prince00113
Booker awards are not merely about who wins the coveted literary prize, an annual honor that bestows instant celebrity status and a windfall in terms of book sales. They are also about such things as who deserved to win, why someone lost and whether someone else was unfairly overlooked - issues that become the stuff of intense literary brawls, vicious backbiting on occasion - but always engaging.
Which of the following weakens the assessment made in the above argument?
A. The Nobel Prize for literature brings with it more acclaim, honor and recognition than the Booker Prize.
B. Whenever any literary award is announced, it is usual for the people in the field the world over to raise controversies, most of which are unjustified
C. There have been some years, including the year in which Arundati Roy was chosen for the award, when there was universal approval of the choices.
D. This year's Booker Prize for the novel 'The Line of Beauty' has raised a controversy that it is not better than another entry 'Cloud Atlas'.
E. Literature is a field where one would think the practitioners have risen well over petty squabbles and criticisms.
Please give Kudos if you liked the question !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Difficult..IMO, OA is C
A. The Nobel Prize for literature brings with it more acclaim, honor and recognition than the Booker Prize.
-> Nobel Prize is out of scope.
B. Whenever any literary award is announced, it is usual for the people in the field the world over to raise controversies, most of which are unjustified
-> Not weaken. The argument said '
vicious backbiting on occasion'. So B is just true.
C. There have been some years, including the year in which Arundati Roy was chosen for the award, when there was universal approval of the choices.
=> I chose this. Because of the work '
universal approval of the choices'.
D. This year's Booker Prize for the novel 'The Line of Beauty' has raised a controversy that it is not better than another entry 'Cloud Atlas'.
-> Same as B
E. Literature is a field where one would think the practitioners have risen well over petty squabbles and criticisms.
-> Similar as B
I cannot assure these reasonings are correct..I hope these reasonings can helpful..