particles of seawater
(E) experiments with electromagnetic radiation
 C

Praetorian · Answer

i dont think there is a lot of "history of the universe" in this passage.

Read the first few lines of the passage.

Virtually everything astronomers known about objects 
outside the solar system is based on the detection of 
photons-quanta of electromagnetic radiation.  Yet there 
is another form of radiation that permeates the universe: 
(5) neutrinos. 

Its starts off by saying, virtually everything... and then introduces neutrinos...and then the entire passage is devoted to how neutrinos can be useful..

I hope this helps. If you read it once again, i am sure you will see the error in choosing B. I am quite sure the answer is A, but let me know if you disagree. we can discuss it.

Just a note about your error log.

This is a good candidate for your error log. just make a note for yourself saying... the first paragraph gives the most important clue about the title...of course you have to study the answer choices for choosing the right answer. 

The more you practice RC's , the more closer you will get to a clearly defined strategy for yourself. Make notes for every mistake you make. no matter how boring this sounds, if you maintain this discipline, you might see a difference. Go over your log every time you start your prep.

Sincerely
Praet

anandnk · Answer

I aced this passage. I eliminated B for the first one because the Author does not mention about the history of the universe in the entire scope. I liked the word threshold because already Neutrinos can be detected and that itself is a major breakthrough ( mentioned in the begining of the second paragraph )

took 5 minutes

1.A
2.C
3.A
4.D
5.E

Dharmin · Answer

Correct praet, Thanks for reply. I accord you and i have taken this as a note, ofcourse to personal rc-log

Dharmin

icandy · Answer

I am signing up. Just like the good old ad, am egg a day keeps the doctor away, 3 RC's a day gets you closer to the GMAT target.

Here is what I got.

I feel that passages as long as this one are atypical of GMAT.

How much time do you think is good enough for this passage?

Any ways, if this is LSAT stuff, its good to do because it makes GMAT RC easier.

B T W, I took a guess on Q 5, which had line numbers mentioned in Q and the Q did not have the appropriate lines underlined. I hope I am right on that.

B,C,A,D,E,A,E,D,C

I was really torn on the first Q and spent a lot of time. Nothing made sense to me. By POE I arrived at B.

Now lets get to the OA's/OE's and discussion.

nitya34 · Answer

Now since I know how the Real Qs look like ..promise you all that I will try to post GMAT-like RCs(theme wise-astronomy,archaeology,paleontology,World War II, Climate Change, paintings etc) this one is not from LSAT category Q 1 was most difficult to guess.I got 5/9 right.Poor I must say

I believe one can take 2 Mins/Qs..say 16-18 Mins for this 9 Q passage(becoz its not a tough passage) with practice, we should bring done the time taken/passage every 10-20 seconds we save will help us in CR/SC will post the OAs soon

ritula · Answer

Threshold means "The starting point for a new state or experience"

In the passage, it has been stated that scientists have proposed the concept of neutrinos. here is the line
 "Fortunately, a group of astrophysicists has proposed a means of detecting cosmic neutrinos by harnessing the mass of the ocean"  
Also the passage concludes with "Neutrino astronomy will doubtless bring its own share of surprises". Hence the name "At the threshold of N A" is most suitable.

scthakur · Answer

By POE, I also had to choose from option A and B and finally chose option B. However, after seeing the OA, A does make sense.

The passage does not talk about History of universe with respect to Nutrino. In fact, it explains hos Nutrino Astronomy and expects surprises. Hence, an answer choice with "Nutrono Astronomy" will be the most correct answer. Here, between A and B, A contains this.

castrocmc · Answer

8/9 17 Min. I feel this one had many questions that were Specific to the passage type...no Main Idea, what did the author mean, etc

2. I missed...I had it down to C and E and went with E based on the understanding that the passage said it was discovered 25 years ago but with no real testing. So I interpreted the answer choice but I guess the answer choice is relative.

3. Was tricky and was down to A and C...but after POE I went with A

aniketm.87@gmail.com · Answer

Can someone pls explain the OA for Q3 ?

3. In the last paragraph, the author describes the development of astronomy in order to 
(A) suggest that the potential findings of neutrino astronomy can be seen as part of a series of astronomical successes
(B) illustrate the role of surprise in scientific discovery 
(C) demonstrate the effectiveness of the DUMAND apparatus in detecting neutrinos
(D) name some cosmic phenomena that neutrino astronomy will illuminate 
(E) contrast the motivation of earlier astronomers with that of the astrophysicists working on the DUMAND project

I marked it as B)

Thanks in advance

PS : This is the only Q i got wrong (solved it under 6 mins)

meetmba91 · Answer

Can any one provide the explanation for the first problem. I choose C - The study and creation of Neutrinos. First paragraph provides the details of the Neutrinos with its introduction. Second talks about the artificial creation of Neutrinos. Why is this not the answer? Why A?

abhimahna · Answer

Notice that all over the passage the author is trying to convey the importance of Neutrinos and the difficulties they are facing in detecting them. Then the author says if we are able to find a way to detect it, we will be able to see many more surprises.

Only Option A is as per the Passage.

Nightmare007 · Answer

11 min 8 seconds

1 incorrect .

Last one got wrong- but knew the answer from : "since then virtually all research with neutrinos has been with neutrinos created artificially in large particle accelerators "
D mentions process for detection not helpful for studying properties. according to passage.

jawele · Answer

Total 7 minutes

1. Which of the following titles best summarizes the passage as a whole?
(A) At the Threshold of Neutrino Astronomy -> correct, the passage talks about some details of neutrinos, including why neutrinos are important, how to detect them and the project involved in their detection.
(B) Neutrinos and the History of the Universe -> wrong, there's only a small detail about the history of the universe that is mentioned
(C) The Creation and Study of Neutrinos ->wrong, the passage doesn't speak about the creation of neutrinos
(D) The DUMAND System and How It Works -> wrong, mentioned as a detailed in the last paragraph
(E) The Properties of the Neutrino -> wrong, discussed only in the first paragraph

2. With which of the following statements regarding neutrino astronomy would the author be most likely to agree?
(A) Neutrino astronomy will supersede all present forms of astronomy. -> there's no such claim
(B) Neutrino astronomy will be abandoned if the DUMAND project fails. -> there's no such claim
(C) Neutrino astronomy can be expected to lead to major breakthroughs in astronomy. -> correct, "Neutrino astronomy will doubtless bring its own share of surprises."
(D) Neutrino astronomy will disclose phenomena that will be more surprising than past discoveries. -> there's no such distinction made
(E) Neutrino astronomy will always be characterized by a large time lag between hypothesis and experimental confirmation. -> may be true, but not mentioned

3. In the last paragraph, the author describes the development of astronomy in order to 
(A) suggest that the potential findings of neutrino astronomy can be seen as part of a series of astronomical successes -> correct, "The extension of astronomy from visible light to radio waves to x-rays and gamma rays never failed to lead to the discovery of unusual objects such as radio galaxies, quasars, and pulsars. Each of these discoveries came as a surprise. Neutrino astronomy will doubtless bring its own share of surprises."
(B) illustrate the role of surprise in scientific discovery -> wrong, findings from the study of neutrinos are likely to cause surprise
(C) demonstrate the effectiveness of the DUMAND apparatus in detecting neutrinos -> wrong, the effectiveness is not discussed
(D) name some cosmic phenomena that neutrino astronomy will illuminate -> it is said that findings will bring a share of surprises, but it is not said what specific phenomena it will reveal
(E) contrast the motivation of earlier astronomers with that of the astrophysicists working on the DUMAND project -> no mention of this

4. According to the passage, one advantage that neutrinos have for studies in astronomy is that they 
(A) have been detected for the last twenty-five years -> wrong, "Twenty-five years passed between Pauli's hypothesis that the neutrino existed and its actual detection"
(B) possess a variable electric charge -> on the contrary, they have no electric charge
(C) are usually extremely massive -> on the contrary, they are of negligible mass and their detection apparatus would have to be massive
(D) carry information about their history with them -> correct, "Furthermore, neutrinos carry with them information about the site and circumstances of their production: therefore, the detection of cosmic neutrinos could provide new information about a wide variety of cosmic phenomena and about the history of the universe."
(E) are very similar to other electromagnetic particles -> only electromagnetic radiation is mentioned

5. According to the passage, the primary use of the apparatus mentioned in the highlighted portion would be to 
(A) increase the mass of a neutrino -> wrong
(B) interpret the information neutrinos carry with them -> wrong
(C) study the internal structure of a neutrino -> wrong
(D) see neutrinos in distant regions of space -> wrong
(E) detect the presence of cosmic neutrinos -> "But a neutrino telescope, capable of detecting cosmic neutrinos, is difficult to construct."

pjthatsme318 · Answer

Why is the answer to 3 A and not B
Similarly C and not D to 8

Sajjad1994 · Answer

Hello dear

Both of these questions are of medium difficulty levels. In question number three the intent of the author is to know the main idea of the last paragraph. You just have to identify the main idea of these 3-4 lines. B is never near even. The world  surprise  is used here just to highlight that the method will lead to more and more knowledge and discoveries and there is no any other use of the word it is used to show the value of the method DUMAND. If you think B should be the answer then your basics are not good and you need to work hard on RC section.

For the question #8 the answer is given in the second last paragraph in the lines:

The detecting medium is the seawater itself: when a neutrino interacts with a particle in an atom of seawater, the result is a cascade of electrically charged particles and a flash of light that can be detected by the sensors.

Hope it helps

LauraChen310 · Answer

Can someone explain why #9 is C instead of D?

9. According to the passage, one of the methods used to establish the properties of neutrinos was
(A) detection of photons
(B) observation of the interaction of neutrinos with gamma rays
(C) observation of neutrinos that were artificially created
since then virtually all research with neutrinos has been with neutrinos created artificially

(D) measurement of neutrinos that interacted with particles of seawater
(E) experiments with electromagnetic radiation

bM22 · Answer

Hi  LauraChen310 ,

Lines: "Twenty-five years passed between Pauli’s hypothesis that the neutrino existed and its actual detection:  since then virtually all research with neutrinos has been with neutrinos created artificially in large particle accelerators and studied under neutrino microscopes . "

Option C can be directly inferred from the above lines.

What we can infer from the project DUMAND is that it is a recent project for the detection of neutrinos in seawater. Since it's a recent and ongoing method, it will be too soon to say that this was one of the methods used to establish the properties of neutrinos. Thus C is the better answer.

Hope This Helps.
Thanks.

woohoo921 · Answer

Sajjad1994 
Thank you for your helpful reply. For question 7, I was confused because both answer choices B and E seem to be mentioned:
"the neutrino interacts with other particles so rarely that a neutrino can cross the entire universe, even traversing substantial aggregations of matter, without being absorbed or even deflected. Neutrinos can thus escape from regions of space where light and other kinds of electromagnetic radiation are blocked by matter"

I realize that Choice E seems more specific because it is first mentioned, but also saying "neutrinos can thus" seems to also include Choice B.

Thank you for your insights in advance.

Virtually everything astronomers known about objects outside the solar

Prep Toolkit

Top 5 GMAT Debrief Videos

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards

GMAT Reading Comprehension (RC) Questions

Virtually everything astronomers known about objects outside the solar

Prep Toolkit

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards