Unlike X, Y
X= emergency calls
Y= cellular calls
A- Wrong because of the usage of "they"
B- Correct
C- Wrong, Parrellisme issue : travel // informing
D- Wrong, remember Unlike X, Y : in this option, we are comparing "emergency calls" and "emergency operators"
E- Wrong, same issue in C and D

So, the correct answer should be B

Hi,

In A - 'where they ' is incorrect usage
Sentence starts with 'Unlike emergency calls', so comparison should be with 'cellular calls'.
In C the comparison is with location of a caller
In D and E, the comparison is with emergency operators.

So, B should be the right answer.

Regds
Sony
_________________

Unlike emergency calls that travel through regular telephone lines, where they thus automatically inform the operator of the location and phone number of the caller, cellular calls require emergency operators to determine the location of the caller.


In the para emergency calls should be compare with "some sort of calls" i.e. after second comma there should be noun (for some type of calls)

Thus makes C,D and E out

Now in A "they" creating a confusion for anteceedent which is clear in B

So my take B

We are comparing emergency calls with cellular calls...So only option B seems correct.

Does the usage of "where" correct here!
pls advise
_________________

Unlike emergency calls that travel through regular telephone lines, where they thus automatically inform the operator of the location and phone number of the caller, cellular calls require emergency operators to determine the location of the caller.

A. lines, where they thus automatically inform the operator of the location and phone number of the caller, cellular calls require emergency operators to determine the location of the caller -- usage of where is incorrect

B. lines and thus automatically inform the operator of the location and phone number of the caller, cellular calls require emergency operators to determine the location of the caller - Correct

C. lines, thus automatically informing the operator of the location and phone number of the caller, the location of a caller on a cellular phone has to be determined by the operator- Emergency calls and location of a caller are not parallel

D. lines, and thus automatically inform the operator of the location and phone number of the caller, emergency operators have to determine the location of the cellular phone caller- Emergency calls and emergency operators are not parallel

E. lines, thus automatically informing the operator of the location and phone number of the caller, emergency operators receiving a cellular call have to determine the location of the caller - same as D

Answer B
_________________

Skywalker18
isn't the use of they ambiguous in A

inform is better than informed and option d and e has parallelism error so b is correct option.

Unlike emergency calls that travel through regular telephone lines, where they thus automatically inform the operator of the location and phone number of the caller, cellular calls require emergency operators to determine the location of the caller.

A. lines, where they thus automatically inform the operator of the location and phone number of the caller, cellular calls require emergency operators to determine the location of the caller - Wong because "where" is used to describe a thing and can only be used to describe a place, "and" adding they is poor grammar in this situation.

B. lines and thus automatically inform the operator of the location and phone number of the caller, cellular calls require emergency operators to determine the location of the caller - Better, it maintains the structure of "Unlike this, that" and lines up Emergency calls and Cellular calls

C. lines, thus automatically informing the operator of the location and phone number of the caller, the location of a caller on a cellular phone has to be determined by the operator - Biggest problem here is that we've changed to "UNLIKE emergency calls, cellular calls" to "UNLIKE emergency calls, the location". No longer making an apt comparison.

D. lines, and thus automatically inform the operator of the location and phone number of the caller, emergency operators have to determine the location of the cellular phone caller - and thus would mean in addition too, rather than result of. Also "UNLIKE emergency calls, emergency operators" is wrong.

E. lines, thus automatically informing the operator of the location and phone number of the caller, emergency operators receiving a cellular call have to determine the location of the caller - again wrong "UNLIKE emergency calls, emergency operators".

Can someone please confirm this thought below?
generally all of them are also incorrect (except B) because if you do "1st-noun clause1a, thus clause1b, 2nd-noun" you are incorrectly attributing clause1a to noun2.

Hello from the GMAT Club VerbalBot!

Thanks to another GMAT Club member, I have just discovered this valuable topic, yet it had no discussion for over a year. I am now bumping it up - doing my job. I think you may find it valuable (esp those replies with Kudos).

Want to see all other topics I dig out? Follow me (click follow button on profile). You will receive a summary of all topics I bump in your profile area as well as via email.
_________________