Tracy95
Dear
GMATNinja EMPOWERgmatVerbal I have concern over the use of "many times as rare as" and "many times more rare than". I hope you could help enlighten me.
As far as I know, it's okay to say "this road is three times as long as that road". Thus I think it's also okay to say "leopards are many times as rare as pandas".
So either "many times more rare than" or "many times as rare as" is grammartically correct. Is my thinking correct?
Thank you
Hi
Tracy95!
You are correct that using the phrases "as rare as" or "as long as" are grammatically correct.
However, they are not ALWAYS correct. It depends on what the meaning you're trying to convey.
The phrases "as rare as" or "as long as" are ONLY used to say that the 2 items are the same. If you're trying to say the 2 items are different, you cannot us "as many as" or "as long as."
So for this question, here is what we're dealing with:
"many times as rare as" =
WRONG (The phrase "as rare as" would mean the 2 items are the same, but we start with "many times," which is a clue that the 2 items are not the same level of rare.)
"many times more rare than" =
CORRECT (The phrase "more rare than" makes it clear to readers that the 2 items are different - one of them is many times MORE rare than the other.)
As for your other example:
As far as I know, it's okay to say "this road is three times as long as that road".NO, this is not grammatically correct. If you say that there is a 3x difference between the two roads, you CANNOT use "as long as." Remember - "as X as Y" only works if the 2 items are the same - and these two roads are different lengths. You must say "This road is three times longer than that road."
I hope that helps clear things up!