Profile Evaluation

Question

Demographic - Indian Female.
Education: BFIA from SSCBS( 8.2 CGPA), MA Econ DSE (6.8)
GMAT - 710 (Expired now, can retake for better score)

Work experience: 2 years of Full-time Work experience as an Analytics Consultant at Big 4, received fast track promotion

Previous offers: Received an ISB YLP admit during undergrad

Internships: IIM, 2 Big 4s (received PPOs both times)

Post MBA Goals: Product Management/Strategy Consulting/Impact Finance

Key concerns: Potential impact of gap year for government exams, very low marks in Masters

Is an M7/T15 viable for me?

Thanks in advance!

admitStreet · Answer

tsaha25 - some thoughts and clarifications: 1. The undergrad GPA is fine, but the masters score isn't ideal, as you've noted. Have there been alum from your undergrad/ Masters at M7/ T15? Some precedence can help. Also, any reason why you didn't apply to top US Deferred MBA programs, alongside your ISB YLP application? 2. The big-4 brand and fast-track promotion are strong angles, but your work-ex is on the lower side for most MBA programs (key stats here ). Having said that, a strong score (ideally a GFE 705+) can help compensate to an extent. M7's would still be tricky, given the competitive pool - refer here for key stats and class-profiles at M7 MBA programs. 3. Your post-MBA goals need more clarity and brainstorming. Selecting/ prioritizing schools can be made easier once there's directional clarity here. I'd also suggest expanding the mix to include some US T15-25, if you're particularly keen on applying this year. A deepdive of my candidate's success journey with lower-than-average work-ex who got into a US T20 program is here. If you're looking at applying next year, which can improve odds (particularly at UST15, in my view) my Profile Building Program could be of help. Hope this helps a bit. Feel free to reach out if you'd like to have a deeper chat. Regards, Arvind Founder, admitStreet | Request a free chat W: https://admitstreet.com | E: consultingteam@admitstreet.com | LinkedIn

CrackAdmission · Answer

Hello @ tsaha25 ,

While the gap year wont be such a big concern as long as you can justify some personal development endeavours during that time, low post grad scores and relatively less work experience are more critical areas of concern.

Realistically speaking to get a competitive shot at M7, I will recommend gaining one more year of professional experience, getting a score in excess of 685+ (GMAT FE) and diversifying your profile to areas beyond just the realm of core professional work and take up some outside work leadership initiatives.

T15-T20 on the other hand is of course less competitive but you can apply this year as well. However, getting a 665+ score in GMAT FE and showcasing a side of you beyond your work at Big 4 is imperative for a strong application.

Feel free to reach out if you seek professional guidance.

Cheers and Best of Luck !!

MBAandBeyond · Answer

Hey, @  tsaha25

Given your profile, aiming for an M7/T15 MBA is viable, though addressing certain areas is crucial. Your strong educational background, with a BFIA from SSCBS, internships at IIM and top consulting firms, and ISB YLP admission, showcases solid academic and practical experience. Your professional achievements, including two years as an analytics consultant with a fast-track promotion, further highlight your potential.

However, the gap year for government exams and low MA marks are concerning. To mitigate these, retake the GMAT and aim for a higher score. Clearly explain the gap year in your essays, focusing on constructive activities and personal growth. Emphasize your fast-track promotion and quantify your impact in your current role to demonstrate capability.

Strong letters of recommendation, a compelling narrative tying your past experiences to your post-MBA goals, and highlighting any significant extracurriculars will strengthen your application. Target a mix of M7 and T15 schools, focusing on those with strengths in your areas of interest. With these strategic enhancements, you can present a competitive application to top MBA programs.

Let’s talk

If you have any further questions related to your profile or want to have a 1:1 discussion with our top profile experts,  feel free to schedule a complimentary profile evaluations session with our experts  . We match you with the students and alums of top B-Schools according to your background and target schools.

TheRedPen · Answer

Hi  tsaha25 ,

Your profile seems sound, however, an MBA abroad typically requires 3-5 years of work experience to stand a better chance. In your case, your big 4 (brand name) and fast-tracked promotion can be a strong point in your narratives.

Our MBA experts can be better positioned to discuss your profile in length and help you make the right choices. You can  schedule a complimentary call  with the team or connect directly at +91 7780769732.

shivshambhu441 · Answer

Profile evaluation for Rotman and top European Business schools:
10th- 90%
12th – 90% 
Btech- 68% (Tier II College)
GMAT- 760
Work Experience:
Working as a Gp ‘B’ Officer in Ministry of Defence, Government of India for ~ 8 years.
Handling General Management and HR related work of around 2000 employees all over India
Work Achievements:
Fastest and youngest to be Awarded commendation from the Head of Office.
Overhaul of Defence Medical Depots relating to their manpower management issues and medical stores.
Active participation in the ‘Mission Recruitment Mode’ of the Government of India where total 10 lakh vacancies have been filled in less than 1 yr.
Prepared the Transfer Policy for the Defence Civilians under MoD for the first time.
Worked as an officer in Conducting the Lok Sabha Elections of India in 2019 and 2024.
Worked as a coordinator overseeing the arrangements for the republic day parade in 2024.
Work also involved Liaisoning with PMO, Ministry of Finance, Ministry of law etc
Extra Curricular Activities:
Worked as volunteer for CRY Foundation and Hindustan times campaign in my college days. Worked in the slums of Delhi and got various students admitted to government schools by convincing their parents and children alike, which included a divorced girl. 
Quora writer with around 3.5 lakh content views till date. Answer questions on Government jobs, GMAT, etc
Part of Musical Club during college.

Pls provide genuine review, feedback and your take on chances for admission in Rotman and the top European B schools.

MBAandBeyond · Answer

Hello,  shivshambhu441

Your strong profile makes you a competitive candidate for Rotman and top European business schools. Academically, your 10th and 12th grades are excellent, your B.Tech score of 68% is on the lower side, and your exceptional GMAT score of 760 compensates for this.

Your substantial work experience involves significant management and HR responsibilities, and you demonstrate strong leadership, project management, and strategic planning skills.

Your extracurricular activities, including volunteer work and participation in a musical club during college, highlight your well-rounded personality. While your undergraduate GPA could be improved, your GMAT score helps offset this, and any international projects or collaborations would further enhance your application. Your chances for admission to Rotman and top European business schools are strong, given your high GMAT score, significant work experience with notable achievements, and impactful extracurricular activities. To strengthen your application, highlight your leadership, strategic impact, and unique experiences in your essays, secure strong letters of recommendation, and prepare thoroughly for interviews.

Connect for a detailed analysis t o have a 1:1 discussion with our top profile experts.

Click here to connect for a detailed profile analysis  . We match you with the students and alums of top B-schools according to your background and target schools.

Profile Evaluation

Prep Toolkit

Top 5 GMAT Debrief Videos

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards