Hi. Just because the system doesn’t work with one of the questions, it doesn’t mean it’s a bad system.
I would just point out and say some thing I’ve learned over the years and basically the fact is, patterns and systems and convenient rules don’t work well with hard GMAT questions. That’s what makes them hard
Similarly if you use the approach of answering the question in your own words before attempting a critical reasoning question, it works really well on easy and medium questions. However it will not work on hard critical reasoning questions most of the time.
Anyway, that’s why Hard GMAT Questions are hard 🤷♂️ It’s a very unsatisfying answer but there is another side to this answer. You will need a different approach for hard questions which most likely will be sort of like brute force combined with gut feel and subtle hints. That’s the best recommendation I have for you for the hard critical reasoning questions. They just don’t fit the patterns.
PS. But if this question is hard for you, you should print it out and save it and review it every few days until you know every single word and every single nuance of this question. Imagine a similar question would show up on your GMAT would not it be nice to be able to answer it?
Posted from my mobile device