Bunuel
12 Days of Christmas 2024 - 2025 Competition with $40,000 of PrizesThe 400 students at Watermelon Sugar High School can choose up to 3 electives from the following classes: an art class, a business class, and a computer class. Half of the students chose the art class, half of the students chose the business class, and half of the students chose the computer class.
If 96 of the students have signed up for all three electives, select from the available options the least possible and greatest possible number of students who could have signed up for exactly two of the three electives. Make only two selections, one in each column.
Manhattan Prep Official Explanation:
Step 1: Understand the Prompt and Question
Glance at the answers. There are a lot of clues that this is a Quant-based question, such as the numbers in the answers and the column headings of
Least and
Greatest. The question stem clarifies that these are the least and greatest
possible number of students who could have signed up for exactly two of the three electives, which makes this an
Overlapping Sets question.
Read the prompt and jot down the given information on your scratch paper.
400 students, up to 3 elects
classes: A, B, C
1⁄2 took A, 1⁄2 took B, 1⁄2 took C
96 took A + B + C
Least/Greatest taking 2 of 3?
Step 2: Plan your ApproachOn overlapping sets questions with just two categories, the double set matrix works. But this is one that has three: the three possible classes. Thus, the double set matrix won’t work here. With this kind of overlapping sets problem, an algebraic solution is often effective. Further, because this question is asking for the least and greatest possible values, it will be possible to
Work Backwards here.
Regardless of the approach, the key to solving this problem will be reconciling the difference between the total number of students (400) and the total number of enrollments. Since half of the students (200) take each of the three electives, there are a total of 600 enrollments to account for among only 400 students.
Step 3: Solve the Problem
The number of students who take three electives is given, so the variables in play are the number of students who take zero, one, or two electives. The number of enrollments is also given, so consider how to minimize and how to maximize the number of students taking two electives by adjusting the numbers of students taking zero or one elective.
AlgebraUse
w,
x,
y, and
z to represent the number of students who take zero, one, two or three electives, respectively. Note that
y is the one whose least and greatest possible values are needed. There are two equations that relate these variables, one for students and one for enrollments.
The following is the equation for the number of students:
400 =
w +
x +
y +
z400 =
w +
x +
y + 96
304 =
w +
x +
yThe following is the equation for the number of enrollments. Remember that each student
y takes two courses and that each student
z takes three courses:
600 =
x + 2
y + 3
z600 =
x + 2
y + 3(96)
600 =
x + 2
y + 288
312 =
x + 2
ySubtract the first equation from the second, then rearrange to isolate the needed variable,
y:
312 =
x + 2
y − 304 = w + x + y 8 =
y −
w y = 8 +
wThis final equation shows that the number of students who take two electives is 8 greater than the number of students who take zero. Thus,
y is minimized when
w equals 0, and the least possible value for
y is 8.
Rearrange the enrollments equation from above (because this equation relates
y to just one other variable,
x) to solve for
y:
312 =
x + 2
y2
y = 312 −
xy = 156 − (
x ÷ 2)
According to this equation,
y is maximized when
x = 0. Thus, the greatest possible value of
y is 156.
The correct answer is
8 for the first column and
156 for the second column.
Work BackwardsOn almost all questions that require finding a least or a greatest possible value, the answer choices are a great resource. Starting with the smallest value among the answer choices, test them in increasing order. The first one that works is the least possible value. A similar process can be used to find the greatest possible value: start with the greatest value among the answer choices and test them in decreasing order. The first one that works is the greatest value.
Does 0 work? If 0 students take two electives, then all of the enrollments are accounted for by the students who take three electives or one elective. The 96 students who take three electives account for 96(3) = 288 of the enrollments, so the other 600 − 288 = 312 must be accounted for by students taking one elective each, but that requires a total of 312 + 96 = 408 students. That’s too many!
Does 8 work? If 8 students take two electives, then they account for 16 enrollments. In addition to the 288 enrollments already accounted for by the students who take all three electives, this covers 288 + 16 = 304 enrollments. This leaves 400 − 96 − 8 = 296 students and 600 − 304 = 296 enrollments. This works if all 296 of those students take one elective! Thus, 8 is the least possible number of students who take two electives.
Starting from the greatest number listed, does 304 work? If 304 students take two electives, that’s 304(2) = 608 enrollments. That’s more than the total without even considering the students who take three enrollments.
Does 156 work? If 156 students take two electives each, that’s 156(2) = 312 enrollments. Combined with the 288 enrollments from the 96 students who take three electives each, that’s 312 + 288 = 600 enrollments. That’s the target number of enrollments. If no students take one elective and the rest take zero electives, this number works. Thus, the greatest possible number of students who take two enrollments is 156.
The correct answer is
8 for the first column and
156 for the second column.