csaluja
Hi GMATNinja, could you please explain why option D is correct for Q5? I chose option B instead.
No problem, let's start with the question itself:
Quote:
5. According to the passage, the scholars mentioned in the highlighted text assert which of the following about the growth of participatory democracy within a particular nation?
This is a wordy way of asking, "Which choice matches what the
scholars say about the growth of participatory democracy?" The phrase "within a particular nation" is a bit of a weird choice, but it's just another way of saying "within any given nation."
Here's what the passage attributes to these
scholars:
"Many scholars have theorized that economic development, particularly industrialization and urbanization, contributes to the growth of participatory democracy; according to this theory, it would seem logical that women would both demand and gain suffrage in ever greater numbers whenever economic development expanded their economic opportunities."
We know that the author spends the rest of the passage picking apart what these scholars have theorized, using several different nations as examples. But the question doesn't asks us what the author says. The question asks us what the
scholars say. And given what we've just read in the passage, the answer seems straightforward:
The scholars assert that industrialization and urbanization contribute to the growth of participatory democracy.Let's look for the choice that matches and eliminate the choices that don't:
Quote:
A. It is not necessarily correlated with increasing income and opportunities for women in that nation.
This is actually closer to the opposite of what the scholars say ("according to this theory, it would seem logical that women would both demand and gain suffrage in ever greater numbers whenever economic development expanded their economic opportunities"). Eliminate (A).
Quote:
B. It is not necessarily related to the implementation of women's suffrage within that nation.
There's no information in the passage to support whether the highlighted scholars make this fine-grain distinction between participatory democracy and women's suffrage (i.e., women's right to vote). Remember, we're looking for the choice that matches
what the scholars say, not what the author or anyone else says. So let's eliminate (B), too.
Quote:
C. It cannot adequately explain the nation's level of economic development.
As with (B), this choice isn't supported by the passage. The only thing that we really know about the
scholars is that they've theorized that economic development contributes to the growth of participatory democracy. There's no mention of their beliefs regarding whether the growth of participatory democracy explains economic development. Eliminate (C).
Quote:
D. It tends to be encouraged by the occurrence of industrialization in that nation.
Great! The
scholars think that industrialization and urbanization contribute to the growth of participatory democracy, and choice (D) says almost exactly the same thing. Let's keep (D) around and check up on the last choice.
Quote:
E. It is to increase with the growth of leftist parties in that nation.
This potential association shows up in the author's observations at the end of the passage, but it doesn't at all match what the
scholars say. Eliminate (E).
That's why (D) is the only choice supported by the passage, and why (B) -- not to mention every other choice -- is wrong. I hope this helps!