arjun221199
can someone explain how is option E not relevant? if there is oil released...it could be responsible for the pollution right?
and in option D we don't know anything about the tankers...
1) wether the tankers were going by road?
2) wether the tankers spilt inside the ocean or just on road not affecting the ocean
3) more importantly it is not given that it is the tanker for the given company... then how can we say that the company is responsible.....
E seems to be a better choice... if such plants release the chemicals... i don't need to know it is the only company..... just that it contributes to the pollution which is supported by option E.
Please advise
GMATNinja Two things about (E)
1. Stem says: not undermined by the finding that
none of Gaston Inc.’s oil plants in the Southern Ocean had
any oil spills
E says: sometimes deliberately discarded by oil plants
Doesn't (E) oppose the premise?
2. E says: oil are
sometimes deliberately discarded by oil plants: How do you know that Gaston Inc. is among those oil plants? Now, you may say the same about (D).
But notice the weak word ''
sometimes'' and a better stronger word ''
often'' in (D)