Information given:- Elephants in an experiment spend more time at an enclosure containing a distressed calf from their own herd vs. a different herd or an empty pen
- Conclusion: elephants are more motivated to care for members of their herd than for other elephants
Question:- The zoologist's argument would be most strengthened if it were true that, in the experiment, the elephants led to the enclosures tended to spend more time at the enclosures when
Solution:- A: They were encouraged by a familiar zookeeper than when they were encouraged by an unfamiliar zookeeper
- No link to calves or motivation to help herd members
- Does not strengthen argument
- B: The enclosure was empty than when the enclosure contained a distressed calf from a different herd
- Suggests the distressed calf from a different herd might be less interesting than an empty pen
- Does not strengthen argument
- C: Distressed calf from the elephants’ herd was in the enclosure than when a distressed calf from the elephants’ herd was visible but outside the enclosure
- Shows the time spent in enclosure is not just due to seeing the calf, but rather actively approaching to care for it
- Suggests behavior (time spent) is motivated by concern, not just curiosity
- Strengthens the argument
- D: A distressed calf in the enclosure appeared interested in the approaching elephants than when the calf ignored them
- This is about the calf's behavior, not the adult elephant's motivation
- Does not strengthen the argument
- E: a distressed calf from a different herd appeared friendly toward elephants than when a distressed calf from a different herd displayed hostility
- Suggests behavior of the different herd calf can very, but the argument is about the elephants' motivation to care for their own
- Does not strengthen the argument
Answer: C, a distressed calf from the elephants’ herd was in the enclosure than when a distressed calf from the elephants’ herd was visible but outside the enclosureBunuel
Zoologist: As part of an experiment, several mature elephants were led to three enclosures- one that contained a distressed calf from the elephant’s herd, one that contained a distressed calf from a different herd, and one that was empty. It was observed that in the majority of cases, the elephants spent more time at enclosures with the calf from their herd than they did at enclosures with the calf from a different herd. This suggests that elephants are more motivated to care for members of their herd than for other elephants.
The zoologist's argument would be most strengthened if it were true that, in the experiment, the elephants led to the enclosures tended to spend more time at the enclosures when
A. they were encouraged by a familiar zookeeper than when they were encouraged by an unfamiliar zookeeper
B. the enclosure was empty than when the enclosure contained a distressed calf from a different herd
C. a distressed calf from the elephants’ herd was in the enclosure than when a distressed calf from the elephants’ herd was visible but outside the enclosure
D. a distressed calf in the enclosure appeared interested in the approaching elephants than when the calf ignored them
E. a distressed calf from a different herd appeared friendly toward elephants than when a distressed calf from a different herd displayed hostility