If x, y, and z are all distinct positive integers and the percent

Question

If x, y, and z are all distinct positive integers and the percent increase from x to y is equal to the percent increase from y to z, what is x?

(1) y is prime

(2) z = 9

Bunuel · Accepted Answer

If x, y, and z are all distinct positive integers and the percent increase from x to y is equal to the percent increase from y to z, what is x?

The percent increase from x to y is equal to the percent increase from y to z: \(\frac{(y-x)}{x}*100 = \frac{(z-y)}{y}*100\) --> \(xz = y^2\) (\(0 < x < y < z\))

(1) y is prime:

y = 2, then \(xz = 4\), and since \(0 < x < y < z\) and all of them are positive integers, then x = 1 and z = 4.
y = 3, then \(xz = 9\), and since \(0 < x < y < z\) and all of them are positive integers, then x = 1 and z = 9.
y = 5, then \(xz = 25\), and since \(0 < x < y < z\) and all of them are positive integers, then x = 1 and z = 25.
y = 7, then \(xz = 49\), and since \(0 < x < y < z\) and all of them are positive integers, then x = 1 and z = 49.
...

We can see a pattern there, in all cases x = 1. Sufficient.

(2) z = 9 --> \(9x = y^2\). Case 1: x = 1 and y = 3; case 2: x = 4 and y = 6. Not sufficient.

Answer: A.

chetan2u · Answer

Hi..

I would simplify for myself by taking same % increase as multiplication by same number

Although Q becomes a bit easier with finding value of x, I'll answer it if say we were to find value of y as it would be a bit more challenging.
For finding x as the Q presently states, statement I is sufficient as shown below. x will always be 1.
A

Say we were to find value of y 
1) y is prime..
Starting with 1, I can find various combinations.
Say y is 2.... 1, 1*2, 2*2......1,2,4
Say y is 3.....1, 1*3, 3*3...... 1,3,9
Say y is 5......1,1*5,5*5.....1,5,25
Insufficient 
2) z=9
Possible values..
1,3,9.....1,1*3,3*3
4,6,9....4,4*(1.5),6*(1.5)
Two possible ways..
Insuff

Combined..
ONLY 1,3,9 remains.
Sufficient

C

gmat_for_life · Answer

Hello Bunuel,

I couldnt understand why (0<x<y<z). We could have selected the values of x,y and z as 4,2 and 1 or 9,3 and 1. The percentage changes for the above 2 cases would be negative but the changes would be equal. It was based on these 2 different sets that I ruled out option A as a possibility.

Could you please suggest where I might be going wring?

Regards,
Amit

chetan2u · Answer

hi anit,

the Q stem talks of % increase - "the percent increase from x to y", so we cannot take % decrease by taking x>y>z....

gmat_for_life · Answer

Oh right! My mistake! thanks a lot Chetan!

rohit8865 · Answer

simplifying the stem 
as percent increase from x to y is equal to the percent increase from y to z

(y-x)/x = (z-y)/y
y^2-xy = xz-xy
y^2 = xz-------(given in stem)
so x=??

(1) if y =3
then x=1,z=9 or x=9 ,z=1
Not suff

(2) no info of other integers
clearly insuff..

Combined
z=9 and y is prime then,

y^2= x*9
as 9 = 3^2 = Prime ^2, then for x,any value but 1 leaves y not anymore a prime number
rather x=1 leaves y =3
i.e Y^2(3^2) = x(1) * 9(z)
thus x=1,y=3 ,z=9
suff

Ans C

sahilkak007@gmail.com 
Please confirm OA

swapnilvar · Answer

Wrong;
Y= %increase* x= prime
Prime= no. itself * 1
Comparing both, since x and y are distinct, x can only be 1, hence statement 1 is sufficient

rekhabishop · Answer

Great approach, Bunuel I have learnt so much from you!! :shock:

shmba · Answer

(y-x)/x=(z-y)/y >> y^2=x*z 1. if y is prime, y^2 has only 3 factors 1,y,y^2. since x

energetics · Answer

+int x<y<z
Let a% = some % increase
a%*x = y 
a%*y = z

(1) y is prime  
Say y is 2, and a is 100%
If x = 1, then y is 2 and z is 4, this works.

Say y is 3, and a is 100%
x would have to be 1.5 for y to be 3, this is not possible due to int constraint.

Say y is 3 and a is 50%
Then x could be 2, and a 50% increase gives us y=3
BUT, 50% increase of 3 gives z=4.5, which is again not possible.

We can conclude that the only way to get the same percent increase and to maintain all int values is if x starts at 1. Sufficient. 
This makes sense because only 1 is a multiple of every number so essentially 1*y=y and then y^2 = z. This works for many cases but only if x=1.

(2) z = 9 
Say a is 200%, If x = 1 then y could be 3 and z could be 9
Say a is 50%, If x = 4 then y could be 6 and z could be 9
Not sufficient.

vijay282001 · Answer

Another way to solve A
let's say a is the percentage increase,
y = x(100+a)/100
since y is prime, so either x is 1 or (100 + a)/100 = 1,
(100 + a)/100 = 1 can't be true because it will yield a = 0 and x, y and z are unique, so x is equal to 1

Palladin · Answer

Question says percentage increase from  x  to  y  and from  y  to  z  is the same.
Few solutions say that, hence,  0<x<y<z .

I cannot completely agree.

If  x=4 ,  y=2  and  z=1 , where  0<z<y<x ,
Percentage increase from  x  to  y  =  (\frac{(2-4)}{4}) * 100  =  -50\% 
Percentage increase from  y  to  z  =  (\frac{(1-2)}{2}) * 100  =  -50\%

So,  0<x<y<z  may not always hold.
I can however conclusively say  x , y  and  z  are in ascending or descending order.

Percentage increase can be negative too, can it not?

kajaldaryani46 · Answer

————————- Could you please link similar Qs below for further practice? Bunuel Thank you!

Posted from my mobile device

bumpbot · Answer

Automated notice from GMAT Club BumpBot: 

A member just gave Kudos to this thread, showing it’s still useful. I’ve bumped it to the top so more people can benefit. Feel free to add your own questions or solutions.

 This post was generated automatically.

If x, y, and z are all distinct positive integers and the percent

Prep Toolkit

Top 5 GMAT Debrief Videos

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards

GMAT Data Sufficiency (DS) Questions

If x, y, and z are all distinct positive integers and the percent

Prep Toolkit

615 to 715 in 15 Days (Ria's Strategies)

More than Quant/Verbal Abilities: Speed vs. Accuracy

745 with Only Self-Prep and GMAT Club

From 555 to 765: 210-point Improvement

Perfect 805 Score Debrief by Julia

My Rewards