Quote:
The birth rate in Country X is down this year by 12% compared to last year. The death rate in Country X has remained stable for several years. Therefore, the population of Country X is decreasing measurably.
Visualizing the problem: Conclusion : Population of Country X is decreasing measurably. why?
Because, Birth rate this year dropped by 12% compared to last year while death rate has remained stable for several years.
For, suppose :
Births------------------Deaths----------------------Total Population= present population(say 100)+ births - deaths
176(12% less)---------20--------------------------100+176-20=256 (Current year)
200(assume)-----------20--------------------------100+200-20= 280 (Last year)
In the above scenario, population did decrease. But, we are not considering any influx of population of from outside countries. If there is influx of migrants, then the author's conclusion will break.
So, author assumed that there is no influx of population from other countries.
Which of the following is assumed by the author of the argument above?Quote:
(A) The causes of the declining birthrate in Country X can be discovered through physician surveys.
The cause of the decline in birth rate really does not matter. It does not effect the conclusion.
Quote:
(B) Statisticians are able to predict future changes in the size of the population of Country X.
Let's say statisticians did predict future changes. is this change increase or decrease? We don't know. And knowing the statisticians predictions wont help us with the conclusion.
(C)
Quote:
Country Y, which has a nearly identical population to Country X, is experiencing the same population shift as Country X.
Out of scope. The topic of discussion is country X only. The passage does not provide us any link between country X and country Y.
Quote:
(D) There was no significant migration into Country X during the time under discussion.
Correct.
Quote:
(E) The causes of the declining birthrate in Country X are primarily economic in nature.
The cause is not the matter of discussion.