GMAT Club

Susan McInerny Reviews

Company: mbaMission

HBS MBA and Yale admissions interviewer with 30 years of investment banking, private equity, consulting, and nonprofit experience. I completed my BA in economics and political science at Yale (for which I have been an admissions interviewer since I graduated) and my MBA at Harvard Business School. Over the past 30 years, I’ve been fortunate to work in investment banking at Morgan Stanley in New York and Los Angeles, in private equity in California, in consulting with BCG, and in the nonprofit sector to advance issues I am passionate about, including education and workforce development (with organizations such as DonorsChoose and Jobs for the Future). I’ve also had the privilege of leading collaboration, conversation, and curated counsel for private communities of Fortune 100 C-suite executives through my work at World 50. This variety of experiences has provided me with a great deal of perspective on the unique and dynamic nature of work and leadership in many industries, insight that I use to help candidates tell compelling stories about where they’ve been and where they want to go—especially when that may involve transitions across sectors.

5.0 /5 Average Rating
Based on 30 reviews
April 13, 2026
commodifuga

Joined: Jan 21, 2026

Posts: 0

Kudos: 0

A+

REVIEWER IDENTITY VERIFIED by school email address [?]

Susan McInerny surpassed my expectations in all ways and I recommend her without qualification. So as to not bury the lede – I only applied to Wharton's executive MBA program, I was accepted, and I am certain that Susan's prudent guidance meaningfully improved my chances.

I first considered pursuing an executive MBA in early 2025. In the course of my research, I came upon mbaMission. Recalling the many, many hours I invested in applying to law school—and now having a far busier schedule such that I wouldn't have those hours—I was eager to lean on a professional's guidance. Susan answered my questions, was not sales-y, and clearly explained the cost structure and what to expect if I decided to hire her.

Two months later, I hired Susan who, thereafter, consistently outpaced her own self-imposed deadlines in the process. With her guidance, I went from a general notion of wanting to attend business school for career advancement to a finely-honed personal story that would not only show the "best me" in my application but clarified my own aimed-for trajectory.

Being aware of my own idiosyncrasies, I appreciated how she calibrated to my personality and work style. What's more, I dare say Susan became a friend throughout the process.

Looking back, hiring Susan will likely prove to be one of the best investments I've ever made.

Read More

verify-zero-posts
This reviewer has not participated on GMAT Club but it is a REAL person and a REAL review. GMAT Club has verified this test-taker's identity through GMAC/Pearson Vue Score Reporting system or .edu email address and confirmed that this reviewer indeed took the GMAT, is unique, and has not submitted multiple reviews.
March 30, 2026
mcmeggz

Joined: Mar 30, 2026

Posts: 0

Kudos: 0

I can't recommend Susan McInerny highly enough!!

REVIEWER IDENTITY VERIFIED by score report [?]

Susan was absolutely instrumental in my business school application journey. Her essay edits and thoughtful feedback helped me clearly articulate my story while making my applications stronger and more compelling. She has an incredible ability to identify what makes your experiences unique and help you communicate them in a way that resonates with admissions committees while still feeling authentic to your voice.

She also provided fantastic interview prep materials and guidance that gave me so much confidence going into each interview.

Susan was always responsive and took the time to answer my many questions - whether about schools, the application process, or the GMAT. Throughout the entire process, she was thoughtful, encouraging, and incredibly knowledgeable. Applying to business school can feel overwhelming, but Susan’s structured approach and steady guidance made the experience far more manageable.

I am so grateful to have had Susan's support throughout this process. I truly believe I could not have done it without her and I cannot recommend her highly enough to anyone navigating the business school application process!

Read More

February 22, 2026
KarenSChi

Joined: Feb 01, 2025

Posts: 0

Kudos: 0

An Amazing MBA Consultant and True Partner

REVIEWER IDENTITY VERIFIED by waiver or admit report [?]

I cannot recommend Susan highly enough. She was an incredible partner throughout my entire MBA application process, and I truly don’t think I would have been admitted to my top choice school without her guidance and support.

Susan is patient, thoughtful, and an excellent listener. She has a rare ability to pull meaningful insights from small details and help craft them into a clear, compelling narrative. She was not only invaluable with my essays, but also helped me think critically about my future goals during a time when my career direction felt unclear.

She supported me through every part of the process — essays, interviews, video submissions, deferral updates, and scholarship negotiation — and was always extremely responsive and a pleasure to work with. What once felt like a confusing black box became a clear and manageable journey thanks to Susan. I am deeply grateful for her support and would strongly encourage anyone considering an MBA consultant to work with her.

Read More

January 24, 2026
Kavya2024

Joined: Jan 11, 2021

Posts: 34

Kudos: 13

Verified GMAT Focus score:
695 Q86 V85 DI83

She Helped Me Achieve What I Thought Was Impossible

REVIEWER IDENTITY VERIFIED by score report [?]

When I began my MBA journey, several consultants told me that as an Indian male engineer — one of the most overrepresented demographics — my odds at any M7 were slim. Susan saw it differently. She believed I had a decent shot and gave me honest feedback on exactly what to work on.

The result? I applied to three M7 schools through Susan and was admitted to two — including Wharton, my dream school.
Working with Susan exceeded my expectations significantly. I enjoyed the process, learned a lot about myself, and we deep-dived into every aspect of my application to make it the best it could be. I've already recommended her to my brothers and friends who've asked how I got into an M7 as an overrepresented candidate. If you're wondering whether it's possible — it is. With the right guidance.

Read More

January 05, 2026
kmr71997

Joined: Jan 05, 2026

Posts: 0

Kudos: 0

Best investment I've ever made!

REVIEWER IDENTITY VERIFIED by score report [?]

I worked with Susan through her full school package and applied to six Round 1 MBA programs. I was accepted to several top programs, including an M7 school—and I can say with total confidence that none of this would have happened without her.

Susan’s support went far beyond essays. She helped me navigate major career decisions, handle a challenging situation with a new boss, and shape a clear, authentic story and set of career goals I’m genuinely proud of. She has an incredible instinct for knowing exactly what you need in the moment—whether that’s tough love, encouragement, or perspective.

What truly sets Susan apart is that she made this entire process not just manageable, but genuinely enjoyable. I looked forward to every call with her. This was the best investment I’ve ever made, and I know Susan will remain a mentor and friend for years to come.

Read More

October 21, 2025
as9601

Joined: Jul 18, 2023

Posts: 0

Kudos: 0

Amazing consultant and mentor!

REVIEWER IDENTITY VERIFIED by score report [?]

I loved working with Susan and truly would not have gotten into my dream school without her. As an international applicant with a consulting background and below average test scores, I knew I needed to find other ways to stand out. Susan helped me do exactly that – guiding me through thoughtful brainstorming, sharpening my essays, and even connecting me with a GRE tutor to boost my score.

What stood out most was her positivity and calmness – she was always quick to respond and made time for me whenever I needed guidance. Susan made the entire journey feel less stressful and overwhelming. Even though I purchased the two-school package, she went the extra mile to make sure my other applications were on track.

Thanks to her guidance, I was ultimately accepted into my dream M7 school. Susan is a true mentor and partner throughout the application process. Highly recommend!

Read More

June 04, 2025
snleon

Joined: Mar 31, 2024

Posts: 6

Kudos: 0

Excellent Service!!

REVIEWER IDENTITY VERIFIED by gmat club tests [?]

Susan McInerny has deep expertise in the application process, especially when it comes to interviews. I used her interview service, and it was incredibly helpful. The mock interview with her helped me understand the rhythm, the tone, and the type of questions I could expect. Her years of experience gave me the confidence to walk into my actual interview and nail it—I got into Harvard! I was definitely stressed, but she guided me to focus on what truly mattered. Her support made all the difference. If you're preparing for an interview, working with her is totally worth it.

Read More

April 19, 2025
rloh

Joined: Nov 30, 2023

Posts: 1

Kudos: 0

Susan is amazing!!!

REVIEWER IDENTITY VERIFIED by score report [?]

I cannot speak highly enough of Susan. With her support and expertise, I was accepted into all the schools I applied to! Her wisdom, mentorship, and guidance made the application process so smooth and enjoyable.

I decided to work with her after meeting with a multitude of admission consultants. She was the only one who gave me tangible and impactful advice during my complimentary consultation. Also, I could tell she genuinely cared about my overall success. Not only did Susan show her deep knowledge of navigating the MBA process, but she also was the kindest and nicest consultant I met.

I am beyond thankful for the opportunity to work with Susan! She helped me craft a meaningful and real story when writing essays. Susan gave me valuable advice when reviewing various aspects of my application portfolio. With her feedback, I was able to confidently submit my applications. She made the entire process stress free and fun! I truly feel blessed!

I definitely recommend Susan to anyone looking for an MBA consultant! She will truly make your life better when applying!

Read More

April 16, 2025
erl1311415

Joined: Aug 05, 2024

Posts: 0

Kudos: 0

Highly Recommend

REVIEWER IDENTITY VERIFIED by school email address [?]

Susan is an all-star: she is whip smart, an expert in her field, and an emotionally attuned cheerleader for what can be a very taxing process. I got into every school I applied to, including Harvard, Stanford, and Wharton, a homerun outcome for which Susan deserves a lot of credit. Susan is generous and flexible with her time; even as an hourly client, I knew she was in my corner and available when I needed her. She is the best in the business -- I am so glad I chose to work with her and now consider her a friend. I highly recommend that you do the same!

Read More

verify-zero-posts
This reviewer has not participated on GMAT Club but it is a REAL person and a REAL review. GMAT Club has verified this test-taker's identity through GMAC/Pearson Vue Score Reporting system or .edu email address and confirmed that this reviewer indeed took the GMAT, is unique, and has not submitted multiple reviews.
April 16, 2025
nicolecmele

Joined: Aug 26, 2024

Posts: 0

Kudos: 0

MBA Admissions- worth every penny

REVIEWER IDENTITY VERIFIED by score report [?]

Working with Susan was hands down one of the best decisions I made during the MBA application process. She wasn’t just an advisor—she was a true mentor, confidante, and champion from day one. Susan brought a unique blend of warmth, candor, and strategic insight that made me feel fully supported at every step, and her guidance played a pivotal role in helping me gain admission to Columbia Business School. Her ability to help you uncover your authentic story and frame it in a way that resonates with top programs is unmatched. With her incredible career experience across sectors and her genuine investment in your success, Susan brings a perspective and level of care that’s incredibly rare. Even after hitting “submit,” she remained a steady source of encouragement and advice, showing just how much she cares about her clients beyond the application. If you have the chance to work with Susan—take it. You’ll walk away with not only a stronger application, but a lifelong mentor and friend.

Read More